
Growing up as the daughter of a Lutheran pastor in Johnstown, Pa., my world was seeped in the Christian Bible. Famously, when asked as a preschooler to say just one line as the “Head Angel” in the school Christmas pageant — something like “The baby is in the stable!” — I instead busted out the full “For unto you a child is born!” speech from the second chapter of Luke instead.
That I knew it at 5 years old makes sense, because we really doubled-down on the Bible during Advent and Christmas. And I loved it. Of course, I didn’t know I was a writer yet, but I loved the words. The fancier and King James-ier the better: Foretold! Unto! Babe! Swaddling! These were and are words of mystery and wonder, of hope and joy. I read them year after year with delight, and still do.
Writers who are not Christian (or even religious) tell me they feel a twinge of envy when reading or hearing the gospels at Christmas. The writing is so good. Every year, I’m blown away again by how terrific this nativity tale is as a story, how it feels both realistic to how we humans behave and majestically not of this earth.
For many years, when it came to Christmas, the Biblical Gospels, especially Luke, were it for me. What could come close? Then I read David Sedaris’s “Holidays on Ice.”
Let me be clear about two things. First, this book is at the way opposite end of the Christmas book spectrum from the Bible. And second, I’m not really recommending this book to you, as it, sadly, has not aged well. The title story, in which Sedaris recounts his time working as Santa’s elf at the giant Macy’s on 34th Street in Manhattan, features a slur for mentally challenged people that immediately puts off today’s readers.
Yet my memory of reading this book is one of pure delight. Sedaris is unsparingly scathing in his assessment of every single person involved in his recounting — from the other elves (most of whom were trying to become soap opera actors), to the questionable Santas Macy’s employed, to the parents who dragged their screaming kids to have their photos taken, to the kids themselves who peed and threw up frequently. Sedaris is also merciless towards himself, a grown man with no better job prospects than pretending to be an elf for pay. It’s a chronicle of unserious people.
For years, those were my two suggestions when asked for a good Christmas read: the Bible or David Sedaris. Honestly, you could do worse to sum up my personality. I tried other Christmas books, but they were too sentimental (offending my taste), or used Christmas as an aesthetic instead of as a focus (offending my beliefs).

But thankfully for you, on the recommendation of one of my many amazing writer friends, I sat down with the Irish writer Claire Keegan’s lauded “Small Things Like These” last Advent. It’s a novella and can (in my opinion, should) be read in one sitting.
Like most of Keegan’s work, it’s set in Ireland, this time in 1985, and focuses on a coal deliveryman, Bill Furlong, and the community he serves, including an imperious Mother Superior at a local convent. He gradually becomes aware that everything is not all right at the convent. He also begins to realize he will have to make a hard choice about what, if anything, he’s going to do about that. And then, in the last few pages, he acts.
Tonally, the story couldn’t be more different than “Holidays on Ice” — every choice made is harrowing, every character depicted is complex. It’s no Christmas Gospel story, either; any angels that arrive to give direction go unheard and unseen.
But if anything, Keegan’s novella is the Christmas story in the way we rarely think of it: a scared, single teenage girl, about to give birth, far from home, in need of aid and the people who must decide if they will help her. It wonders what it might mean to take an idea of love and to put it into action.
It asks us, this Christmas, what better people might we become if we did?
Shannon Reed is a teaching associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh, and, most recently, the author of “Why We Read: On Bookworms, Libraries and Just One More Page Before Lights Out.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.