The “Lost Cause” myth about the antebellum South began to coalesce within just a few decades of the end of the Civil War. Essentially it held that the South was a gracious, refined and just society, and that slavery was a far more humane institution than abolitionist propaganda claimed. Novels, poems, paintings, public sculptures, school textbooks and even films such as “Birth of a Nation” or “Gone with the Wind” propagated this story, and by mid-20th century Northerners and Southerners both widely accepted it.

“TO WALK ABOUT IN FREEDOM: THE LONG EMANCIPATION OF PRISCILLA JOYNER”

By Carole Emberton

W.W. Norton ($28.95)

Advertise with us

Even government reports ended up reinforcing this lie, as Carole Emberton shows in “To Walk About in Freedom: The Long Emancipation of Priscilla Joyner.” In this telescopic biography of a formerly enslaved woman, Emberton undermines every dreamy moonlight-and-magnolia falsehood, and shows that slavery, and the self-contradictory racial laws and everyday practices that arose when the South tried to re-establish its pre-war world, created a sick society characterized by everyday cruelty to its most vulnerable members.

Priscilla was born in January 1858 in Nash County, N.C., to Ann Eliza Joyner, the white wife of Rix Joyner. But Priscilla’s dark skin made it clear that Rix wasn’t her father. After Ann Eliza kicked Rix out of the house for selling her property, she had turned to a Black man for companionship and Priscilla was the result.

Sexual relations between white men and enslaved Black women were common (if never acknowledged), but the reverse arrangement, if consenting, fundamentally threatened the South’s racial and sexual ideologies. For that reason, Eliza Ann never told Priscilla the identity of her father. Even decades later, this information could get him murdered.

So was baby Priscilla enslaved or free? It’s unknowable. She grew up in the Joyner household, and was not enumerated on the “slave schedule” of the 1860 census. But she was not treated as a member of the family. Her status, Emberton points out, was murky and unclear, and “churns up the muddy history of race and sexual intimacy in the slave South.” Priscilla embodied the complexity and contradiction of what was purportedly a simple binary system. She was and was not Ann Eliza’s daughter; she was and was not a full person.

Allowed to return home, Rix turned his children against Priscilla, who abused and ostracized her. When she was 12, Priscilla was sent to live with the Dancys in a community of freed people. In Freedom Hill, Priscilla found another kind of makeshift family very different than the one that had expelled her, a community of mutual support among people who had experienced innumerable traumas and who were trying to build lives in a region that still resented and sought to undermine their freedom and self-determination. And she did just that. She married, several times. She had children, some of whom died. She cared for her family and house and garden.

Advertise with us

In many ways, Priscilla lived an unremarkable life, and this is probably what called her to the attention of Eudora Ramsay Richardson in the late 1930s. As director of the Virginia Writers’ Project, the state-level subsidiary of the Federal Writers’ Project, Richardson was editing “The Negro in Virginia,” a study of Black life in the Old Dominion. VWP researchers traveled the state interviewing elderly African Americans, compiling their stories, and Richardson helped knit these stories into an ethnography.

But, as Emberton makes clear, Richardson knew what story she wanted to tell, and it didn’t match those of her informants. A wealthy, intelligent, ambitious “new Southern woman,” Richardson was one of the thousands of influential people who fostered and maintained the Lost Cause myth. She excised from “The Negro in Virginia” stories of the cruelty of slavery that she found “unbelievable,” and even ventriloquized her subjects. “My old mistress was the best woman in the world,” Priscilla says about her mother, in words that appear in none of the actual interview transcripts. Repeated innumerable times, these small distortions added up to a widespread perception, by the 1940s, that slavery was benign.

Emberton’s original and compassionate book uses Priscilla Joyner’s life story, as well as those of many other subjects interviewed by the VWP, to create a vivid, ground-level portrait of the struggles and joys of rural southern Black people in the aftermath of slavery, the confusion of Reconstruction and the imposition of Jim Crow. It’s also a telling depiction of how powerful figures like Richardson created “history” and myth, and how intellectual dissenters of the time (such as African American poet Sterling Brown) tried to thwart the spread of this disinformation.

Greg Barnhisel is a professor of English at Duquesne University.