
The Cliffs,” New York Times best-selling author J. Courtney Sullivan’s sixth novel, centers on Jane Flanagan, a white Harvard librarian whose career and marriage are in shambles because of her alcohol abuse. After a recent and disastrous blackout, the consequences of Jane’s behavior push her back toward the small coastal Maine town of Awadapquit where she grew up, forcing her to live in her late mother’s house because she has nowhere else to go.
Thanks to her childhood best friend who now runs a local inn, Jane learns that the formerly abandoned cliffside Victorian home she loved to visit during her teenage years has been purchased by a new owner, who in turn hires her to investigate the house’s history, ostensibly to honor its prior inhabitants.
THE CLIFFS
By J. Courtney Sullivan
Knopf ($29)
What Jane does not know is that her own family history intersects with the house in ways she would have never guessed, and the new owner’s true motives are more complicated than they first appear. Despite Jane’s skepticism regarding the supernatural, her investigations also lead her into several increasingly persuasive encounters with a spiritual medium, who gives her a pressing message to deliver from one of the house’s several ghosts.
While Jane’s story forms the book’s central spine, Sullivan interweaves occasional chapters featuring other women whose lives were marked by their time at the Victorian, beginning with the present and moving backward through time. It takes a while for the logic of these somewhat unexpected shifts in point-of-view to become clear, but readers will be rewarded for staying the course.
Sullivan also makes the deft move of revealing answers to several of the book’s most pressing dramatic questions near the book’s midpoint. This increases the dramatic irony as the reader shifts from wondering how the pieces might fit together to wondering how and if the characters will ultimately assemble the full picture.
Ghost brought to light
Along the way, Sullivan takes great care to acknowledge the violence perpetrated by European settlers of the area as well as to draw attention to more recent wrongs in terms of how museums and exhibits have often erased, co-opted, or distorted the stories of women and the Abenaki people. Though these periodic detours from the central narrative are well-intended and an attempt is made to contextualize them within Jane’s work as an archivist, some readers may find them too didactic in tone.
Where Sullivan most successfully engages with these historical injustices, however, is in bringing some of these imagined women to life on the page. The chapters about the Shaker woman who came to the house to work as a servant and the Abenaki woman who still haunts the eponymous cliffs, for example, are among the most moving and beautifully rendered sections of the novel.
The book in some respects evokes Daniel Mason’s “North Woods” — the two novels share an ambition to tell the many stories of the inhabitants of a New England house over centuries, with a touch of the supernatural. Both also focus primarily on the stories of white settlers and their descendants, but with an awareness of how such stories are part of a much larger and more complex narrative that includes the region’s Indigenous peoples.
That said, “The Cliffs’’ will appeal more to readers who enjoy a fairly straightforward narrative arc with a single central protagonist. Jane’s struggles to put her life back together while navigating a family legacy of alcohol abuse are as fundamental to the novel as the larger project of shining light on the lost stories of the women of the cliffside Victorian.
As Jane reflects near the end of the novel, “Human beings did so much damage to one another just by being alive. To the people they loved most, and to the ones they knew so little about that they could convince themselves they weren’t even people.”
“The Cliffs” does not only excavate the damage, but also offers the reader one possible version of the journey to recovery.
Jules Fitz Gerald is a writer originally from Pittsburgh. Her most recent fiction can be found or is forthcoming in A Public Space, The Common, Salamander, Wigleaf, and Witness.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.