Jimmy Dore is the son of a Chicago cop and brickworker, and one of 11 kids — the youngest of seven brothers — so he has some fight in him.
If you’re one of his million-plus subscribers on YouTube, you’ve seen that come out quite often in the past few years as the comedian and political commentator, who was aligned with “The Young Turks” from 2009 to 2019, has gone against the tide of his fellow progressives.
Among his battles: Dore did not buy into Russiagate, he launched the Force the Vote movement to challenge the progressive wing of the party to put Medicare for all to a vote, he rails against identity politics and pushes back against COVID-19 policies.
At first he was all in. Last year, he went on the Joe Rogan Experience to talk about his struggles with a rare bone disease and also the long-term body aches, joint pain, etc., that he experienced after his second COVID shot.
In the wake of all that, Dore has clashed with a lot of former lefty allies while building new allegiances and a larger audience of independents.
On Thursday, the 56-year-old comedian makes his first Pittsburgh appearance on a small Midwest comedy tour that stops at the Improv at the Waterfront. He talked to us by phone from Los Angeles.
You were about 10 years into your comedy career when you began transitioning into the political realm, where you’re more in a battleground. How has that changed your life?
Most recently, the way it has changed my life is that I’m filling a hole, I’m feeling a need, and the need is for someone to tell people what's actually happening without a corporate bias. People are hungry for the truth and they're constantly being gaslit by the corporate media. Let’s remember what the corporate media is there to do. They’re there to manufacture consent. And consent for who? Consent for the billionaire establishment class that run everything. There's only a handful of billionaires that run all of our media and they all have the same agenda, right?
During the 2015-16 Bernie Sanders campaign, and afterwards, people would come up to me and tell me things like, “Thanks for keeping me sane.” And when they first started telling me that, I dismissed it. I just thought they were being overly gracious and nice and complimentary, but then it kept happening. And ever since then, everywhere I go, people say that, and so I have to accept it’s a real thing. People appreciate that I’m able to show them what the corporate news is saying, and what they’re leaving out, and what the real story is.
Also, what people feel is that their frustration and rage over a corrupt system that is designed to oppress them and keep them poor, they see me express that outrage that they feel inwardly, and they feel less alone. They feel, “Oh my God, I’m not crazy. This is rational to feel this way and I'm not the only one.” Chomsky taught us that the corporate media is always reflecting the ideas and values of the establishment, of the oligarchy, and you and your views are never mirrored back to you through corporate media, so you think that you’re the only one thinking that and it’s isolating, and it’s intended. The service I provide them is debunking propaganda.
The left wasn’t exactly unified, but when we got into COVID, it seems like we went into uncharted territory and people split in all different kinds of ways. You had alliances on the left that blew up. What is like being in this realm where you’re even more alone?
Even when I was debunking Russiagate, I had more allies than I do debunking the COVID narrative. And a lot of people didn’t turn on me over Russiagate. People distanced themselves from me, but definitely people have turned on me over COVID. And those are people who just ingested the propaganda and it doesn’t matter how many times Fauci lies to them or many times you see the CDC chairwoman acting like a used car salesman. It’s just amazing to me that people who are skeptical of everything have zero amount of critique for COVID or vaccine policies or boosters or mandates. It’s just mind-blowing to me. People who still think Elvis is alive and question the moon landing have no questions over the vaccine and COVID policies. It’s nuts to me.
I saw a tweet recently that even included you on a list of “right-wing” people.
Yeah, me with Russell Brand and Joe Rogan — three people who’ve never voted Republican in their life and advocate for nothing but left-wing ideas. If you don’t go along with the Democrats, they call you a right-winger. You know why? Because they’ve got nothing else. All they can do is try to discredit you. They can’t answer your criticism ’cause my criticism of the Democratic party is 100% spot on. And so what they try to do is smear you and discredit you because they can’t answer my criticism.
So, you have to find alliances where you can.
Yeah, I just saw today on Twitter that Christian Smalls, who was the African-American who was fired by Amazon and then started his own union and just won — a huge victory — he went on Tucker Carlson to help get his message out, and on Twitter today, there are people attacking him for that: “How dare you go on that show that props up racism and blah blah blah!” It's like he’s not propping up Tucker Carlson. He’s using Tucker Carlson’s platform to reach half the country.
When Democrats say we have to organize along class lines, either they don’t mean it and they’re lying, or they don’t know what they’re saying. Because when you say, “Let's organize along class lines,” that means everybody in your class, which means Republicans, which means Trump voters, which means libertarians, which means Proud Boys, which means everybody on the right and the left in the same class, which is how you organize labor unions.
