
Some legends say Harry Truman was the first president to pardon the poultry industry’s annual offering of turkeys. Some say it was John F. Kennedy. But it didn’t become a formal rite until 1989.
While animal rights groups protested nearby, George H.W. Bush declared that he was pardoning the turkey and sending it to a children’s farm close to Washington. “He’s granted a Presidential pardon as of right now,” Bush declared. And every president since has followed this absurd tradition.
CONSIDER THE TURKEY
By Peter Singer
Princeton University Press ($9.95)
Moral philosopher Peter Singer quips in “Consider the Turkey,” his newest offering, that “[t]he US Constitution authorizes the president to grant a pardon for a federal crime, but no one has ever suggested a crime for which the turkeys are supposedly being pardoned.”
“Consider the Turkey” borrows its naming convention from David Foster Wallace’s “Consider the Lobster,” a 2004 essay that empathizes with the lobster and asks pointed questions about the cruelties humans inflict on another sentient species for our own pleasure. But don’t expect much of Wallace’s charm or self-deprecating humor here.
Singer’s self-righteousness is sharp and humorless, as he details the processes by which the millions of turkeys consumed during our holiday feasts live painful, cramped lives, terrorized by poorly paid workers, who are in turn terrorized by their managers. The paragraph quoted above goes on: “Does it make families in the United States feel better, as they chew on the corpse of one of the 46 million turkeys killed annually for Thanksgiving dinners, to know that somewhere, two of them are still alive?”
Singer is right, of course, in identifying the raising of turkeys as a moral catastrophe. The way we permit animals to be raised for our consumption is an obvious problem, regardless of the scale of our need. Factory farms should be much more tightly regulated or banned outright.
But, rightly or wrongly, however, the massive demand for animal products isn’t going anywhere. People like eating meat, and many people argue that they need it, so we need solutions at scale if we want to solve this complex problem.
It’s easier to recommend individual penance. For moral Thanksgiving choices, Singer suggests either a high-brow veganism, or, if one must, an omnivore meal featuring a turkey purchased from a small farm where animals live fuller, happier lives. Singer makes a bit of a morally condescending assumption here: Provided an affordable option, who wouldn’t prefer to purchase a butchered turkey knowing that it had enjoyed its brief life?
For a conscientious reader who can’t afford Singer’s morality, or whose body can’t support a vegan diet, Singer offers no action to address the sense of moral debt his argument creates. Perhaps the discomfort is the point. Or perhaps, as Singer later suggests, we should all fill awkward silences over Thanksgiving dinner by enlightening the people who have invited us to their tables as to the brutal ways factory farmed turkeys are artificially inseminated, as if we were all home on break during our first semester of college and Ethics 101.
Evidence matters, but so does style. Petulant rhetoric does not change opinions, nor does it inspire. Just ask the Democrats who harangued their own voters relentlessly for three weeks prior to election day and have since been wondering incredulously why those voters stayed home — or, worse, turned away from them.
“Consider the Turkey” also arrives at a poor moment to act upon an argument for advancing American farming ethics. In January, MAGA apparatchiks across the government will get to work disrupting institutions of democracy, the public safety net, and longstanding — if often hypocritical — commitments to human rights, not to mention animal rights. The meat industry will benefit, while progress on animal welfare will be set back years.
If those of us who care about animal rights arrive at the next presidential inauguration in 2029 having preserved both democracy and the status quo of those rights, we should consider it a victory. Then, animal rights activists can and must make a more inviting, friendly, and solutions-focused argument for improving animal welfare than what Singer offers here.
Joshua D. Graber is a writer and software engineer from Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.