
Tommy Orange, an enrolled member of the Cheyenne and Arapaho tribes of Oklahoma, hooks readers early in his multigenerational, multivocal new novel “Wandering Stars,” with a macabre scene from the 1864 Sand Creek Massacre, a carnage in which more than 600 federal troops attacked a village of Cheyenne and Arapaho in what is now known as Colorado.
For the intruders, killing the children “was like killing bugs at Sand Creek.” Jude Star escapes the bloodbath and lives to tell his story. Through short chapters, Jude’s narrative eventually connects with his descendant, Orvil Red Feather, who was introduced to readers in Orange’s debut novel, “There There,” published in 2018. Spanning generations, “Wandering Stars” is both a prequel and sequel to the critically-acclaimed “There There.”
WANDERING STARS
By Tommy Orange
Knopf ($29)
Jude, tired of running and facing starvation, turns himself into the U.S. soldiers, who transport him to a prison in Florida, where he is under the aegis of military officer Richard Henry Pratt, a true historical figure.
There, Pratt strips prisoners of their native culture by mandatory assimilation. Pratt seizes their blankets and clothes and tells them they “could not dress like Indians anymore.” He forces military training and, using the Bible, teaches them how to read and write in English. He also forces prisoners to take American names. Pratt later established the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania, which Jude’s son, Charles, attends.
Trauma and addiction
Soon we move to Oakland, Ca., the author’s hometown, and setting of “There There,” with Charles, an aspiring writer, who faced abuse at Carlisle: “He keeps the memory away from his thoughts, and is only reminded when something like rain touches the back of his neck, there where a man first held him down, gripped the back of his neck so hard his legs gave out on the floor of the bathroom of the boys’ quarters at Carlisle.”
Orange’s illusive prose conveys Charles’s drug-addled state, detritus from his time at the school. Laudanum, “the doomed God of dream in the tincture,” was his drug of choice.
As we move through the years, we meet Victoria Bear Shield, Orvil’s great grandmother, who continues to underscore the theme of trauma. After her mother dies, Victoria lives with adopted white parents who exploit her by treating her like the help. But Victoria is strong. She must be — her husband Melvin Red Feather abandons her leaving her to raise her daughter on her own.
The second part of the book, more cohesive than the first, picks up right after the powwow shooting in “There There.” It is 2018 in Oakland and Orvil lives with his grandmother Jacquie and great aunt Opal Viola Victoria Bear Shield. Once again, Orange highlights the painful effects of addiction in the family, this time through Orvil who floats through town with his supplier Sean, whose father cooks drugs out of his own lab.
Opal believes in Orvil, though: she takes out loans to pay for his private high school and sends him to therapy. But Orvil continues to use to alleviate the mental trauma from the powwow shooting: “The bullet made its hole, a hole I felt stayed open even though it’d been sewn shut. … [It was] asking something of me in return, like it needed to be filled, and here were these pills.”
Orange’s telling also includes intimate portrayals of Orvil’s brothers who wrestle with trauma and mental illness.
Orange draws on historical events to highlight over 150 years of trauma and addiction. Through multiple points-of-view of one family, Orange elucidates, once again, Native Americans’ struggle and continues to be one of the most powerful Native American voices in literature.
Wayne Catan is a freelance critic whose work has appeared in The New York Times, USA Today and the Minneapolis Star-Tribune.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.