Two weeks ago, a newspaper in a small North Dakota town published a review of a new Italian restaurant. Within days, the story went viral, leading to thousands of comments on Twitter, more than a million page views of the original review, follow-up reports from every major media outlet, and a New York City media trip for the critic, including visits to several of the city's top restaurants.

I'm referring, of course, to Marilyn Hagerty's review of the Olive Garden, published in the Grand Forks Herald on March 7. The tone of the commentary was mixed: Some mocked the very idea that anyone would need the Olive Garden explained to them, while others found the piece refreshing in an age of obsessive restaurant worship.

But the explosive reaction to such a straightforward, mild-mannered review suggests that the Olive Garden is emblematic of a greater culinary divide. It embodies the qualities that many people find distasteful in chain restaurants: huge portions, bland Americanization of one of the world's great cuisines and the trite (and ubiquitous) advertisements. Yet it's one of America's most popular and successful restaurant chains, serving millions of meals a year.

Rather than asking why Ms. Hagerty reviewed it, we could just as easily ask why more restaurant critics don't. Why do critics in larger cities routinely ignore the country's most popular restaurant? Don't these restaurants influence American tastes as much as independent dining spots?

Advertise with us

Not so many years ago, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette critics regularly reviewed new chains coming to town, just as Ms. Hagerty still does. When the pace of independent restaurant openings picked up, we mostly stopped, with a few exceptions. I reviewed the Capital Grill in 2007 and Munch reviewed Noodles & Company early this year.

Readers occasionally have asked me why I don't review chains. I usually responded with some version of the following: Chain restaurants are inexpensive and centrally located, so people have an easier time finding out about them on their own. It would be impossible to review a chain fairly, because how would you choose which location to review? Local, independent restaurants are better for the community. All restaurants provide jobs and pay taxes, but a larger portion of money spent at independent restaurants stays in the local economy.

These are reasonable answers, but they are not completely honest ones. The first, and perhaps most significant, is the choice that critics make in deciding which restaurant to review. Critics want to review the dining establishments that matter, and in our minds, chains don't matter. Independent restaurants, particularly those owned by local chefs, drive trends, promote creativity and take risks. Food, we are arguing, is like fashion and architecture. When practiced at a basic level they are skills, but at the highest levels they become art.

That's not to say that every independent restaurant offers food and service superior to every chain. It's more that comparing chain and independent restaurants would be like comparing a specialty spice shop with a large grocery store -- they have such different purposes that they barely belong in the same category.

That difference at least partly explains what many people found so funny about Ms. Hagerty's review in the first place. People who live in larger cities aren't used to reading straightforward reviews of chain restaurants (though Yelp is full of them) and Ms. Hagerty's succinct, deadpan style made the review a little too easy to mistake for a piece from the online humor publication, The Onion.

Advertise with us

Chain restaurants aren't exactly suffering for lack of attention from reviewers. According to the market research company The NPD Group, U.S. restaurant visits declined by 2.1 billion between 2008 and 2011 and independent restaurants accounted for "87 percent [about 1.8 billion] of these traffic losses." In 2011, there were 4,511 more chain locations and 7,158 fewer independent restaurants than there were in 2008.

I suspect those numbers speak more to the differences between chains and independents than they do to their similarities. Chain restaurants excel in certain ways that are more difficult for independent restaurants. They promise familiarity and consistency; diners know exactly what to expect, something they might particularly value during a recession.

Independent restaurants, meanwhile, take more risks and ask diners to take them, too. It's not always clear what will be available, chefs actually strive to offer creative, unexpected combinations. Eating in some contemporary restaurants can be confusing and intimidating, but it can also be exciting and inspiring.

If I've taken anything away from the nonstop discussion of Marilyn Hagerty and the Olive Garden over the past two weeks it's this: As someone who loves food and restaurants, I feel incredibly lucky to live in a city where the opening of an Olive Garden is not big news.

And I can't wait to read Ms. Hagerty's review of New York's famed Le Bernardin.