When Christian Smalls organized a labor union, he didn’t go to the shop floor and say, ‘Who here is a libertarian? You’re out. Who here is a Trumper? You’re out. Who’s a Republican? You’re out. Who's the Boogaloo Boi? You’re out. Who’s a gun nut? You’re out. Who’s a homophobe? You’re out. OK, who’s left? Now, let’s organize.” That's not how you do it. The Democrats are all about identity politics, which is all about stopping you from making economic progress. That’s why they push identity politics because it leads to tribalism, which leads to propping up the status quo, but the joke I do is, if it was 1860, the Democrats would be bragging about their first transgendered slave owner. That's the end goal of identity politics. You ignore the horror and you applaud that someone of your same identity is now the oppressor.
How does the politics work into your comedy on stage right now. Do you keep it separate?
No, it’s woven all through it. What am I gonna do, go up and talk about airline food and dating?
[laughs] So how has your crowd changed in recent years since the whole pandemic?
My crowd is very much like the George Carlin crowd. When I used to go see George Carlin, I always remarked at how his crowd was everybody. There were hippies, there were guys in business suits, there were kids, there were elderly people, everybody in between: men, women, Black, white, Mexican, Asian, everybody. And that’s my crowd. When you come to see me you’re going to get all that, too, and I couldn't be more happy.
And people try to attack me because they say, “Oh well, Jimmy has right-wingers in his audience,” so what they’re saying is, “Oh, you should be ashamed that you have broad appeal.” I'm not ashamed of that. I don’t preach division. I preach unity. I have more in common with those people than I do with Bill Gates or Jeff Bezos or Joe Biden and Barack Obama. We have more in common than we have that keeps us separated. And as soon as people realize that, that’s when we’ll have power. And I think people are waking up to that. And that’s why I go on Tucker Carlson’s show. Not to be friends with Tucker Carlson, but because I want to speak to his millions of viewers and I want to get my message out to those people, ’cause that used to be the goal. The goal used to be to change men's hearts and minds with the power of your ideas. And now you’re not supposed to talk to people who are bad. That's crazy. That's not how politics works.
I cracked up the other day when you said [of Rogan] something like “We need a guy who calls UFC cage matches to tell us this stuff.”
Yeah, a guy who announces men fighting in cages had to school the doctor from CNN — tell him how natural immunity works. That’s what happened right in front of your face. It’s just called propaganda. This is what happens when your paycheck is tied to the people you’re supposed to be investigating and exposing.
And it’s getting harder for people to say “Why listen to a comedian?” when [Volodymyr] Zelensky was a comedian. He’s actually providing credibility.
Right. I just love that whole thing when they don’t like what you say, they don’t ever actually respond to what you’re saying. They just try to dismiss you, like when I was pushing Force the Vote and [Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez] was like, “He’s not a recognized organizer.” “What? You were a [expletive] bartender two years ago!” It’s America. Anybody can be anything. You can be a congresswoman after being a bartender. That's just the trick that they use. When you say something about COVID policy, they go, “Oh, you a doctor?” No. Bill Gates didn’t even graduate college. Why does everybody [expletive] listen to him?
Bill Burr put that “we’re just comedians” line on Joe Rogan that became a viral clip.
Yeah, I had that same conversation and I was like, “I don’t know if you’ve ever been seriously ill. I have, and not only did I have to get two opinions, I ended up having to get about 22 opinions, because I was sick in a really unique way and nobody had any expert experience with it. So I had to get all these opinions and then I had to get as informed as I could because the person who had to choose which doctor to follow was me. Not all doctors say the same thing.
That’s why you have to get different opinions, and then you have to decide. Do you recommend that we don’t do that anymore? I saw comedians shaming people for trying to get informed about a medical procedure that was being mandated them. They were shaming people for what they called “doing your own research” and I’m like, “You know, you’re one-half-turn of the screw away from shaming people for reading.” It’s like, ‘We got ourselves a READER?! Whatchu readin’ for?! Whatchu READIN’ for?”
If you’re using comedy to shame people for getting informed and questioning authority, you’re not doing comedy, you’re doing propaganda, ’cause comedy is supposed to poke holes in the status quo and challenge authority and question authority. Comedy is not supposed to be there to [expletive] tell you to stop questioning authority. That's all propaganda. Anybody can have an opinion on the quality of my jokes. Anybody can say, “Well, I don’t find them funny.” What you can’t say is “they’re propaganda.”
How do you deal with the daily feedback? Do you read the comments?
I don’t read my mentions on Twitter and I don’t go on Facebook or Instagram. I might go on Facebook once or twice a month ’cause someone sends me a link of something. Every time you go on there, you feel worse after you get off Facebook. Me, personally, I never feel better. And I always have to try to un-remember something so I can remain friends with someone.
OK, I hope you enjoy Pittsburgh. Do you have any history here?
I’ve never played there. But I was there in 1984 or 1985 to see the Cubs clinch the National League East. A bunch of my friends drove from Illinois State to Pittsburgh to watch it happen, and it happened on a Monday night.
Jimmy Dore performs at the Improv at 8 p.m. Tickets are $35 at ticketweb.com.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.