Philippa Gregory likes to take characters on the margins of Tudor English history – a discarded wife or mistress – and make her a star.
She performed this trick most notably in 2001 with “The Other Boleyn Girl,” making Anne Boleyn’s sister, Mary, the protagonist and portraying Mary’s children as Henry VIII’s illegitimate son and daughter.
As with all works of fiction, the reader’s immersion in the story depends on a realistic depiction of time and place and the reader’s willingness to suspend disbelief. Gregory has mastered the former. She manages to slide small historical details into a narrative that can make a scene ring true. But turning Jane Boleyn into a believable heroine stretches credulity, as Gregory tries to do in “Boleyn Traitor,” due out Oct. 14.
Wanting a son, Henry broke with the Catholic Church and declared his first marriage invalid, freeing him to marry Anne Boleyn, one of his wife’s ladies in waiting. But Anne gave birth to a girl, a humiliation for Henry.
A miscarriage or two later, Henry decided to get rid of Anne, but he wasn’t willing to go through another lengthy process to do so. Instead, he had her accused of sleeping around with several men including her brother, George, and sent them all to their deaths.
Jane, the protagonist of this novel, was George’s wife. She had a front-row seat to the coerced testimony and rigged trials that led to Anne’s, George’s and four other men’s executions. At the very least, those terrifying events should have taught her that Henry considered himself above the law and adultery against himself to be a capital crime.
After Anne’s beheading, Henry married one of her ladies in waiting, who had the good grace to deliver a son and promptly die. At this point, the king’s chief minister, Thomas Cromwell, persuaded him to make a political marriage to a German princess from a minor Protestant state. No one, not even Hilary Mantel in her Cromwell trilogy, ever described Cromwell as a warm, gentle guy, but here he is presented as a kindly mentor and protector.
Like a Tinder date gone bad, Henry regretted marriage No. 4 as soon as he laid eyes on his bride — who wisely agreed to his terms for an annulment. Henry then married wife No. 5 — one of wife No. 4’s ladies in waiting (seeing a pattern?). He also had Cromwell executed for the marital debacle.
Through all these turns of fortune, Jane managed to stay in or regain her post as lady in waiting. For reasons that beggar the imagination, Jane chose to help the teen bride No.5 have secret meetings with a handsome young courtier, Thomas Culpeper.
The novel tries to pass off Jane’s motivations as the small voice of rebellion against a despot, but this justification doesn’t hold water. No one could believe she could oppose Henry after witnessing how he annihilated his opposition to get rid of queens 1 and 2.
The novel further explains Jane’s actions as having been done in the name of love. Insert spit take here. No woman in her late 30s who lived through her own husband’s capital trial would be stupid or naive enough to risk her life for someone else’s “true love,” especially between a flirty queen and a womanizing courtier.
Yet historically, Jane’s reason for helping queen No. 5 meet secretly with Culpeper remains a mystery. It is the one action in Jane’s life that does not seem predicated on self-preservation. Did she believe Henry would die soon and see some advantage to herself in promoting the queen’s liaison?
Perhaps it is better to view a novel as a novel, the characters as different people from the historical figures on which they’re based. Perhaps historical fiction can be light on history and long on fiction.
By that measure, “Boleyn Traitor” works — for a light read. Just don’t ask too many questions.
Laura Malt Schneiderman is an assignment editor and interactive developer for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. She is co-author of the book “Kaufmann’s: The Family That Built Pittsburgh’s Famed Department Store.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.