Smart bombs, satellite surveillance, stealth drones and other military robots? The technological leap that has profoundly changed the nature of warfare in the 21st century may be less expensive and more ubiquitous. It's in the pockets of thousands of soldiers and rests openly on the dashboards of insurgents.
Director Deborah Scranton gave digital cameras to three National Guardsmen from her native New Hampshire and used their footage for the documentary "War Tapes."
Click photo for larger image.
Related review
Web site:http://www.thewartapes.com/
Web site: www.teampredator.com Advisory: Explicit language
Personal digital cameras capable of shooting quality still and video images are everywhere in Iraq and Afghanistan. All you need is Internet access to e-mail the digital images anywhere, anytime. A technology that would have revolutionized reconnaissance in previous wars is now a low-priced consumer commodity available to just about everyone on both sides of the conflict. Soldiers say that everyone carries them, particularly in Iraq, where allied military personnel, commercial contract workers, indigenous civilians, nationalist insurgents and foreign terrorists are recording the war.
The new technology has opened an unprecedented window to warfare that allows soldiers to send moving pictures to loved ones, insurgents to better surveil and attack allied troops, and film directors to produce a new kind of reality war movie.
Presence of the cameras has also opened a can of worms regarding security concerns and ethical issues.
Today's release of director Deborah Scranton's "The War Tapes" at Regent Square Theater, and an upcoming screening of a documentary by a Pennsylvania National Guardsman from Creekside, Indiana County, are part of a new wave of war movies that has outpaced Pentagon security guidelines and the national debate on personal freedoms in the age of terrorism.
"As an American, you're protected by the First Amendment to do whatever you want as long as you remain within a code of conduct," says Shawn Bronson, a former sergeant with the Pennsylvania Army National Guard. The 21-year-old Point Park University student now lives in Penn Hills and works with an EMT ambulance crew. He said his movie, "Team Predator: 365 Days in Iraq," will be screened Labor Day weekend in Indiana.
"Soldiers enjoy the luxury of Internet access at almost every major base," adds Sgt. Steve Pink, one of three videographers on the "War Tapes" project. "I shot everything I thought was important when I was there."
Sgt. Pink, now a carpenter and aspiring writer on ready-reserve status with the New Hampshire Army National Guard, was given a professional video camera and some in-country direction, via e-mail, by Scranton. Bronson calls his compilation of amateur video clips shot by him and others "ad-lib filmmaking." Their documentaries differ in process and content from films such as Michael Tucker and Petra Epperlein's "Gunner's Palace," shot and directed in Iraq by professionals and released through an industry that has its own motivations and acceptable codes of conduct. Soldiers' films differ, too, from the work of embedded reporters, whose video dispatches are usually filtered through the process of journalism and subject to the competitive needs of each news source.
Amateur videos shot by soldiers are loosely regulated by the Universal Code of Military Justice, guidelines that Carol Kerr, a public affairs officer with the U.S. Army War College, says are intended to protect the troops.
Sgt. Shawn Bronson videotaped his tour of duty in Iraq to create "Team Predator: 365 Days in Iraq," which will be screened in Indiana, Pa.
Click photo for larger image.
Sgt. Steve Pink filming in front of a Humvee.
Click photo for larger image.
"Operational security is the source of these guidelines," she said. "We do not attempt to censor soldiers' descriptions of what they've done or seen ... [but] commanders brief soldiers on what they can capture [on video] and what they can't."
During previous wars, soldiers' snapshots and letters home were routinely censored by the military. With the warning "loose lips sink ships," they were told that in the wrong hands, innocent correspondence about troop locations and movements could help the enemy. Modern technology and contemporary views on free speech make that kind of censorship of Americans impossible today, yet the threat of giving away soldiers' locations and plans is greater than ever.
On entering a war zone, American soldiers are briefed on Pentagon guidelines regarding what can and can't be recorded. It's forbidden to divulge specific troop locations and details of past and future missions. Photographing captured insurgents is forbidden by the Geneva Convention, and it's against regulations to take pictures of casualties. Before images are e-mailed or carried out of country on information storage devices, they're to be screened by a military public affairs officer. Violators are subject to punishment in military court.
Bronson and Pink say that while some of the images they shot were banned, they concur with those decisions and support the guidelines.
"I did, at one point, take footage of an insurgent casualty," said Pink. "That was deemed inappropriate and rightly so. That was the only tape out of hundreds that was not allowed. I never went out of my way to film specifically where we were. When Geraldo [Rivera] was embedded and got thrown out of the country, he was an idiot. He gave away troop locations. I would never endanger myself or the guys in my unit."
Bronson says he had "some aerial footage from unmanned [drones] that I had to take out," and for ethical reasons, he self-censored some of his images that were cleared by military security.
"In an insurgent video film that we found, they were 10 feet away, filming this guy just before they blew him up," he says. "Drivers take a camera and sit it on the dash while driving down the road. They use the tapes for recruitment. We had footage of [another guy], and as soon as he walked out of the room, he got blown up from the flak jacket down. Because of the way the insurgents used guys in their film, I didn't include that guy [in 'Team Predator']."
Pink says that despite his involvement in "The War Tapes," he's concerned the guidelines may not be strict enough.
"I do feel the possibility of sensitive information getting out there could easily happen," he says. "But I also feel soldiers have to maintain their discipline and training. Giving away classified information is illegal and should not be done," even if it means losing a good shot.
Pink and Bronson say it's important to note they didn't get involved in their film projects to support a political agenda.
"I just planned on doing my job," says Bronson. "We started getting accidental clips -- everybody was trading them back and forth -- and somebody said it'd be cool if somebody put it all together. I'm a film student. I wanted to do a documentary that explains stuff to a public that just hears things in the media and doesn't know what's going on."
Pink says he was "completely leery" about director Scranton's motivations when first contacted about "The War Tapes."
"I have a mild cynicism about the media," he says. "They have a license to tell any story they want. But she had done a previous documentary, 'Stories From Silence: Witness to War,' and had a great deal of knowledge about the New Hampshire National Guard. I saw that and spoke with her and took a leap of faith."
After the war footage is approved by military public relations and makes it into a reality movie, it's often used in another battle being fought at home. Since the initial screenings of "The War Tapes," Pink says partisans on both sides of the war debate have tried to use the film to serve their agendas.
"I've done plenty of interviews, and I can tell when the questions become leading and they want me to get their points across," he says. "I call them out. I say, 'You're provoking me to say a specific thing. I won't, and I think that's bad journalism.' "
For the Post-Gazette's review of "The War Tapes" that ran in Weekend Mag, visit www.post-gazette.com.
Sgt. Steve Pink
Click photo for larger image.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.