In his 1945 lecture “Existentialism is Humanism,” Jean-Paul Sartre writes that a key to existentialist philosophy is that “existence precedes essence” — people, not gods or kings or any sort of magic, are responsible for their own behavior. Novelist Karl Ove Knausgaard (along with translator Martin Aitken) tests Sartre’s claim in “The Third Realm,” which continues the Morgenstjernen series and provides readers with a series of complicated characters, within seemingly isolated and intimate chapters, who make tough, existence-defining choices.

THE THIRD REALM

By Karl Ove Knausgaard, translated by Martin Aitken

Penguin Press ($32)

Advertise with us

About a third of the way into the novel we’re introduced to Jarle, a neurologist who is summoned to investigate an improbable “re-awakening” of a brain-dead man. In the course of the chapter, Knausgaard gives us access to the book Jarle is writing about the nature of consciousness.

In a frantic session, Jarle writes, in reference to mathematician Alan Turing, “the explanans must be of a higher order than the explanandum — which is to say that a brain cannot explain the brain, consciousness cannot explain consciousness. For that we need a more general principle in order to explain the particular phenomenon. Something of a higher order.”

For Knausgaard’s previous novels in this series, and this one, those explanations of a higher order are always related to the sudden appearance of a new star in the sky. It’s important to note that the actions of the characters in this text often take on guises and decisions that feel terrifying. But they also make very human, very everyday choices about who they love and what is it they want out of their lives.

These are, strangely enough, quintessential existential questions, and ones very much directly related to responsibility. There are characters cheating on spouses or deciding to attend black metal raves with a man they’ve just met. But there are also characters hearing voices or investigating a young student seemingly possessed after the appearance of this new star. For Knausgaard, these disparate events have a conjoined nature; one which cannot be extricated.

A number of background characters from other novels in the series are primary actors in this one. Thus, when readers in-the-know are presented with the difficult mental instability of Tove right at the beginning of the novel, long-time fans of the series will be familiar with her husband Arne, a primary actor in its prequels.

Advertise with us

This choice in perspective is both limiting and illuminating, depending on the reader, as you might have no previous expectations of Tove (from Arne’s perspective), or you might have all the expectations in the world, and might be hungry to know why she’s been making the choices she’s been making. This theme of choice and who bears the responsibilities of those choices, including the reader, is paramount to both the novel and its perspectives.

Over the course of its 493 pages, “The Third Realm” never steers too far away from the sudden appearance of this new star. But, with that said, it never completely alters the gravitational pull of the lives of these characters either.

Instead, it’s something in-between those two extremes. There are explanations, musings, arguments, and near-impossible acts of god (or something else entirely). But no matter how close or far these characters are from the new light of their shared sky, they continue to make very real, and very human, determinations.

How much of our decision-making is our own responsibility? In that responsibility, how much of it is merely the small signals of our brain-tissue? How could, Knausgaard writes, “such an abrupt and microscopic electrical impulse occurring in such total darkness represent a face? A voice? A landscape of fells and fjords?”

It is a question as impossible to answer as whether or not the new star has fundamentally changed anything “real” about these characters’ lives, beyond the faint light that seems to drape like a pall through these chapters. But your answer to it, as a reader, is an answer to Sartre’s assertion. In the end, this is a novel of both existence and essence, but the ordering of those two things is entirely up to you.

Matthew Minicucci is a poet and essayist. He is an assistant professor at the University of Alabama.