When Michael Pollan’s latest book, “A World Appears: A Journey into Consciousness,” arrived in my mailbox, I texted a friend who loves Pollan’s work. I sent a photo of the cover and one of a random page I’d opened to in the middle of the book.
“Looks like somebody kept taking psychedelics,” I wrote, appending a winking emoji. My friend responded: “Sophomore home for the holidays two weeks after his first LSD trip.”
We were joking, of course. Pollan is in his 70s now, and his work is far too nuanced to be dismissed as a stoner’s ravings. Still, he admits, in the opening pages of this book, that this exploration into consciousness itself was occasioned by his earlier research into — and experimentation with — psychedelic experience.
The first section of “A World Appears” focuses on sentience, particularly on the idea of sentience in plants. Pollan writes that he only took this idea seriously after having eaten psilocybin mushrooms. While hanging out in his garden, he became “as certain of the sentience of the flowering plants around me as I had been of anything up to that point.”
However, Pollan qualifies this statement with sober doubt later in the paragraph. And he is too much a science writer to publish such a sentiment without providing some empirical research to back it up. He makes a convincing case that plants, indeed, possess a certain form of sentience.
It may seem a radical idea now. But indigenous societies the world over have acknowledged the intelligence of non-human beings. Charles Darwin, too, respected the intelligence of the non-human world, plants included. Pollan observes, however, that “Darwin’s deep respect for the intelligence of plants has not been shared by many scientists, at least not until recently.”
At the center of plant sentience science are the “plant neurobiologists,” who argue, convincingly, that plants are “highly intelligent beings,” who can “predict changes in their environment and take appropriate steps.”
Plants can sense changes in nutrient content in surrounding soil and send their roots to the place where nutrients will be more dense. Their roots can even, somehow, hear that water is flowing through a pipe and send their roots to attempt to break through the pipe.
From the sentience of plants, Pollan introduces us to a whole host of theories and the researchers who dream them up. There are between 20 and 30 competing theories of consciousness, depending on how you categorize them. They range from brain-centric models, like Global Workspace Theory, to models like Integrated Information Theory, one that suggests a kind of panpsychism, with individual bodies reduced to a kind of consolidation of differentiated experiences.
Along the way, we meet stubborn humanists, experts on random thoughts, and researchers who have committed themselves to the quixotic quest to build artificial consciousness by housing advanced artificial intelligence algorithms in synthetic bodies that are made intentionally vulnerable, as our bodies are vulnerable: not so much terminator as clumsy bipedal primate.
If all this seems a little, well, head-spinning, you’re not alone. Pollan, nearing the end of his trip through the major categories of consciousness studies, expresses to the famous researcher Christof Koch, that he feels he knows less now than when he started to work on this book. Koch smiles and remarks how great it is that he’s making progress.
The true mystery of what goes on in our minds is still as opaque as ever and arguably best accessed through methods as ancient as a psilocybin molecule or Zazen meditation.
It is probably not surprising that this book does not end with many answers. The concepts and theories and science around it are all illuminating but only to a point. Still, Pollan has a knack for engaging my wonder at the sheer complexity of the world. For this experience alone, he is worth reading.
Joshua D. Graber is a writer and software engineer from Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.