James Beard and International Association of Culinary Professionals Award–winning author Tamar Adler’s “Feast on Your Life” tries to do in her kitchen what Annie Dillard did at Tinker Creek: share with the reader minute observations, collected through a tenacious practice of noticing and appreciating such phenomenon as a mulberry bursting through its fine skin in the hand or the hint of cinnamon in a cherry picked from the backyard.
These ruminations, which read as diary entries, sometimes lead to a wholesome message and often are complete in themselves. Sometimes scooping out the cream today means that tomorrow, the yogurt will be lean, and you’ll have to find something else to be joyful about, and that’s OK.
Other entries border on poetry; “September 11” reads:
Salted egg
Salty egg, salted egg, hundred-year egg, thousand-year egg, tea egg, poached egg, fried egg, coddled egg. I shiver imagining whoever first broke the spherical coherence and scrambled it. Shattered egg.
For the reader disposed to a light, noncommittal, whimsical read, the book may be a delight, a new way to see one’s time in the kitchen, a challenge to try something new or an invitation to think differently about a familiar dish. A simple trick is described for the nights when cooking sounds like too much of a bore or a burden to bother: pretend you are cooking for an interesting stranger you’ve invited to your table.
As the salted egg passage suggests, repetition is a keystone in the book. There are multiple entries about coffee: “coffee and a donut,” “coffee and a muffin,” “coffee with pigeons,” “bitter coffee.” One paragraph about salted butter uses the word salty more than once.
Other foods turn up again and again: apples, artichokes, beans. At times it feels like reading a food diary where Adler just lists the components of her dinner and names the people that she ate it with. No storyline to follow. A few recipes hide within the pages.
Not without its virtues, “Feast on Your Life” is certainly the first book of its kind that this reader has come across. That said, I couldn’t help but think while reading that if I had turned this in for a creative writing project, I would have gotten the following feedback: Instead of 366 (of course, it’s a leap year) short, disjointed thoughts, why not dive deeply into three or four?
Furthermore, rather than “I can’t remember who said this,” or “I might be misremembering this quote,” why not look it up and be sure? An irresistible pun about being “half-baked” might have been included in the critique to cut the tension. In other words, kill 99% of your darlings.
Conceptually, the book isn’t a flop. Food traditions are interesting — from basic and desperate plates heated hastily in the microwave at home to the intricate, richly storied meals eaten on trips to foreign countries or forays to fancy restaurants. Adler’s exploration in this book just doesn’t cut deeply enough into them.
Living in the moment and practicing mindfulness are important skills, but Adler’s yearlong food-themed meditation practice felt like an exhaustive stream of consciousness. She espouses patience and awareness while cooking and eating to discover delight every day. For the reader who doesn’t already possess these values, the book may be difficult to get through.
Or as she writes: “This is where an author tells you ‘How to read this book.’ ‘In bits each day’ is my first guidance. Or: ‘All at once.’ Or: ‘Sitting or standing up or lying down.’ … Read it in the morning. Read a little each time you’re in the kitchen. Or when you never want to return to the kitchen.”
My recommendation is: in small doses, when you’re craving adjectives, when you want to find spark in simplicity, when you’re feeling impatient and want something short to think about, when you’re feeling patient and can handle a little woo-woo, or when you want to eat potato chips for dinner.
Kaitlyn Shirey is a Westmoreland County engineer and writer.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.