Revisiting the characters and setting of his best-selling 2009 novel, “Brooklyn,” Irish writer Colm Tóibín picks up the threads of protagonist Eilis Lacey’s life in his new novel, “Long Island.”

Eilis is now in her forties, still married to Tony Fiorello, and raising their two children in a suburb of Lindenhurst in the often-suffocating bosom of her Italian in-laws and their extended family. This is a life that Eilis both did and did not choose, and it is Tóibín’s great talent that the reader is immediately immersed in the heartrending ambivalence that has defined Eilis’s life.

As readers of “Brooklyn” will know, twenty years prior Eilis faced a terrible choice: to make her life in America with her husband Tony or to return to Ireland where she had the sudden opportunity for employment and a chance at romance with Jim Farrell, a young man with good looks and steady business prospects. Put this way it seems a choice between two men, but much more is at stake: a question of personal identity, between an American or an Irish life.

LONG ISLAND: A NOVEL

Advertise with us

By Colm Tóibín

Scribner ($28)

For years, Eilis seemed to live with her choice to return to America with something like happiness, partly because Tony has always so clearly needed her and because she was content in motherhood.

But at the beginning of “Long Island” this idea of life is damaged by news that Tony has fathered a child with another woman. Worse, the woman’s husband has threatened to drop the baby on Eilis and Tony’s doorstep when it’s born. He refuses to have the baby in his house. After some thought, Eilis decides she won’t have it either: In the face of this crisis, Eilis chooses to return to Ireland while Tony decides what he will do with her ultimatum.

For Eilis, returning to Ireland feels like escape, something she has often dreamed of, even if only for a little while — “slipping away, getting a train or even driving to some town and finding an anonymous hotel to spend two nights away from everyone.”

Advertise with us

However, once back in her mother’s house, she realizes her escape will come at a price. Her mother is difficult, seemingly not interested in the life Eilis has been living in America, and her best friend from the old days, Nancy Sheridan, is polite but resents how she abandoned them all those years ago. Most significantly, there is Jim Farrell who, after being left so unceremoniously by Eilis, has never married.

Jim is one of Tóibín’s most complex characters. He is a pillar of the business community and a steady personality — a man who seems to fit the local’s idea of masculine competence and determined reticence.

Inside, however, Jim is a vulnerable mess who, in his forties, is hoping for a last chance at happiness by marrying Nancy. It’s clear they’re going to be good for each other, but when Eilis shows up he is completely unmade. All of the old feelings for her are still there and he is filled with a kind of drunken recklessness. When they meet again, sparks are reignited and Eilis is once again at the center of emotional turmoil that affects nearly everyone she knows.

Coming back to Ireland has not brought Eilis any closer to understanding herself or how best to live. In fact, as she sits at Nancy’s daughter’s wedding, she looks around thinking, “No one really knew anything about her. In this pew in the cathedral, and the ones behind and in front, sat people who had lived in the town all their lives. They did not have to explain themselves.”

Nor did they have children who were so American they were vaguely embarrassed by her accent and largely indifferent about her life before they were born. The desire to reconnect with Jim Farrell stems from an old need to feel whole, to be completely known by someone.

Advertise with us

Ultimately — beautifully — Colm Tóibín renders the immigrant dilemma with compassion and verve. He has created a novel not to be missed. Perhaps most significantly for those of us who have come to love these characters, he also leaves things deliciously unresolved, perhaps holding open the opportunity for a third installment.

Jeffrey Condran is the author of the story collection “Claire, Wading into the Danube By Night” and is the co-founder and ​publisher of the independent literary press, Braddock Avenue Books.