Chrysta Bilton’s memoir, “Normal Family: On Truth, Love, and How I Met My 35 Siblings,” sounds like a segment that might be featured on “Oprah.” The book itself, however, is much more akin to memoirs like “The Glass Castle” by Jeannette Walls than reality TV.
Bilton recounts her childhood as the daughter of Debra, a resourceful but deeply flawed mother looking to make it big in Los Angeles. As a lesbian in the 1980s, Debra had to begin her unconventional family in a clandestine manner, with the help of a sperm donor named Jeffrey whom she met coincidentally at a hair salon. Jeffrey becomes an erratic fixture in Bilton's life while secretly building on his success as a sperm donor with other families.
“NORMAL FAMILY: ON TRUTH, LOVE, AND HOW I MET MY 35 SIBLINGS”
By Chrysta Bilton
Little Brown & Co. ($29)
The book followers Bilton as she grapples with her mother’s chaotic lifestyle and slowly untangles the secrets both parents have kept for decades, eventually uncovering dozens of other half-siblings spread across the nation.
Unfortunately, this memoir is not anywhere near as well-crafted as "The Glass Castle,” and doesn’t come close to instant classics like “Educated” by Tara Westover. The first few chapters are undeniably the most engrossing and provide a memorable entry into Bilton’s childhood, but the rest of the book just doesn’t have the same magnetism. (An unfortunate side effect is that the details of Bilton’s conception are discussed, um, thoroughly.)
The most compelling character is Debra, a powerful and indomitable woman Bilton describes as the director of her life’s own masterful play. She stands in stark contrast to Bilton’s easygoing, off-kilter father, who occasionally decides to step up for the family — but only when the price is right.
Debra somehow scales and then crashes down every single rung on the economic ladder through complex multilevel marketing and real estate schemes, all while dragging a zoo full of animals and girlfriends through makeshift homes in Los Angeles. She manages incredible feats of economic and parental success while also manufacturing constant instability and fighting her own addictions. She’s dynamic and fun, and possibly a complete liar and fraud.
The memoir could have been a complex look at Debra continuously grappling with her sexuality as a lesbian woman who outed herself on national TV before retreating back into the closet when faced with career setbacks. Bilton herself struggled with telling school friends about her mother's sexuality, with palpable consequences. However, the book keeps us mostly outside of Debra's mind, observing from a distance.
It could also have been a painful documentation of Jeffrey’s life, starting as a handsome Playgirl model whose bouts of mental illness became more prominent until he is nearly unrecognizable. Or even a look at the commodification of his story as one of the most prolific sperm donors of his time as the media descended upon him and his children. But intimate looks at either parent are largely absent.
In fact, the book keeps readers outside of the author’s mind, too. Rather than recounting the understandable and conflicting emotions Bilton must have felt when enduring monumental challenges, the author reacts to the chaos like a one-dimensional saint: “I was angry at my mother for hurting my sister. I didn’t like my mother when she drank. My sister and I had grown apart.”
Much of the book tells readers what the author feels retroactively, plants characters and only gives them emotional weight after they’ve already left, or doesn’t adequately build to a payoff through scenes or dialogue.
It also continually commits one of the cardinal sins of writing: It tells rather than shows.
If it were as insightful or timely a book as “Hillbilly Elegy” by JD Vance — another memoir whose strength doesn’t lie with narrative storytelling but which struck a painfully topical chord across the nation — it might have been enough to hold interest.
But without relevant critique, striking scenes or even a satisfying climax, the book becomes a recounting of a fascinating childhood in the most banal manner.
Rebecca Spiess: rspiess@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.