“WHERE THE DEER AND THE ANTELOPE PLAY: THE PASTORAL OBSERVATIONS OF ONE IGNORANT AMERICAN WHO LOVES TO WALK OUTSIDE”
By Nick Offerman
The great outdoors can be great fodder for writing, dear reader.
Are you comfortable being addressed as “dear reader” throughout a book? Can you accept a narrator who sometimes brings up a subject only to note it will be returned to later in the story? Is the labeling of all the narrator’s friends, loved ones and acquaintances as fabulous, brilliant and excellent a device with which you can live? Do you enjoy having a great deal of beverages described as “roborative?”
Perhaps even more importantly, in the case of actor/humorist/woodworker Nick Offerman’s latest book, “Where the Deer and the Antelope Play,” are you keen to see the ideas of naturalists John Muir and Aldo Leopold considered through the tales of three semi-recent outdoor-centric excursions by the author?
Offerman, despite his jokey delivery, has rich source material to recount. He spends a week taking guided hikes in Montana with writer George Saunders and the frontman of the alternative rock group Wilco, Jeff Tweedy. He then visits shepherd/author James Rebanks and family on their farm in England, spending days off from shooting a TV series indulging in what he considers rather joyous labor. Finally, at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, Offerman and his actress wife Megan Mullally buy an Airstream trailer they dub “Nutmeg” and explore parts of the American Southwest. Each excursion offers opportunities for Offerman to also look at big picture issues surrounding Americans’ relationships with the natural world.
Read More
While it’s part of his schtick, Offerman’s narrative conceits, at times, can grow a bit wearying. His use of the digital shorthand of the young to mock the digital shorthand of the young, often in ALL CAPS, wears thin. So does a repeated punchline of “Because, money.”
As well, Offerman frequently veers off-course from the stories of his treks into nature. Many of the asides are relevant, from how Native Americans were removed from the land that is now Glacier National Park to how industrial “farming” bears almost no resemblance to the process when done in an ecologically responsible manner. A rant about Brett Kavanaugh’s Supreme Court nomination hearings, however, interrupts the story to come to some fairly self-evident conclusions that simply reinforce Offerman’s already clear, generally liberal, worldview. A number of considerations of Kit Carson spring from Offerman stumbling upon the grave of the “mountain man” in Taos, N.M. Recounting Carson’s checkered “heroic feats” seems like well-worn turf by the time it appears.
And yet, what could be a meandering mess of a book somehow charms. While not all of his techniques land solidly, Offerman puts his comic timing and self awareness to good use elsewhere. After a stark, semi-profane listing of wrongs perpetrated on our nation’s native people, Offerman descends from his high horse with the quip, “I am a humorist, not Cormac McCarthy.” He also pokes a hole in his own balloon by capturing the moment he “silently renewed [his] promise to [himself] and all of humankind to fix everything by writing this lightweight meander of a nonfiction title. (You’re welcome.)”
Offerman knows not to reach too far beyond his expertise, frequently quoting the aforementioned Muir and Leopold along with literary heavyweights like Henry David Thoreau and Wendell Berry. Yet there is considerable wisdom to be found in the author’s own observations during his travels. When Offerman shares highlights of his conversations with a fellow hiker in Arizona, he hits upon one of the more interesting subjects at the heart of his book, “the particularly human dichotomy of greed and selflessness.” How people manifest both qualities in relation to the natural world gives the author plenty upon which to expound.
Like so many humorists, however, Offerman cloaks some of his bigger ideas in hyperbole and sarcasm for effect. He notes that his book is “about making generalized statements and then fulminating on some personal opinion or other without really considering both sides of the argument. You know, without nuance.” Offerman is an engaging fulminator who clearly understands nuance. He just might have a bit more faith in the power of his core stories to get his points across.
John Young teaches seventh-grade language arts and plays in the rock band The Optimists.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.