
Where were you when the world ran out of toilet paper? As the COVID-19 pandemic hit the United States in March, 2020, the first wave of panic buying and more time spent at home meant that store shelves were empty of common household goods, most notably (at least in media coverage): toilet paper.
As the pandemic wore on, shortages appeared on more goods, and increasingly more critical goods, from milk and hand sanitizer to baby formula and rubber gloves. In “How the World Ran Out of Everything: Inside the Global Supply Chain,” Peter S. Goodman goes on a deep dive into the root causes of the supply chain breakdown and exposes decades of faulty assumptions about the universal benefits of globalization.
Unsurprisingly, Goodman’s reporting takes us first to China, where American businesses have long taken advantage of low labor costs, ample supplies of raw materials, and subsidies from the Chinese government.
HOW THE WORLD RAN OUT OF EVERYTHING: INSIDE THE GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN
By Peter S. Goodman
Mariner Books ($30)
However, in leveraging China’s manufacturing capabilities to maximize profits, these same businesses have allowed domestic manufacturing capacity to deteriorate, instead concentrating enormous risk in China’s ability to deliver a steady stream of goods. What’s more, Goodman notes the misuse of “Lean Management” as a mandate from the consulting class to eliminate inventory in favor of short-term financial benefits, a tactic that further increases the risk of shortages.
But even if China can make enough to satiate the appetites of American consumers, goods located half a world away are of no use to the businesses that commission them. Ocean shipping, railroads, and trucking all play a key role in getting the right item to the right place.
Taking a closer look, Goodman again finds a focus on immediate shareholder value standing in diametric opposition to risk management and concerns for supply chain resilience.
Bad for workers
While the specifics of each industry are different, the themes are the same: government deregulation allowing a few, powerful corporations to control the vast majority of the infrastructure and dictate pricing to customers; worker exploitation through the erosion of collective bargaining and non-compliance with labor law; and cost-cutting measures that leave infrastructure out-of-date and void of excess capacity.
Goodman, a veteran economics reporter, makes for a compelling narrator as he collects first-hand accounts about the broad-ranging effects of these policies on ordinary workers. At one point, he looks at “Precision Scheduled Railroading,” a system in which trains are not run on a set schedule, but in specific response to the demands of their largest customers, the Walmarts and Amazons of the world.
While fewer trains with more cargo are more efficient for the railroads, a secondary effect is an uncertain and erratic schedule for the workers who run, maintain, and load cargo on and off these trains. Meanwhile, the likes of small-scale farmers and ranchers are at the mercy of large retailers to decide when their time-sensitive agricultural goods can be shipped.
In the book’s final section, Goodman turns his eye towards potential solutions. Can “reshoring,” bringing manufacturing back to the United States, prevent rampant shortages when another crisis hits? Can manufacturing in Mexico serve as a middle ground between low costs and long distances? Can effective U.S. trade policy reduce our reliance on China?
While there is some promise in any of these solutions, Goodman ultimately dismisses them as true answers, instead concluding that the global supply chain is characterized by a “permanent fragility arising from dependence on exploited labor,” and that true resilience will come from worker protections, antitrust laws, and the reinvigoration of government oversight agencies.
Though the book’s focus on shortages within the United States may make it most appealing to an American audience, Goodman’s tour through the global supply chain will be an intriguing read for anyone who wants to understand the shortages brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic and the future of similar risks.
“How the World Ran Out of Everything” has the potential to join Pietra Rivoli’s immensely popular “Travels of a T-Shirt in a Global Economy” as a general interest breakdown of a broad and complex topic.
Amy David is a Clinical Professor of Supply Chain and Operations Management at the Mitchell E. Daniels School of Business at Purdue University.
Correction: A previous version of this story misspelled “Pietra Rivoli.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.