“HELL’S HALF-ACRE: THE UNTOLD STORY OF THE BENDERS, A SERIAL KILLER FAMILY ON THE AMERICAN FRONTIER”

By Susan Jonusas

Viking ($28)

Once upon a time, a family named Bender lived in a little house on the wide Kansas prairie. Every once in a while, a pioneer saw the little house on his way West and asked to spend the night. The Benders obliged. They served a meal, carefully seating the visitor with his back to a piece of cloth that divided the cabin into two rooms. Behind that cloth lurked other family members with weapons. A little while later, the Benders stripped their dearly departed guest of his belongings and buried his remains in their orchard.

Advertise with us

Such is the story of the “Bloody Benders,” a family of serial killers living in a different kind of little house on the prairie than the ones in Laura Ingalls Wilder books.

The family’s motive seems to have been money, and their method resembled Sweeney Todd: Armed with hammers, family members hit the victim in the head to stun him, beat in his temples, slit his throat with a knife then pulled open a trapdoor and slid the dying man to the cellar where he bled to death. The Benders seem to have fenced the goods stolen from their prey.

All the known victims were men except an 18-month-old girl traveling with her father. The Benders are suspected of other murders, but no proof exists.

Although many visitors to the Bender cabin noticed its odor and flies, it was not until lawmen observed shallow depressions in the orchard that they found any bodies. By that time, the Benders had long since quit Kansas.

This latest book on the family, “Hell’s Half-Acre: The Untold Story of the Benders, a Serial Killer Family on the American Frontier,” by British author Susan Jonusas, claims to push the story beyond its familiar boundaries. It does, but to no satisfying conclusion. The murderers fled through Native American tribal lands and lived on the run with a gang of outlaws in Texas. What happened after that, no one knows for sure.

Advertise with us

Much of the last parts of the book focus on the trial of two women suspected of being Ma and Kate Bender, but the evidence put forward by Ms. Jonusas makes clear that the pair bore no relationship to the actual murderers.

Ms. Jonusas does a commendable job keeping the reader in suspense as lawmen discover the family’s bloody deeds and pursue them into the Old West. She does not dwell on motive, inter-relationships or the ultimate fate of the Benders, and these omissions are both refreshing and aggravating.

However, the book pays scant attention to the Benders’ known backgrounds. Perhaps little is known, but a fuller account would have been welcome.

In addition, the book lacks photos. Ms. Jonusas made the curious decision to include just engravings from Harpers Weekly magazine and drawings from newspaper stories, none of which depict the Benders.  A quick search on Google will uncover plenty of photos, including ones of Kate Bender, who, even in a blurry, damaged photo, is unusually good-looking.

On balance, Ms. Jonusas’ adherence to what is credibly known of the case makes “Hell’s Half-Acre” worth the read in spite of its flaws.

Laura Malt Schneiderman: lschneiderman@post-gazette.com