
Two questions haunt “Jumpman,” the newest book by Johnny Smith. First: Do we need another book about Michael Jordan? Second: Which Michael Jordan is this book about? Dr. Smith tries to answer the first question by answering the second: “Jumpman” argues that looking at either a Michael Jordan of overwhelming talent or a Michael Jordan of overwhelming determination and ambition, as he suggests previous biographies have attempted to do, leaves out the essential role that Jordan’s navigation of race and racism played in shaping him during his first few seasons in the NBA.
In making his arguments, Dr. Smith has constructed something that’s less a traditional biography and more a series of case studies: a chapter on the famous “It’s Gotta Be The Shoes” commercials; a chapter on Jordan and Magic Johnson; a chapter on “The Last Dance,” the documentary-slash-hagiography that came out in 2020, and Jordan’s post-playing-career choices. Each of these is an interesting exercise in choosing specific threads and following them, and each reads like the kind of long-form think piece one might have expected to read in Grantland or GQ. This structure, though, does mean that the book seems to start and restart.
JUMPMAN: THE MAKING AND MEANING OF MICHAEL JORDAN
By Johnny Smith
Basic Books ($30)
“Jumpman” carries a formidable subtitle: “The making and meaning of Michael Jordan.” And it begins with a formidable epigraph, a James Baldwin quote that ends, “You were not expected to aspire to excellence: you were expected to make peace with mediocrity.” And it concludes that epigraph by pointing out that “The Fire Next Time,” from which that quote was drawn, was published in 1963: Michael Jordan’s birth year.
That’s the experience of reading large swathes of “Jumpman” — Dr. Smith repeatedly brings together interesting claims, solid research and minor coincidences. The overall effect is, more or less, that of being at a dinner party with a somewhat meandering professor who has a deep knowledge of their field and has recently picked up some cool factoids on a trivia podcast: It’s often interesting, it’s sometimes endearing, and it’s frustratingly difficult to tell what’s the deep knowledge and what’s the cool factoid.
While I can’t speak to his personal directness or the quality of his dinner parties, Dr. Smith does clearly have a deep knowledge of sports history, of which he is an associate professor at Georgia Tech. “Jumpman” is his fifth book; he’s previously written about Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Muhammad Ali and Malcolm X, and John Wooden. “Blood Brothers,” the book about Muhammad Ali and Malcolm X, was turned into a Netflix documentary, which got positive reviews for the breadth of its research and some criticism for relying on platitudes.
The breadth of the research in “Jumpman” is, I think, solid. Citations for endnotes speckle the pages; there are references to obscure newspaper articles, interviews, academic texts, everything from W.E.B. DuBois and Michelle Alexander to Michael Wilbon and Diane Sawyer.
That’s not to say that everything in Dr. Smith’s book feels fresh, though. I haven’t read Sam Smith’s “The Jordan Rules” or David Halberstam’s “Playing for Keeps” since I was about 14, but I kept coming across quotes and thinking “wait, I know that from somewhere,” then flipping to the references at the back and finding a citation to one of those two texts. That’s not surprising: “The Jordan Rules” and “Playing for Keeps” have loomed large over what one might call the still-growing field of Critical Jordan Studies since their publications in 1992 and 1999, respectively.
It does make parts of “Jumpman” feel stale or derivative, though, as Dr. Smith winds up offering a quick critical-theory-inflected take on someone else’s take on someone else’s take, citing each source along the way. Imagine one of ESPN’s sports debate shows if each participant had to say whom they were paraphrasing and what the original quote had been before they offered their take on the paraphrase. Historically, blessedly rigorous; practically, somewhat clunky.
Michael Hodges lives in Seattle, Washington. Their first book, “An Idea of Feathers,” was published in 2022.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.