Because “Dear White People,” the debut film by writer/director Justin Simien, already won the 2014 Sundance Film Festival’s Special Jury Award for Breakthrough Talent, it comes wrapped in the suffocating garb of great expectations, which is too bad. “Dear White People” would be a far more enjoyable experience if it weren’t the subject of so much hype — and hope.
Had it not done as well at Sundance as it did, it might be possible to see the film for what it truly is — a thoughtful, but often didactic excursion into the messy scrum of America’s racial politics.
'Dear White People'

Starring: Dennis Haysbert, Tessa Thompson, Tyler James Williams, Brandon P. Bell, Teyonah Parris.
Rating: R for sexual situations, profanity, drug use and alcohol consumption
“Dear White People” takes place at fictional Winchester University during the Obama presidency. Samantha “Sam” White (Tessa Thompson), one of the leaders of the campus black student union, uses her campus radio broadcast to throw out such racially provocative bon mots as: “Dear White People; the number of black friends required not to seem racist has just been raised to two. Your weed man, Tyrone, doesn’t count.”
“It’s like Spike Lee and Oprah had some pissed-off baby,” one white student complains to another when he hears the “Dear White People” broadcast.
When Sam unexpectedly beats her former lover, Troy Fairbanks (Brandon P. Bell), the privileged son of the dean of students (Dennis Haysbert) in an election to head Armstrong Parker House, she decides to thwart the university’s plans to integrate the historically all-black house.
Meanwhile, Lionel Higgins (Tyler James Williams) a black, gay nerd and aspiring journalist who exists on the periphery of every campus social circle, desperately wants to connect to some individual or group without compromising his own quirky identity. His huge, unruly afro sets him apart from the mass of black male students who wear their hair short and neatly trimmed or in dreads.
When Lionel is confronted by more militant students about why he never comes to their meetings, he answers in a way that doesn’t endear him: “I listen to Mumford & Sons and watch Robert Altman films. Do you think I’m black enough for the student union?”
It isn’t long before Lionel is recruited by the seductive male editor (Kurt Fletcher) of the all-white student newspaper to work on a story about the Armstrong Parker House controversy.
Meanwhile, Troy uses the opportunity provided by his election loss to Sam to petition for a position on Pastiche, the university’s all-white, racially boorish humor publication. Troy is so blinded by ambition that he doesn’t flinch when he discovers that Pastiche plans to have a racially provocative fundraising party centered around the theme “Unleashing Your Inner Negro” in which white students are encouraged to dress up as their favorite demeaning black stereotype.
The film’s most inscrutable character is Coco Conners (Teyonah Parris), a wig-wearing, blue contact lens wearing black woman who wants desperately to assimilate into the upper echelons of the university’s social hierarchy. When she finds out that a producer for reality TV programs is scouting the campus for interesting conflicts, stories and people, she tries to fill the bill.
It is Coco who makes one of the film’s most memorable observations about the flipping back and forth between racial personas on campus: “Whites addicted to being black and blacks addicted to blond wigs is a strange symbiosis.”
In the end, “Dear White People” wants to be an ironic meditation on how racial hypocrisy and role-playing is a character flaw that afflicts us all. There isn’t a single character in the film who isn’t double-minded in some way.
It turns out that Sam has a white boyfriend on the side that she’s hiding from her comrades in the black student union because, she assumes correctly, they would be appalled by the gap between her “pro-black” militancy and her personal life.
The black students who protest the racism of the university administration and the campus culture are as one dimensional as the white students who are either oblivious to it or actively hostile to their interests. They spend a lot of time scowling and being aggrieved. Their humorlessness almost qualifies as a character in itself.
The thing that distinguishes the students in this film most from students in real life is their tendency to speechify at the drop of a hat. Everyone, regardless of what side of the racial or ideological fence they stand, is always ready to spout either a postmodern or pop cultural reference. It is as if writer/director Simien decided no one in the film is allowed to be dumb, but everyone is allowed to be stupid.
“Your favorite director is [Ingmar] Bergman but you tell everyone Spike Lee,” Sam’s white boyfriend says during a tense exchange. It is an amusing moment in a film full of such witty exchanges, but “Dear White People” is not as funny as it needs to be to carry the film’s weighty ambitions.
Still, thanks to its undeniable visual charm and intellectual heft, “Dear White People” easily qualifies as a worthy successor to Spike Lee’s “School Daze,” though it fails to advance that flawed film’s questionable premise that there is something interesting about the competing racial theories of college kids who haven’t lived long enough to know what racism truly is. It is a more likable film than “School Daze,” but not by much. Like several of Mr. Lee's films, it unravels at the end after a riot and a confusing postscript.
“Dear White People” dares to ask more questions than it is capable of answering about the intersection of race and university life in the age of Obama. It is self-aware enough to wink at its own intellectual pretensions, but myopic enough to take itself seriously.
Opens today at Waterworks, Cinemark Robinson and AMC Loews at the Waterfront.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.