If ever a movie exemplified the paradox of expectation, it is “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2.” With the first “Guardians of the Galaxy,” Disney/Marvel proved it could build a billion-dollar franchise around a cast of relatively obscure characters that only a subset of dedicated comic readers were familiar with.
There was something liberating about low expectations back in 2014. “Guardians” Vol. 1 stunned audiences by feeling vaguely subversive despite its nearly $200 million budget. It was funny, genuinely heartfelt and blessed with a nostalgia-triggering soundtrack that only the most misanthropic baby boomer could resist.
It was as if writer/director James Gunn was on a mission to make fun of other Marvel movies for taking themselves too seriously. It was crazy space-opera, vibrant colors and cosmic lunacy. It was fizz, bubble gum and permission to check your brain and your wallet at the door. It was so adorable it had a license to print money on every continent it landed on.
‘Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2’

Starring: Chris Pratt, Zoe Saldana, Dave Bautista.
Rating: PG-13 for sequences of sci-fi action and violence, language, and brief suggestive content.
If the original movie had merely recouped its production and advertising costs and turned a modest profit, Marvel/Disney would’ve been ecstatic. After all, what else could one expect from a film about dysfunctional cosmic misfits who look like Saturday morning cartoons compared to mainstays of the Marvel Cinematic Universe such as Iron Man, Thor and Captain America?
But what could very easily have been a one-off experiment in tone-shifting for the MCU juggernaut became a formula once box office receipts started rolling into Disney Corporate. A sequel with an even bigger budget and wilder CGI was inevitable.
With “Guardians Vol. 2,” writer Gunn is back in the director’s chair, and the weight of expectation is the opposite of what it was a few years ago. This movie is expected to make well over a billion dollars worldwide, and it will do that easily. It has all of the elements of the first outing, minus the surprise, the freshness and the low expectations, of course.
The movie, arriving in theaters Thursday, opens with the courtship of Star-Lord’s mother, Meredith Quill (Laura Haddock), and a mysterious man who calls himself Ego (Kurt Russell) 34 years ago on Earth. Running minutes before the film’s opening credit sequence, this beautifully shot vignette establishes Peter Quill/Star-Lord’s (Chris Pratt) parentage and the logic behind the film’s primary conflict.
Fast forward three decades and one ELO song later, we come across our mercenary heroes Star-Lord, Gamora (Zoe Saldana), Drax (Dave Bautista), Rocket (voiced by Bradley Cooper) and Baby Groot (voiced by Vin Diesel) dispatching a troublesome alien monster on behalf of a technologically advanced golden-skinned race of elitists called the Sovereign.
In exchange for doing the dirty work of killing the creature, Gamora’s estranged sister Nebula (Karen Gillan), who was a prisoner of the Sovereign, is released to the Guardians’ custody. This sets up the deadly sibling rivalry between the two that has only intensified since the first “Guardians.”
Meanwhile, the impetuous Rocket Raccoon has gone out of his way to antagonize the Sovereign by stealing the very objects they had been hired to protect. This leads to a cosmic chase sequence that bears a very purposeful resemblance to what one would’ve seen in an ’80s-era video arcade.
Just when it appears that the Guardians are cornered and outgunned, the Sovereign’s high-tech drone armada is wiped out. Still, the Guardians’ starship is so badly damaged that it crash lands on the nearest habitable planet. The heroes are soon joined by Ego, the man from the first scene, and Mantis (Pom Klementieff), his servant.
Once Peter discovers that the mysterious Ego is his long-lost and unidentified father, the movie’s earnest exploration of his unresolved daddy issues begins. We soon learn that Ego is a cosmic being with a back story that stretches back billions of years. Ego claims he has been pursuing his son across the galaxy for decades.
Ego had gone to the trouble of hiring a mercenary named Yondu (Michael Rooker) to grab Peter from Earth the second his mother died. Instead of returning to Ego’s world with the child, Yondu kept the boy and raised him among the Ravagers, a ragtag coalition of interstellar thieves, pirates and scoundrels.
Yondu is Peter’s “abusive” father, so they have their own issues that surface more than once in this film. Their dysfunctional relationship adds to the poignance of what happens near the end when Peter has to make a profound choice about what kind of existence he wants to live.
While Peter is struggling with the legacy of two less-than-ideal fathers, Drax and Mantis, two beings who personify awkwardness, empathy and bluntness have their own uneasy moments. Gamora and Nebula also fight it out until they realize how dumb their deadly rivalry is. Rocket and Yondu have a revelatory moment of mutual understanding, as well. The only one who appears to be drama-free is Baby Groot, who toddles innocently between impending disasters.
“Guardians” Vol. 2 is filled with sight gags and loads of rehashed jokes that already felt perilously close to stale in the first movie. Where the soundtrack was effervescent the first time out, it feels oppressive this time around because it is so self-consciously gimmicky. Mr. Gunn basically doubled down on all the stuff that worked in the first film, but that cut the enjoyment quotient of the film by half.
Still, this is a hard film to hate. It has too many visual delights to be dismissed so easily. It has intriguing concepts, including Ego’s search for meaning through a scheme to remake the universe in his image. Why Ego reveals a bit of information to Star-Lord about his mother’s death makes no sense because it would likely set them at odds. But logic goes out the window in nearly every scene of this beautifully shot but overstuffed film.
If this movie has a theme, it is about the power of “family” even when that family consists of space-faring misfits. The Guardians originally came together as mercenary associates who grew into something more than opportunists protecting each other’s backs.
A true act of cinematic subversion after the shock of the first outing would’ve been for Mr. Gunn to reduce the scale of the sequel to something more intimate. Audiences would’ve enjoyed something less bombastic and emotionally didactic if he had dared to do it. Going “small” without all of the technicolor explosions would’ve produced the richer, deeper, more complex blockbuster one senses he was aiming for. Instead, he’s put together a film that is visually engaging but not particularly interesting.
Still, Mr. Gunn has the consolation of knowing he has produced another billion-dollar hit for Disney/Marvel. Intimate films such as those he did prior to the “Guardians” franchise can wait. He’s already thinking about the third installment and the introduction of another beloved Marvel character hinted at in one of the film’s five end credits.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.