Some of us (cough) search the Post-Gazette archives online, typing in terms like “homicide,” “killed” and oh, let’s say, “severed.” Long-forgotten stories have come to light through such searches. Yet remarkably, neither of the two Pittsburgh cases featured in “Pennsylvania’s Coldest Cases: Ten Unsolved Murders that Rocked the Keystone State” — published in April — were among those search results.

The reasons soon surface. These cases and the others in this book are not just cold but frozen, roughly a hundred years old. Mismanagement of crime scenes, police corruption, the passage of time, loss of records and the lack of DNA evidence has stymied, likely forever, finding the solutions to these mysteries.

The first Pittsburgh case involved the Feely family of 312 S. Braddock Ave., Point Breeze. In 1936, Eleanor Feely and her children — Bobby, 5, and Janice, 3 — were found dead in their home, the children strangled and wounded by an ice pick to the head, the mother strangled with a rope, the handle of a claw hammer having been used to twist it. An ice pick lay to her right. All the bodies also had non-fatal stab wounds. Oddly, the room showed no signs of a struggle.

The husband and father, Martin Feely, had been out of town during the killings. Police initially speculated that Mrs. Feely had been depressed and killed the children then herself, but a coroner’s jury drew the more likely conclusion: That all three deaths were murders. Police were never able to arrest anyone for the crimes.

Advertise with us

The second Pittsburgh case may not have even involved murders. When Hugh “Oyster Paddy” O’Donnell’s tavern was demolished in 1906, workmen found two human skeletons buried under the kitchen. Were they the remains of murdered people? If so, whose? We shall never know. However, the event gives the author the chance to delve into Oyster Paddy’s colorful life and criminal world.

More than anything, the incidents featured here reveal more about their times than their crimes. The police of the first half of the 20th century had few tools with which to work, mostly witness statements (often unreliable), fingerprints (often non-existent) and tire tracks (often unmatchable).

Moreover, police corruption ran rampant during the early part of the 20th century, particularly during the 1920s, when the prohibition against alcoholic beverages spawned widespread lawbreaking and organized crime. Crime scenes were open to the press and public, who stole evidence, even human remains. Given all these factors, one might be surprised that the police solved any murders at all.

Author and Harrisburg hairstylist Marlin Bressi has made a second career mining Pennsylvania’s history of the strange and grim. He produces the podcast “Pennsylvania Oddities” and has written several volumes with the same title. A nimble researcher, he uncovers many obscure yet fascinating events.

His reporting, however, is superficial. He doesn’t go beyond what newspapers published at the time of the incidents. A bit more digging into police reports and court documents might have lent dimension to these tales – newspapers can only be history’s first draft.

Advertise with us

Perhaps the most gruesome and mysterious of these cases is the 1932 murder and mutilation of Norman Bechtel in Philadelphia. The killer stabbed a circle around the victim’s heart and carved marks on his face, leading to speculation that the murder was part of an occult ritual.

Soon, however, the case devolved into a sea of conflicting evidence. A jury found a Black chauffeur guilty of the crime in 1937, but flimsy evidence and an account of police brutality led to the verdict being overturned. Too often in these cases, the evidence suggested contradictory conclusions — and no one’s word was reliable.

Bressi’s research deserves commendation, but he or some other author might wish to inspect these stories more deeply.

Laura Malt Schneiderman is an assignment editor and interactive developer for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. She is co-author of the book “Kaufmann’s: The Family That Built Pittsburgh’s Famed Department Store.”