One of the most universal concepts, love evokes emotion that virtually everyone can relate to, regardless of age, ethnicity, and other distinguishing characteristics. In order to stir the whims of love in an audience, a cast must be engaging, captivating, and convincing; in their performance of “All Shook Up”, Brashear High School did just that.
“All Shook Up” follows the complex romances of a number of characters living in a small, Midwestern town sometime around 1955. Each character becomes victim to an intense infatuation with another, struggling to come to terms with a love unrequited, failing to acknowledge the steadfast adoration of those they do not desire. The irony of the plotline makes the story humorous rather than tragic, and, in a classic fashion, with the conclusion comes a happy ending.
While the show was neither glitzy nor flawless, what was lacking was compensated for through the visible passion of the cast, all of whom had an undeniable dedication to their roles. I found myself especially impressed by both Tiahna Flannigan and Desmond Taylor, as they both perfectly embodied the essence of their on-stage personas Tiahna naturally executing the rather sassy, no-nonsense nature of Sylvia, and Desmond strikingly devoted to the quirky, nerdy personality of Dennis, who was no doubt one of the most entertaining to watch.
The band added a significant layer of enchantment to the performance, rendering the music of Elvis in a fun, romantic fashion, and heightening the emotional twists and turns which trickled throughout the night. Aside from her well-developed impersonation of Sylvia, Tiahna possessed a memorably beautiful voice, charming the audience into sympathizing with her character’s frustrations, and adding depth to her role – an accomplishment which I feel only a few seasoned performers can master.
The weight of multiple love plots found relief in the hands of comedic characters such as Dennis and Mayor Matilda, as well as unexpected (at least for non-traditional musical attendees like myself) developments, particularly in Miss Sandra and Chad’s falling for Ed, a male disguise assumed by Natalie in the hopes of wooing her lover
Again, Brashear’s strength was in the ability of those such as Angie McHugh, playing Mayor Matilda, to wholeheartedly take on the demands of her role, constructing a convincing aura of conservatism and militarism that seemed laughable in contrast to the genuineness of her peers. I can still hear her voice screeching “Dean” and see her hunched over in intense pursuit of her rebellious son.
Nothing about the performance felt forced: each student became one with their role, adding their own unique personal attributes, making the evening raw, real, and sincere. In doing so, the performance was rather casual, making it easy to feel as if one were engaged, rather than a detached audience.
A number of times, notably during the end of the first and second act, I surprisingly found myself swelling with sentiment at the cast’s heartfelt delivery of Elvis’s “Can’t Help Falling in Love.” I felt myself identifying with the events unfolding on stage, reminiscing on my own experiences of love and heartbreak.
For me, the imperfections of the night, such as the minuscule frustration created as the band periodically drowned out the singing of the cast, were overshadowed by Brashear’s ability to make their performance relatable, rather than just admirable. Furthermore, I am sure that I was not alone in this conviction, as the cheers, laughs, and supportive responses of the audience conveyed the effectiveness of the performance. The night was not only enjoyable but left me with a lesson learned: though things don’t always turn out how we expect them to, everything has a way of working itself out.
The Kelly Critics is a joint program of the Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh CLO's Gene Kelly Awards for Excellence in High School Musicals, in which students at Kelly schools review musicals at other Kelly schools. Reviews are edited by senior theater critic Christopher Rawson. For more high school musicals coverage, go to http://www.post-gazette.com/ae/theater-dance/ and scroll down.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.