It’s 1921, and famous author “Willie” Somerset Maugham takes his secretary-cum gigolo, Gerald Haxton, with him to Penang, in British Malaya, now Malaysia. Willie is facing bankruptcy and needs material for a new bestseller. There, he meets Lesley Hamlyn, the discontented wife of an old friend. They bond over their sham marriages and constrained lives. She confesses a past love affair with a Chinese dissident and her connection to a local murder years earlier. She feels unburdened, and he gets his story.

“The House of Doors”

By Tan Twan Eng

Bloomsbury Publishing ($28.99)

Advertise with us

While Willie and Lesley’s transactional friendship is the centerpiece of Tan Twan Eng’s “The House of Doors,” long-listed for the Booker Prize, its main character is the vibrant Penang of the early twentieth century. It’s a cultural crossroads where Chinese revolutionaries scheme and unskilled laborers pull rickshaws bearing British functionaries to fancy clubs.

During their visit, Willie and Gerald stay at Lesley’s Cassowary House by the sea: “The wind frisked the topmost branches of the trees. Golden orioles flitted around the garden. Listening to the waves fizzing on the sand, Willie felt the knots in his body slowly unravelling.”

Mr. Eng excels at setting an atmospheric mood, whether it be in a bustling and exotic enclave or a home where secrets are traded over tea and gin. He sets much of the novel’s action on verandas, transitional spaces evoking romance. After Willie’s departure from Penang, Lesley moves to a South African sheep farm, where her house has a rustic “stoep” instead. By then, romance exists for her only in memories — and in Willie’s fictionalized account of them.

Of the two protagonists, Lesley is the less convincing. Born and raised in a middle class family in Penang and rumored to have “some Chinese blood,” she nevertheless communes with the town’s elite Europeans, having wed Robert Hamlyn, a worldly English barrister nearly twice her age. Part society matron/​part feminist, she conforms to the expectations of her role as she sympathizes with marginalized women, which leads to some untenable positions.

She tolerates her own husband’s infidelity, while simultaneously condemning Chinese revolutionary Sun Yat Sen for his polygamy. Later, she lies under oath to protect a philandering friend who claims she’s been raped. In struggling to reconcile her conflicting impulses, she develops a wobbly sense of justice. We don’t trust Lesley to know her own mind.

Advertise with us

Willie, on the other hand, knows himself and makes his priorities clear, at least to us. For him, personal contentment and professional success is paramount. A closeted gay man, he deserts his wife and six-year-old daughter in London to roam the world with the louche Gerald, mining their adventures and the people they meet for stories. He’s an insecure wheedler, a literary predator with a tell-tale stammer.

At one point, Lesley wonders why Willie’s stories are “so frequently about adultery and unhappy marriages.” These topics preoccupy Mr. Eng, too. Lesley regularly cuckolds her spouse in the House of Doors, where she can “forget everything outside its walls, forget that I had a husband, and yes, forget even that I was a mother with two young sons.” Willie and his wife, Syrie, are no better.

In Mr. Eng’s depiction, Syrie is greedy and superficial enough to warrant her own abandonment. Willie bemoans that Syrie made the unfortunate mistake of “falling in love with her husband.” When he leaves home for months at a time, his daughter cries herself to sleep every night.

Mr. Eng describes the unyoked Gerald as his novel’s “happiest character,” because he’s “true to himself and not beholden.” Another character, albeit a minor one, might embody this happiness better. Wealthy philanthropist Loh Swee Tiong attends a party in Penang, hoping to get Willie to sign a book for his son, who followed Sun Yat Sen to China and has been there for several years. “I would give away every cent I have for my son to return to us, safe and unharmed, for my granddaughter to have her father back again,” Loh says.

He can’t find Willie at the party and has to leave to tend to his sick wife. While sad in his present circumstances, the selfless and devoted Loh no doubt knows a thing or two about true happiness, which Gerald — and all the rest — have yet to discover.

Sharon Skeel is the author of Catherine Littlefield: A Life in Dance (Oxford University Press, 2020).