When a child disappears, investigators immediately look at the parents or the child’s guardian. That makes sense, since they are usually the closest to the child. But what if no one can be trusted?

That is the premise of the new thriller by six-time New York Times Bestseller Shari Lapena, “Everyone Here is Lying.”

Ms. Lapena’s book takes place in the fictional town of Stanhope, where the book’s title holds true.

In the first chapter we meet Dr. William Wooler, a respected physician who has many secrets of his own, including an affair. He also has a complicated relationship with his ‘difficult’ nine-year-old daughter, Avery.

Advertise with us

Avery knows how to push William’s buttons, to the point where in the past he has lost his patience and raised a hand to her. As the book begins, he has just lost the mistress he loves, Nora Blanchard, who out of guilt has decided to end the relationship.

William goes home hurt and upset, hoping to find an empty house, but Avery is there after getting in trouble again at school. Already upset and angry, he hits Avery with a hard slap, knocking her to the ground. By the time her older brother gets home, Avery is missing.

Ms. Lapena’s story takes you on a whirlwind of guessing who is lying and who is telling the truth, with interconnected neighbors who are struggling themselves — and may hold a grudge against the Wooler family.

“The idea of Avery just came to me one day,” said Ms. Lapena in an interview with the Post-Gazette. “I thought: what if a father struck his daughter really hard and she disappeared? I wanted to have a difficult child, because that’s a bit different.”

Avery gets in trouble at school and at home. Her behavior is impacting her family, especially her parents, whose relationship is strained due to their different views on how to handle her.

Advertise with us

“I wanted to explore the dysfunction in that family and how the raising of a particularly challenging child affected each parent differently and damaged their marriage,” said Ms. Lapena.

Ms. Lapena started writing when she was a child, the same age as Avery is in her book. She further dabbled in her twenties, but thought that trying to make it as a writer wasn’t practical. She decided to go to law school and then teacher’s college. She came back to writing when she stayed at home with her first child. That was 24 years ago.

“My first novel was a literary comedy. It did well critically, but didn’t sell outside of Canada,” said Ms. Lapena. After another literary comedy, she switched gears and wrote a thriller, the global bestseller “The Couple Next Door.”

“I’ve been writing psychological thrillers ever since. It seems to be where I belong,” said Ms. Lapena.

“Everyone Here is Lying” not only explores the dysfunction of the Wooler family. We get to meet many neighbors while detectives Gully and Bledsoe of the local police department start asking questions, trying to get some answers on who may have taken Avery. Their answers bring more questions and reveal there may be one or more psychopaths living in their upscale neighborhood.

Advertise with us

“I love to go inside psychopaths’s heads. I think there are more of them around than most people realize,” said Ms. Lapena.

The short chapters of “Everyone Here is Lying” make the book move quickly, with multiple points of views. Just when you think you may have the answers to what happened to Avery, Ms. Lapena takes you into another direction with ease, keeping readers on edge. And even when what happened to Avery is revealed, the twists continue.

“Everyone Here is Lying” is a perfect summer read. The story keeps you interested until the very last sentence and makes the reader long for a sequel.

Cindy Alexander is a freelance journalist for both the Post-Gazette and Shady Ave Magazine. She is also the co-host of I Wish You Lived Next Door, a podcast dedicated to previewing upcoming book releases.