A long, long time ago, when coaching dinosaurs named Pop (Warner), Knute (Rockne) and Jock (Sutherland) roamed the land, Duquesne University’s football program was near extinction.
After winning only four games in three seasons, Duquesne rolled the dice on a promising young coach from tiny Columbia College in Dubuque, Iowa. The gamble paid off, yielding perhaps the greatest turnaround in Duquesne history.
“ELMER LAYDEN: NOTRE DAME’S QUIET HERO”
By Don Doxsie
Amazon Publishing Pros ($14.99)
From 1927-1933, the Dukes rolled up a 48-16-6 record, with marks of 9-0-1 in 1929 and 10-1 in 1933. The latter ended with a 33-7 pasting of Miami (Florida) in the Festival of Palms Bowl, precursor to the Orange Bowl.
The architect of all that winning was Elmer Layden, the subject of Don Doxsie’s new book, “Elmer Layden: Notre Dame’s Quiet Hero.’’ While Layden’s stint on the Bluff is almost an aside in yet another paean to Notre Dame, it’s a pivotal period in Doxsie’s story – and one of the high points of Layden’s brief and almost-forgotten coaching career.
Layden was just 24 years old, less than three years removed from his starring role in Notre Dame’s legendary Four Horsemen backfield, when he took over Duquesne’s downtrodden program. Duquesne had won only 43 games in its entire history when Layden signed on following a successful two-year stay at Columbia.
Layden rewarded Duquesne’s faith with a 4-4-1 record his first season, followed by a combined 17-1-1 the next two years. The victories weren’t amassed against the Little Sisters of the Poor. The Dukes punched up, playing an ambitious schedule that included West Virginia University and Washington & Jefferson, then a national power. And it beat both of them.
The Dukes also battled Carnegie Tech, another nationally respected program, to a scoreless tie before a throng of more than 42,000 at Pitt Stadium. The Dukes became so popular they played most of their home games under the lights at Forbes Field. The Dukes’ burgeoning renown forced Sutherland to add Duquesne to Pitt’s 1932 schedule.
“The Dukes are a big-time football attraction right now,’’ wrote Pittsburgh Press columnist Ralph Davis. “Win or lose, the Laydenites play up-to-date football. They are well-coached and finely trained.’’
Layden parlayed his Duquesne success into the head-coaching job at Notre Dame, but he resigned under pressure after seven seasons. He then became the National Football League’s first commissioner, but was sacked after five years. His football life was over at age 43.
If Layden’s football odyssey could be summed up in a single adjective, it might be “unfulfilled.’’ Not failed or even mediocre, just unfulfilled.
Great expectations clung to him like a sweaty jersey. As a member of the most famous offensive backfield in college football, Layden had conditioned the public to expect extraordinary feats. But no matter his accomplishments, and there were many, Layden always seemed to leave fans and alumni and NFL owners feeling that there could have, should have been so much more.
Layden compiled a respectable 47-13-3 record at Notre Dame, but there were no national championships and only one top-5 finish in the Associated Press poll. He quit in February 1941 amid growing alumni discontent and reports that the Notre Dame administration had secretly contacted Boston College football coach Frank Leahy.
The NFL never offered an official reason for Layden’s sacking. According to various reports, there was a clique of owners, led by the Washington’s George Preston Marshall, that had never warmed up to him. Despite his historic status as the NFL’s first commissioner, Layden has not been inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
In assessing Layden’s place in Notre Dame’s coaching pantheon, Doxsie acknowledges that he ranks below Leahy, Rockne and Ara Parseghian, all of whom own higher winning percentages and multiple national championships.
Which begs the question: What makes Layden “Notre Dame’s quiet hero?’’ Doxsie says it’s because he was a man of loyalty and integrity who never made a scene even when he departed Notre Dame and the NFL under difficult circumstances.
Layden left football behind with little, if any, regret, Doxsie claims.
“I always figured coaching was at best a precarious living,’’ the author quotes Layden as saying. “I was always prepared to leave when the time was right.’’
Doxsie is a retired sportswriter based in Iowa, Layden’s home state, and clearly has a soft spot for his subject. Nostalgia is a heady drug.
Steve Halvonik is a former Post-Gazette reporter and editor.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.