If the George Zimmerman trial taught us anything, it taught us that justice can be a crapshoot, especially in Florida. If a defendant has a clever lawyer, Florida’s permissive “stand your ground” law can be used as a defense for almost anything.

The shooting death of Trayvon Martin was still a waking nightmare for many African-Americans when Michael Dunn, a middle-aged white man, shot and killed 17-year-old Jordan Davis at a gas station in Jacksonville on Black Friday, 2012.

Dunn shot the unarmed black teenager as he sat in an adjacent SUV with three friends listening to music. Dunn claimed that he “feared for his life” after Jordan allegedly cursed him after he asked the teens to turn down their music.

At his trial, Dunn claimed that he reached for his gun only after he was convinced he was moments away from being shot by the teen, whom he insisted was armed with a shotgun or some other weapon.

Advertise with us

'3½ Minutes, Ten Bullets'

Ratings explained

Rating: No MPAA rating; contains profane language.

Although no other gun was found at the scene, the defendant claimed Florida law was on his side because merely feeling threatened justified a lethal response under state law.

Director Marc Silver wades into the drama and high emotions that surrounded Jordan’s killing in “3½ Minutes, Ten Bullets,” a documentary about the shooting, the subsequent trial and the pernicious influence of “stand your ground” laws in Florida.

Advertise with us

Using archival trial footage laced with fresh interviews with Jordan’s grieving parents who doted on him and his best friends who were with him the night he was killed, Mr. Silver pulls together a compelling portrait of a charismatic teenager reduced to a menacing stereotype by an irresponsible man with anger issues and a gun.

The viewer knows the outcome of the trial because of the heavy coverage it received in the wake of the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman case, but Mr. Silver is able to make the documentary suspenseful by reminding us that the guilty verdict was far from foreordained at the time. Dunn had a very good defense attorney who did his best to paint Jordan Davis and his friends as the “aggressors” for playing loud music and creating an atmosphere of menace in which his client reasonably felt threatened.

The police interview video of Dunn is particularly damning, showing a man with a proclivity for lying and saying stuff he believes the police want to hear. His recorded phone calls from prison show an angry man who wanted to portray himself as a peaceful citizen who refused to be victimized by thugs. What initially looks like a winning strategy a la Zimmerman begins to fall apart as witnesses, including Dunn’s fiancee, take the stand and tell the unadorned truth. Dunn’s whining, self-pitying creepiness comes fully into view as a result.

Mr. Silver does an excellent job humanizing Jordan Davis by including flattering and unflattering aspects of his personality, too. As even the prosecutor acknowledged in his closing argument, Jordan was a kid with a “big mouth” who, nevertheless didn’t deserve to die because he was in a car blasting rap music.

“3½ Minutes, Ten Bullets” is an insightful and morally robust documentary that will generate much needed discussion about criminal justice and the true intent of “stand your ground” laws in a multiracial society where crime continues to drop even as fear and access to guns continues to rise.

Advertise with us

The documentary screens at 6 p.m. today at Carnegie Mellon University’s McConomy Auditorium as a preview for CMU’s film festival March 17-April 3. Tickets, $10; $5 students. See www.cmu.edu/faces.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.