There probably aren’t many stories out there that include a missing woman, vintage Broadway, military life and nuclear physics.
“THE WOMAN WITH TWO SHADOWS”
By Sarah James
Sourcebooks Landmark ($16.99)
Welcome to “The Woman With Two Shadows,” the first novel from Forest Hills native Sarah James. Making its debut Tuesday, the book combines all those elements into a “Gone Girl”-style thriller about a World War II-era woman desperately trying to figure out what happened to her twin sister after she disappears from a military base in Tennessee.
It’s obvious from the start that James has a keen sense of who her characters are and a passion for this moment in history. She sometimes seems a little too excited to show off her mastery of complex mathematical and scientific ideas, but those nerdy digressions only slightly bog down what otherwise is a slick, easily digestible mystery.
Read More
“The Woman with Two Shadows” follows Lillian Kaufman, a budding physicist more interested in securing her career than finding a husband. If it’s not logical or practical, Lillian probably wants no part of it. She certainly can’t fathom why her twin sister, Eleanor, would prioritize her love life and Broadway ambitions over her responsibilities to their family following the death of their father.
Any friction between them immediately becomes meaningless when Lillian is informed by Eleanor’s former lover, Max, that her sister has gone missing while working on an Army base in Oak Ridge, Tenn. Lillian travels there to find some answers and ends up having to assume Eleanor’s identity.
It’s a pretty intriguing setup in a genre that usually doesn’t require much more than someone to vanish suddenly to kick off the main plot. It allows for tension to be baked into every page as James unravels what led to Eleanor’s disappearance and her reasons for leaving New York City.
James almost goes a little overboard in crafting twins who essentially have nothing in common besides their appearance. Lillian’s staunchly analytical approach to all aspects of life stands in stark contrast to artsy, happy-go-lucky Eleanor. Though a tad unbelievable, it certainly makes for a fascinating experiment when Lillian has to fool an entire small town into thinking that she’s Eleanor.
The action in “The Woman with Two Shadows” is laid out in an almost cinematic way. James paints a pretty clear picture of what’s going on at any given time, and the time period-specific details add the necessary texture to fully immerse the reader into what Lillian is thinking and experiencing.
There are also two important male characters: Max, the scorned lover who is both a confidant and thorn in Lillian’s side during her search for Eleanor; and Andrew, a renowned scientist with more than a few secrets of his own. Neither feels quite as fleshed out as Lillian or Eleanor, but that’s forgivable given that the events of the novel are relayed entirely through Lillian’s perspective.
Again, James has an obvious love for science and math, which is revealed in meticulously recreated equations and conversations between Andrew and Lillian that make just enough sense to not be distracting. At least there’s enough detail paid to character quirks and motivations to offset some of the headier stuff that sometimes threatens to halt the story’s momentum in its tracks.
World War II aficionados will probably recognize Oak Ridge as one of the production sites for the Manhattan Project and the development of the atomic bomb. James smartly uses that element as a backdrop for the story’s central mystery rather than making it the focus. She does, however, grapple with the morality of such a world-altering endeavor in a way that leaves plenty of food for thought.
Overall, “The Woman with Two Shadows” is a solid first novel from an author who clearly knows what she’s doing. It doesn’t all come together cohesively, but enough of it does to make for an entertaining read. Whether you’re an aggressively left-brained Lillian or a firmly right-brained Eleanor, you’ll find something to enjoy in this freshman effort.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.