The Kelly Critics is a joint program of the Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh CLO's Gene Kelly Awards for Excellence in High School Musicals, in which students at Kelly schools review musicals at other Kelly schools. Reviews are edited by senior theater critic Christopher Rawson.
Most Americans are familiar with the Addams Family: that “creepy, kooky, altogether ooky” band of misanthropes, who worship death and the macabre. Ironically, their presence doesn’t seem to die. With writers and directors grasping at straws for ideas to excite audiences, original ideas have gone by the wayside. Instead, old artifacts are revamped and take center stage.
Cue the latest reincarnation of the Addams family in musical form. But this version featuring patriarch Gomez Addams and his family went on to a mere, one-year Broadway run. With this in mind, high schools may have been worried to fraternize with the latest Addams’ schtick.
Our Lady of the Sacred Heart begs to differ. Their production proves that you can whistle past the graveyard and entertain an audience.
Although the family has been rehashed between comic strip, television, and film, OLSH’s production immediately stirs up nostalgic memories by greeting the audience with the “da-da-da-dum *snap* *snap*” central to the Addams’—an acoustic Addams Family crest of sorts. Indeed, in the intimate OLSH theater and playing on harbored memories, the cast makes even the audience feel “obligated to the clan,” as the undead ensemble sings their pledge of loyalty to the Addams family.
However, just as her name suggests, Wednesday Addams (Ivy Nowakowski), is caught in the middle of loyalties. Her love for, and clandestine engagement to, Lucas Beineke (Matthew Wojtechko) of the satirized “normal American family” is in contrast to her clan obligations. Wednesday expresses her conflict in “Pulled,” a number displaying Nowakowski’s strong voice and her ability to maintain Wednesday’s angsty teenage aura. After she belts to the stratosphere that love gives her the urge to cuddle puppies and listen to Liberace, she squeezes a song bird, almost sickening the audience with her saccharine display. To my relief and to the amusement of many, the head of the bird pops off and flops around in a moment of directorial wisdom from Dolores Manuel in order to maintain the macabre.
To add to the absurdity of the plot, the Beinekes arrive for dinner, and Alice (Theresa Thimons) speaks mostly in rhymes. Her “typical housewife hair” and grin, coupled with impromptu poetry akin to Dr. Seuss, made even the actors on stage laugh and break character. Gomez (Luke Travis) who knows of his daughter’s pending nuptials must keep them a secret from the guests and his wife, Morticia (Ashley Sitarik), who conveniently abhors anyone who keeps secrets.
With all this hubbub, the plot gets entangled quickly. In the first act finale, “Full Disclosure,” a scene where terrible and hysterical secrets are disclosed, a hurricane comes and locks the Beinekes in with the Addams much to the chagrin of all — an apt ending for a first act plotline that, at times, seems as chaotic as a hurricane.
It comes as no surprise that the majority of act two is spent simply picking up loose ends in order for romance to succeed, a shame considering the second act features two stand-out performances loosely tied to the plot. Nonetheless, Fester’s (Noah Dawgiello) declaration of love for the moon in a ghoulish romance ballad is unlike the typical belting that the show features, allowing his voice and comic ability to stand apart. Morticia’s “Just Around the Corner” is equally commanding. Sitarik clutches notes, hits them with intense vibrato, and ends the number with a devilish smirk of awareness about her show-stealing performance.
What the show lacks, on occasion, is the pace of “Addams Family” comedic timing. Banter and cynical quips lose their luster, in need of that quintessential *snap* *snap* to keep the action alive, especially with a generic ending where love conquers all (ill-fitting for a group who dances with their undead ancestors and cringes at the idea of smiling).
But really, isn’t the whole idea of placing in a musical setting a family who, as Morticia describes, “has to have a taste for death,” a bit odd? The cobweb clad Addams Family is not defined by typical theater tunes and jazz hands, forcing those high schools who dare to tackle the show to embrace the black comedy.
OLSH does this in a production that proves to be a ghastly good evening in the graveyard. They conquer the challenge of presenting the revamped version of something mysterious, spooky, and altogether ooky, “The Addams Family,” Da-da-da-dum *snap* *snap*.
For more high school musicals coverage, go to www.post-gazette.com/ae/theater-dance and scroll down.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.