At this point in Martin Short’s decades-spanning career, what he is most recognized for depends on demographics.

“I always find that it varies from the age and description of the person approaching me,” Short recently told the Post-Gazette. “If it’s a mom and dad who are 45, it’s ‘Father of the Bride’ because they have a daughter who just got married. If it’s a 38-year-old stoner, it’s ‘Clifford.’ Some people just want to talk about [Jiminy] Glick.

“Sometimes, people will call out a line from a [‘Saturday Night Live’] sketch, and I’ll get on the plane and think, ‘What’s that from?’ By the time I land, I’ll come up with it.”

His Western Pennsylvania fans have the rare opportunity to spend an evening with Short — who is starring with friend and frequent collaborator Steve Martin on the Hulu comedy “Only Murders in the Building” — at 7:30 p.m. Thursday at Mercyhurst University’s Mary D'Angelo Performing Arts Center in Erie. Tickets, $40-$65, are available at miac.mercyhurst.edu.

Advertise with us

Mercyhurst recently began putting on in-person events again, including last month, hosting Betty Buckley’s first full concert since the COVID-19 pandemic began.

Short’s show will basically serve as a best-of medley involving some of his most beloved characters over the years. He wanted to keep most elements a surprise, but he did reveal that both Jiminy Glick and Franck Eggelhoffer from “Father of the Bride” will most likely make appearances.

“I might end up in a nude suit,” he said. “It’s hard to say. ... It’s very loose, lots of improv and energy and music and chatter. It’s a party with Marty.”

The Canadian-born Short has no direct connections with Pittsburgh, though he and Martin did come through in 2017 for a night of comedy at the Benedum Center.

Short is back in the public eye these days thanks to his starring role as struggling Broadway director Oliver Putnam in “Only Murders in the Building” opposite Martin as fading crime show actor Charles-Haden Savage and Selena Gomez as the mysterious Mabel Mora. All three live in the same building and come together when their shared love of true-crime podcasts leads them to create their own after one of their neighbors dies under uncertain circumstances.

Advertise with us

“Only Murders in the Building” was born out of Martin’s love for true crime stories. A lunch with “This is Us” creator Dan Fogelman turned into a pitching session in which Martin told Fogelman about his idea for a show about three people solving a murder in their apartment complex. Fogelman, who serves as an executive producer on the show, brought the idea to Hulu and, once it got the green light, helped get Short and Gomez on board.

It wasn’t tough to sell Short on the project — he’s friends with Martin and loved the idea of making a “generational crime-solver” series. He’s always been the kind of actor willing to take big swings on experimental ideas.

“I don’t take it all terribly seriously,” Short said. “I’ve never been defined by the reaction of an audience. I’m fine. If they don’t respond to something, I don’t look in the mirror later and say, ‘You’re not worthy.’ I just say, ‘That didn’t work,’ and then I cut [that joke].”

Short approaches this part by sticking with an ethos of “whatever Oliver says, therefore he is.” In his mind, it’s disingenuous to have Oliver say something purely as a joke. He has to actually mean it.

Production for “Only Murders in the Building” took place in New York from November 2020 through March. Short has had a lot of fun reuniting with Martin and working with Gomez for the first time.

Advertise with us

The show was recently renewed for a second season at Hulu. Short said “there were thoughts in advance” regarding a potential continuation of this story, and there’s already a writers’ room in place to make that happen.

That’s an exciting place to be for Short, who can be secure that steady work will always come as he is freed up to spread the laughter at venues like Mercyhurst.

“It’s not so much about trying to pay the rent but making the experiences fun,” he said. “If it wasn’t fun and joyful, I wouldn’t keep doing it.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.