Other than a limitless lust for cash by the studio that currently holds the license to Marvel’s oldest superhero team, there’s no reason for director Josh Trank’s version of the Fantastic Four to exist.
Two failed attempts in 2005 and 2007 to put on the big screen the series Marvel once hyped as “the world’s greatest comic magazine” — before it unceremoniously canceled the book late last year — should have been enough to convince those responsible for green lighting “Fantastic Four” to think again.
Precocious high school genius Reed Richards (Miles Teller) has been tearing at the fabric of interdimensional space-time in his Oyster Bay garage since he was a fifth-grader stealing component parts from the scrapyard owned by the family of his classmate Ben Grimm (Jamie Bell).
Reed’s genius is noticed at a high school science fair by Dr. Franklin Storm (Reg E. Cathey), a government-sponsored scientist who believes the young man’s dream of teleportation is achievable with enough corporate and military backing.
'Fantastic Four'

Read More
Starring: Miles Teller, Michael B. Jordan, Kate Mara, Jamie Bell, Toby Kebbell, Reg E. Cathey.
Rating: PG 13 for sci-fi action violence and language (has mild profanity, exploding heads, blood, some gore and civilians swept up in a dimensional vortex).
Dr. Storm and his adopted daughter Sue (Kate Mara) scour science fairs recruiting folks like Reed to come work for the Baxter Institute, a high-tech company with close ties to the U.S. military.
Reed’s equations provide a doorway to another dimension that Dr. Storm believes can be tapped for its unlimited supply of energy. He persuades a troubled former Baxter Institute employee Victor von Doom (Toby Kebbell) to return to the project he had previously worked on for a decade and help Reed perfect the science of interdimensional teleportation.
Dr. Storm’s borderline delinquent son Johnny (Michael B. Jordan) is also enlisted in the project because he is a whiz at building fast cars from scratch.
After Reed and Victor create a successful teleportation device, the military moves in and restricts their access, informing them that they won’t be allowed to be the first humans to travel to another dimension.
A night of drinking with Victor and Johnny prompts Reed to call his old friend Ben to meet them at the Baxter Institute. The four men rig the teleportation machine to spirit them to another dimension so that the fame belongs to them, not to NASA or the military. Their night of drinking clearly killed their collective brain cells.
Of course, disaster ensues once they reach the other dimension. One of them is left behind, and the three that make it back to Earth are changed dramatically at the cellular level. So is Sue, who did not travel to the other side but who nonetheless was transformed by residual waves of energy that accompany the three back to Earth.
Reed, Sue, Johnny and Ben are quarantined while scientists try to figure out why they have superhuman powers. Reed can stretch his limbs to impossible lengths. Sue shifts in and out of the visible light spectrum. Johnny is perpetually on fire and can fly. Ben is made of animated rocks and is more powerful than any human on Earth.
This version of the Fantastic Four and its origin will be somewhat familiar to fans of the decade-old “Ultimate Fantastic Four” comic series — not the classic FF series launched in 1961 by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby.
Had “Fantastic Four” been the pilot episode of a 12-episode run on Netflix, it might be considered a work of inspired comic book reimagining because of its dark tone and limitless potential to build upon the story-rich legacy of one of the most successful comic series in history.
As it is, “Fantastic Four” takes a long time in a relatively short film to set up the central conflict between its reluctant heroes and oddly homicidal villain. It is also hobbled by the fact that none of its best moments seem to connect with the audience. There isn’t a single funny line or rousing incident — like the Hulk wiping the floor with Loki in “Marvel’s Avengers” — for the audience to cheer.
The the filmmakers' attempt to fashion a family on screen that reflects the country’s diversity is laudable, but it also begs so many questions. I kept wondering how a black man like Dr. Storm was able to adopt a blue-eyed blond orphan girl like Sue from Kosovo. And why did her hairstyle change so much from scene to scene?
Given the iconic nature of the Human Torch in the comic book, was the risk of recasting his race from white to black worth the payoff in the film? A truly “alternate universe” would be one in which such things happened without longtime comics fans grumbling.
Unfortunately, “Fantastic Four” is stark vindication of the notion that the superhero movie — a genre that has dominated the box office like none other for the past decade — has entered its most visually adept but narratively indifferent phase.
As much as I wanted to like this film, it never gave me a chance to connect to the characters, who are mostly flat and superficially motivated. It isn’t a terrible movie, but it has very little to do with the characters I’ve loved for decades. What’s the point of making a Fantastic Four movie that lacks any hint of cosmic grandeur, optimism about the human spirit or any evidence that the characters even like one another?
Even Stan Lee's usual cameo is missing. There's no point in staying through the credits, either.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.