
In 1935, with the nation’s unemployment rate at about 20%, Congress passed and President Roosevelt signed legislation creating the Works Progress Administration. Among the WPA’s many projects was Federal One, an initiative to provide jobs to struggling writers, musicians, painters, photographers, actors, stagehands and directors.
In “The Playbook,” James Shapiro — a professor of English and Comparative Literature at Columbia University and the author, among other books, of “Shakespeare in a Divided America” — provides a fascinating account of the rise and fall of the Federal Theater Project.
Between 1935 and 1939, the Federal Theater Project, led by Vassar professor Hallie Flanagan, employed 12,000 professionals and staged over 1,000 productions in 29 states, attended by thirty million people, many of whom had never seen a play before.
Offerings ran the gamut from traditional fare to plays about contemporary issues, including racism, slum housing and the threat of fascism. Set in Haiti, with an all-Black cast, the so-called voodoo Macbeth, which launched the career of Orson Welles, was seen by 120,000 people in Harlem, on Broadway and during a national tour that included the Jim Crow South.
THE PLAYBOOK: A STORY OF THEATER, DEMOCRACY AND THE MAKING OF A CULTURE WAR
By James Shapiro
Penguin Press ($30)
De-funded by Congress following allegations of “un-American activities” in hearings chaired by Rep. Martin Dies, D-Texas, the Federal Theater Project, Shapiro argues, was the victim of culture war and identity politics tactics and strategies that are widely used today.
Vice President John Nance Garner, who had turned against the New Deal and opposed a third term for President Roosevelt, played a pivotal behind-the-scenes role in the establishment of Dies’ special committee. Charming, well-spoken and shrewd, Dies used the hearings to suggest that New Deal progressives and advocates of racial equality were advancing the communists’ agenda.
Shapiro attributes much of Dies’ success to what “has now become normalized in American politics”: playing to the media. He dispensed with executive sessions, barred the general public from hearings and “kept a fresh stream of accusations coming” to give the press no time to investigate them.
Dies was also emboldened because government officials did not push back when, in essence, he anointed his committee the arbiter of American values. When Secretary of the Interior Harold Ickes prepared a counterattack entitled “Playing with Loaded Dice,” President Roosevelt didn’t allow him to deliver it. When Roosevelt slammed the committee in the fall of 1938 as “flagrantly unfair,” the rebuke, Shapiro writes, “came too late and Dies knew it.”
Equally important, “The Playbook” documents self-censorship within the Federal Theater, whose leaders knew how vulnerable they were to criticism. The director of promotion for the theatrical adaptation of Sinclair Lewis’ novel “It Can’t Happen Here,” for example, forbade any references in the text to political figures, foreign governments, dictatorships or fascism, and ordered the destruction of a poster that alluded to Hitler.
The Federal Theater Project shelved a proposed play about sharecroppers in the South. Despite revisions extending over years, Shapiro writes, “Liberty Deferred” remained unproduced when the program shut its doors. A deeply researched unconventional dystopian fantasy, the play featured “brilliant and devastating” scenes of murdered Blacks who meet once a year to see whose treatment was the worst, call out the racism of privileged whites and leave the U.S. Senate gallery after members filibuster and table anti-lynching legislation.
In 2021, U.S. Reps. Ted Lieu, D-Calif., and Teresa Leger Fernandez, D-N.M., urged their House colleagues to pass a “21st Century Federal Writers’ Project Act.” Their timing, Shapiro emphasizes, couldn’t have been worse.
Congress, state legislatures and school boards have become battlegrounds for culture warriors. Drawing on Dies’ playbook, they have removed from the curriculum and censored performances of “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” “Three Sisters,” “Oklahoma” and “Fences” (because it has no white characters) and removed scenes involving “sexual conduct” from Romeo and Juliet.
Apparently, Shapiro concludes, we haven’t yet learned that “the health of democracy and theater, twin-born in ancient Greece, has always been mutually dependent.”
Glenn C. Altschuler is The Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Emeritus Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.