
Rob Sheffield’s place as one of rock’s best critics and one of pop culture’s most keen-eyed observers has long been solidified. His musings have graced the pages of Rolling Stone magazine for nearly 30 years now, between books about the life of David Bowie and the music of Duran Duran, as well as a highly praised reflection on The Beatles’ career.
With so much gravitas praising venerated artists, it may come as a surprise that his latest book, “Heartbreak is the National Anthem: How Taylor Swift Reinvented Pop Music,” centers around megastar Taylor Swift, the omnipresent musician that is equally loved and loathed, who Sheffield feels is the star of our lifetime.
HEARTBREAK IS THE NATIONAL ANTHEM: HOW TAYLOR SWIFT REINVENTED POP MUSIC
By Rob Sheffield
Dey Street Books ($27.99)
Yes, Sheffield is a Swifty. The rest of us: “normal people.”
Read More
Throughout the pages of “Heartbreak is the National Anthem,” Sheffield digs through the origins of her prolific career, albums and songs, detailing what he feels makes them so effective. Told chronologically through her releases, with a smattering of biographical details sprinkled throughout, this book focuses primarily on her musical output and its resulting cultural impact. No behind-the-curtain reveals here.
Sheffield dishes like an expert who has earned more than enough Swift friendship bracelets in recent years, while sharing anecdotes which will more than likely make him the envy of many others. How many other fans has Swift directly asked to help pick out her set list?
Sheffield’s insights are both professional and personal. He and Swift are friends. Yet, this does not stand in the way of his candor. He writes: “You can’t fully appreciate her without appreciating the wide range of visceral reactions she brings out in people.”
“Sometimes it feels like I’m hearing her read my diary aloud, making me feel garish and exposed,” he writes. This affirmation distills why he finds her music so appealing: her sincerity. But that sincerity is also the primary reason she is disliked. She is a songwriter in possession of a very powerful medium that can immortalize those who she feels have done her wrong.
But many other artists also pull no lyrical punches, so why the scorn for Swift? Is it because she is successful? Because she is not the ingénue society wants her to be? Or, is it because she is not afraid of defending herself? And how does she continue to dominate like she does?
Perhaps because Taylor Swift cares deeply about storytelling, in both her music and life — and she often attempts to retain control over the narrative surrounding her. Consider how punk rock of her it was to re-record and re-release her early albums after the publishing rights to her original catalog were bought by a hedge fund.
I genuinely enjoyed this book. Like anything else Sheffield writes, his insights are sharp and reflective. His words are both elevating and humbling, as he’s a writer who knows how to frame the perfect verbal snapshot.
“Heartbreak is the National Anthem” surprised me, however, as Sheffield generally writes retrospectives of lauded performers at the end of their careers. Here, he writes about a mid-career Swift like he would write about any other idol, because he simply feels she deserves this now.
It all comes back to the songwriting. In writing about her hit “All Too Well,” Sheffield notes that “In the Swiftian universe, any lost scarf is a ticking time bomb that can take years to explode into a song. No scrap of the past is safe from showing up again — no snow globe, no snowmobile, no snow or beach. She’s a detective who never files the cold cases away.”
He seems as fascinated by her process as he does by her output. To Sheffield, Taylor Swift is both princess and provocateur. Or as he put it: “Taylor is a true daughter of Madonna — she needs to connect on that pop pleasure level, whatever moods she’s expressing, so these songs are designed to work even if you’re in a summer mood. But today, they belong deep in the snow.”
Don’t worry, Rob Sheffield brought his snow shovel. When it comes to Taylor Swift, he’s unafraid to dig.
Edward Banchs is a freelance writer, author and independent scholar based in Pittsburgh. His latest book is “Scream for Me, Africa!: Heavy Metal Identities in Post-Colonial Africa.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.