Our third president defies understanding at every turn. Thomas Jefferson held contradictory views on limited government, slavery and the virtues of small farmers depending on his audience or circumstances.

Historian Andrew Burstein tries to shed light on this complicated Founding Father in “Being Thomas Jefferson: An Intimate History.” One of the foremost experts on the topic, Burstein has written four books on Jefferson, co-authored another and was featured on Ken Burns’ PBS documentary “Thomas Jefferson.”

The part of Jefferson’s life most people today know best is the one Jefferson probably never thought would sully his historical reputation: his longstanding sexual relationship with his slave Sally Hemings.

But the book hints at more, much more. Jefferson might not have liked his parents. Maybe he sowed some wild oats as a single man. Despite a placid and likable facade, he burned with ambition and no small amount of ego. He was a dissembler, a two-faced backbiter, a grudge-holder, behind-the-scenes manipulator and hate-monger. Oh, the joys the reader might have rambling through these foibles and flaws!

Advertise with us

Sadly, these pleasures are not to be had. This book is less a mass-audience page-turner and more a conversation between one academic and others, both living and dead — a sort of Talmudic debate about Jefferson’s true feelings and character.

Although he mentions many, one historian in particular garners Burstein’s attention: Fawn Brodie. The late UCLA professor wrote a bestselling 1974 biography that gave serious consideration to the Hemings affair. Previous historians had mostly pooh-poohed the likelihood of Jefferson ever having had a long-running sexual relationship, much less children, with one of his slaves.

DNA evidence in 1998 proved Brodie right: Jefferson had six children with Hemings, his wife’s half-sister, who may have been just 14 when their liaison began.

It is not until the reader picks up Brodie’s biography that Burstein’s suddenly snaps into focus. He is making academic arguments in the margins of Brodie’s thesis. Interestingly, his book title differs by just one word from hers, which was “Thomas Jefferson: An Intimate History.”

For each event in Jefferson’s life, Burstein assumes the reader already knows the story. Burstein talks at length about how Jefferson made some kind of sexual advance or advances on a friend’s wife but never gives the historical evidence for this assertion. Only by reading Brodie’s biography will the reader learn what that evidence was.

Advertise with us

Likewise, Burstein refers many times to Jefferson’s “head and heart” letter, assuming the reader knows its contents. The final version of his book may include the letter in its appendix, but without it, the reader is lost. Brodie’s book includes the letter – nine printed pages – and after scanning it, all becomes clear.

Of all his female acquaintances, intimates and flirtations, Jefferson seems only to have deeply loved his wife, but posterity has precious few surviving scraps to throw light on that love.

What we do know is that childbearing destroyed his wife’s health, and even knowing this, the couple took no steps to address the problem. Predictably, his wife died soon after having her seventh baby at age 33.

For the casual reader, the book includes a few surprises. It seems Jefferson hated Alexander Hamilton – who knew? George Washington grew to dislike him. And he was a poor public speaker.

But how this helps us understand the man is hard to know. Despite his sparkling prose, Burstein seems reluctant to spell out his conclusions about Jefferson. And, to be fair, Jefferson was a complex man full of contradictions.

Advertise with us

Still, a reader wants to know what the author takes away from such exhaustive scholarship, what is the bottom line? And this book seems more like trees than forest, giving much detail but rarely reaching definitive judgments.

Laura Malt Schneiderman is a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette assignment editor and interactive developer . She is co-author of the book “Kaufmann’s: The Family That Built Pittsburgh’s Famed Department Store.”