Over the last century, the most well-known and important fictional character is an earnest, corny guy with his underwear on the outside of his pants.
Ironically, creators Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster spent nearly six years facing rejection from publishers who found the Man of Steel ridiculous and crude. Still, since Superman’s 1938 debut, countless storytellers have imagined the ways a refugee from a dead world with god-like powers chose not to dominate but to serve.
Forty years ago, two deconstructionist DC Comics stories — Frank Miller’s “The Dark Knight Returns” and “Watchmen” by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons — helped the genre Superman popularized gain respect as a mature art form, but to Superman’s detriment.
These seminal works share a dark, cynical view of humanity. “The Dark Knight Returns” is specifically egregious. Superman appears as an oppressive foil to an aging, violent Batman.
Fans and comic creators criticized this portrayal, and Miller agreed. In a 2010 interview with The Comics Journal he called his version of Superman “the most questionable thing I did.”
Miller’s depiction reveals that with nine decades of adventures across every conceivable medium behind him, there is no singular “correct” version of Superman. But those who best understand the character adhere to Siegel and Shuster’s original vision: an ethical defender of people who never suffers a bully.
Comics, film serials and cartoons from the early 20th century often feature horrific racial, ethnic and sexist stereotypes reflecting the worst attitudes of their day. But rarely do they appear in Superman stories.
In 1946, the KKK was not yet universally reviled. So, the wildly popular “The Adventures of Superman” radio program pitted the hero against the “Clan of the Fiery Cross.” Concurrently, actor Bud Collyer appeared in ad campaigns promoting racial and religious tolerance. According to activist Stetson Kennedy, seeing their kids playacting as Superman fighting the Klan reportedly shamed members enough to leave the group.
Early live-action portrayals in film and TV — with Kirk Alyn and George Reeves in the role – eschewed the worst impulses of their eras. The character challenges contemporaneous ideas of what it means to “be a man.” In “Superman and the Mole Men,” instead of fighting the “monsters,” Reeves’ hero defends them from hostile townspeople, taking their guns.
His alter ego, Clark Kent, is frequently called a “coward,” which remains the kind of insult that leads to fisticuffs. As a reporter, Kent is often delighted to be outdone by Lois Lane, whose mere existence as a respected professional woman was practically revolutionary in comics well into the 1980s.
As the titular villain in “Kill Bill: Volume 2,” the late David Carradine delivered a monologue saying that weak, bumbling Clark is Superman’s indictment of humanity. This scene more reflects Carradine’s character than the Man of Tomorrow.
Sure, some of his “weak” characterization is how Clark deflects suspicion he’s Superman. But his quiet, thoughtful kindness and lack of ego point to his core identity. Clark Kent exemplifies a consistent counterpoint to traditional notions about strength and masculinity.
Those who scorn comics as childish fantasy claim fans still yearn for someone to swoop in and “save” them. Superman’s appeal is not flight, super-strength and laser eyes. That stuff is just cool. What Superman actually gives fans of all ages is a “fantasy” that someone with such power would use it only to help others. Whether feeling unseen or underestimated like Clark, or strong and invincible like Superman, the gift he gives kids (and adults) is they, too, can make a choice to be one of the helpers.
Superman’s lack of a “dark side” and earnest, moral goodness is often cited as the reason he’s uninteresting or dramatically lacking. Nearly 100 years of comics, novels, audio dramas, television episodes and films prove otherwise.
Siegel and Shuster wanted their hero to reflect human nature at its best, and this is why the world needs Superman. He reminds people that compassion, restraint and an unconditional respect for life — even a villain’s — are superpowers, too. And, unlike his other abilities, these are the gifts humanity gave him.
Joshua M. Patton is a father, veteran and senior writer for Comic Book Resources, and his latest short story collection “Tales of Adventure & Fantasy: Giant-Sized!” is available online.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.