Somewhere in the first half of “I Love You But I’ve Chosen Darkness,” author Claire Vaye Watkins’s late father is wandering the Nevada desert, looking to plant his roots after a decade of slumming it in shacks and caves. Disillusioned with his life as a former member of the Manson family, he returns to the sand swept highways he once sped down with a rotating cast of druggies, though this time, the desert offers him a chance at renewal.
“I LOVE YOU BUT I’VE CHOSEN DARKNESS”
By Claire Vaye Watkins
Riverhead Books ($27)
The American West has long served as a backdrop for adventure tales, a place where wanderers face the unknown in hope of new beginnings. In “I Love You But I’ve Chosen Darkness,” Watkins instead reclaims the arid expanse between Los Angeles and Las Vegas as a place to be returned to, mining the wells of deeply personal memories in the process.
For Watkins' character, a stand-in for the author herself, little of anything new is found when she returns to her hometown in Nevada in the midst of postpartum depression. Rather, Watkins rediscovers remnants of a tumultuous early life, a sepia-toned upbringing that faded as the expectations of marriage, motherhood, and a semi-successful writing career piled up.
The novel opens to Watkins trapped in the the web of her adult life in Ann Arbor, wife to an even-tempered husband and mother to a newborn girl. But the unexpected gaping of strangers into the stroller becomes a “hellscape,” barrages of baby photos become an exhausting routine, and Watkins begins to bemoan lost nights of pot brownies and wasting away on the couch to prestige TV.
As the emotional dissonance grows between what Watkin’s should feel about motherhood and what she actually feels, the author’s wry writing style shines.
“We have a machine that rocks you and another that vibrates you and an app that very poorly replicates sounds from the world you’ve not yet heard — breakers and birds, rain on a tin roof,” she tells her newborn. “Robo-baby, I worry you’ll become, since you like the machines so much more than me.”
When this life for Watkins ceases to move forward, the novel takes a hard reverse into the past. In choosing darkness, Watkins leaves motherhood behind to travel solo down the backroads of her life.
Here, we meet the memory of Watkins’ own mother, a free-spirited Bohemian who alongside her daughters traverses the forgotten towns outside of Reno, trespassing, stealing, and getting high on “legal heroin” prescribed by Purdue pharmaceutical. What starts as hard-knocked fun becomes an insidious addiction, ending the twisted fairytale for Watkins. It isn’t until she unearths her mother’s girlhood letters, strewn in various chapters throughout the novel, that the complete image of the woman who raised her comes into form.
While Watkins’ character is undoubtedly a cynic — she often lights up joints with old friends, lamenting about sex with her dead ex-boyfriend and accelerated climate change — “Chosen Darkness” paints a detailed, colorful portrait of life after grief, and the powerful cycle of generational trauma.
“She had her mother’s pain swimming in her blood, and her mother’s and her mother’s and her mother’s and she was fat with it,” Watkins writes of her lineage.
Though it doesn’t come easily for Watkins, “I Love You But I’ve Chosen Darkness” addresses this pain. In her desert world, things may never get exceptionally better, but by reckoning with the past, the road ahead begins to clear up.
Jesse Bunch can be reached at: jbunch@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.