“NEW DEMOCRACY: THE CREATION OF THE MODERN AMERICAN STATE”
By William J. Novak
Harvard University Press ($45)
Political theorist Walter Weyl detected a new spirit in the United States in 1912. The movement’s reform agenda, Weyl declared, included government regulation, tax reform, the reorganization of business in the interest of the industrially weak, and a more equitable distribution of wealth.
In “New Democracy,” a title he borrowed from Weyl, William Novak, a professor at the University of Michigan Law School and author of “The People’s Welfare: Law and Regulation in Nineteenth Century America,” examines the period between 1866 and 1932, during which, he claims, the modern American state was created to address corporate power, corruption by special interests, and people’s health, safety, and well-being.
Novak’s important and timely book debunks the myth that before Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal, municipal, state, and federal governments were weak, and doctrines enshrining free market capitalism, individual, contract, and property rights went unchallenged.
A signature achievement of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, Novak indicates, was the grant of national citizenship to all Americans and a ban on states from depriving them of privileges and immunities; life, liberty, or property; or equal protection under the law. In the 1870s and ‘80s, Novak acknowledges, the Supreme Court eviscerated these rights, and the federal government retreated from its commitment to enforce them. Nonetheless, Novak maintains, the American state and American citizenship had a new constitutional foundation “with significant ramifications for the future.”
Progressive reformers also redefined government, which had been bound by immutable “natural” laws like “liberty of contract,” into a prime mover with “its own ends, objectives, and functions.” Convinced that individual liberty and the common good reinforced one another, they transformed the “police power” into a more positive instrument to improve the general welfare of society and paved the way for a de facto use of that power (via the Commerce Clause) by the national government.
Among the most important innovations of progressives, Novak points out, were the concepts of the “public utility” and “public service corporations.” Because corporations in emerging sectors of the economy (transportation, communications, energy, water, shipping, and storage) were “affected with a public interest,” reformers argued, they should be subject to fact-finding, inspection, investigation, prosecution, price-setting, and regulatory enforcement by legislatures, government agencies, and courts acting in behalf of the community-at-large. And progressives made a compelling case that many businesses were “affected with a public interest.”
Novak also credits progressives with developing the modern concept and practice of social legislation. Arguing that every American had a right to live as a civilized person according to contemporary standards, progressives pushed for laws addressing concrete problems: industrial workers’ hours and wages; inspection of meat, milk, and drugs; affordable housing; first-rate public schools; unemployment and health insurance. Although many of them weren’t opposed to regulating prostitution and alcohol consumption, reformers sought to shift policing and prosecution away from preoccupations with individual responsibility and retribution.
Novak paints with a broad brush. He doesn’t identify ebbs and flows in reform between 1868 and 1932. Or adequately address the diluting, derailing, and defeating of proposals; the minimal impact of anti-trust legislation on the concentration of capital; increases in economic inequality. He doesn’t make a compelling case that the progressives’ administrative state was democratic.
New democracy, Novak acknowledges, “involved an always unfinished aspiration rather than a final realization.” These days, he laments, “contemporary notions of democracy and political freedom” have given way to growing social and racial stratification, aggressive corporate and financial capitalists, and the revival of plutocracy and oligarchy.
And so, as he documents the existence of an alternative political tradition, Novak concludes, with John Dewey, that the democratic state “must always be rediscovered.”
Glenn C. Altschuler is the Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.