Heroes aren’t born. They are manufactured, made up, invented.
Heroes are social constructs, embedded in popular folklore and passed down from generation to generation to help us process cataclysmic events.
Case in point: Lewis Armistead and Winfield Scott Hancock. The opposing Civil War generals were acquaintances but hardly BFFs, at least by today’s definition. Yet pop culture embellished and promoted their fractured friendship to symbolize how the Civil War divided our nation and pitted “brother against brother.’’
Local author and Civil War buff Tom McMillan deconstructs the Armistead-Hancock myth in his excellent new book, “Armistead and Hancock: Behind the Gettysburg Legend of Two Friends at the Turning Point of the Civil War.’’
“ARMISTEAD AND HANCOCK”
By Tom McMillan
Read More
Stackpole Books ($29.95)
“The account of their friendship and ultimate showdown at Gettysburg, when Armistead’s troops attacked Hancock’s troops and both men fell wounded, is one of the astonishing personal stories of the Civil War, and yet its details were distorted in the 20th century by two popular and widely acclaimed works of ‘historic fiction,’’’ McMillan avers.
His assertion is based on careful analysis of existing scholarship as well as exhaustive new research conducted by him and his wife, Colleen. The two popular 20th-century works he alludes to are “The Killer Angels,’’ Michael Shaara’s 1975 Pulitzer Prize winner, and the 1993 film “Gettysburg.’’
“What many readers and viewers did not seem to realize … was that the novel and movie took liberties with the historical record to engage a broader audience, tug at heartstrings and move their stories along,’’ McMillan writes.
In other words, “The Killer Angels’’ and “Gettysburg’’ engaged in a little myth-making.
As the author reminds, the Armistead-Hancock story is quite compelling and hardly in need of fictional embroidery. The two men, at base, were avatars of the warring factions. Armistead was a son of Southern aristocracy, a slave-holding family, who resigned his U.S. military commission and joined the Confederacy because he believed that wealthy plantation owners were being “oppressed’’ by the federal government. Despite his highfalutin name, Hancock was decidedly less patrician. He and his twin brother, Hilary, were born in Montgomery County, Pa., the sons of a schoolteacher.
Both men attended West Point, without distinction. Armistead resigned from the military academy after breaking a plate over the head of another cadet; Hancock graduated seven years later, ranked 18th in a class of 25.
In McMillan’s briskly paced narrative, the two men first encounter each other in October 1844, as junior officers assigned to an Oklahoma fort on what was then the western frontier. They crossed paths again during the Mexican-American War, renewing their friendship over shared meals in Mexico City. They were billeted in southern California when the Southern states seceded from the Union. Hancock was stationed in Los Angeles when Armistead visited to discuss his decision to resign from the U.S. Army to join a Confederate regiment in his native Virginia.
“I cannot sympathize with you,’’ Hancock reportedly told Armistead. “You must be guided by your own convictions, and I hope you will make no mistakes.’’
McMillan, a former Post-Gazette sportswriter and columnist, has also written “Flight 93: The Story, the Aftermath and the Legacy of American Courage on 9/11.’’
Here he uses the divergent military careers of Armistead and Hancock to trace the arc of the Civil War leading up to their fateful clash in Gettysburg. Though not a historian by training, McMillan expertly summarizes the battles – Antietam and Chancellorsville – that served as dress rehearsals for the historic showdown in the rolling fields of south-central Pennsylvania.
The military forces commanded by both men met on the Gettysburg battlefield on July 3, 1863, during the pivotal – and controversial – confrontation that came to be known as Pickett’s Charge. Armistead courageously led a brigade that pierced the deepest into Union lines, frequently referred to as the high-water mark of the Confederacy. But he was wounded mortally, and died two days later at a Union field hospital.
A Union army aide later reported that Armistead had experienced a death-bed conversion. The aide said that Armistead had instructed him to tell Hancock that he regretted his decision to join the Confederate army. It’s an apocryphal tale that McMillan persuasively debunks.
Hancock suffered a thigh wound at Gettysburg that limited his effectiveness for the remainder of the war. He leveraged his enduring popularity to secure the Democratic nomination for president in 1880. He was defeated in the general election by another former Civil War general, James A. Garfield, a Republican from Ohio. A supporter of states’ rights, Hancock won the Southern states but lost most of the Northeast, including his home state, Pennsylvania. Hancock went to bed early on election night, long before all the votes had been counted. The next morning, he asked his wife, Almira, for the election verdict.
“It was a complete Waterloo for you,’’ she said.
Hancock fluffed his pillow and went back to sleep.
Steve Halvonik is a former Post-Gazette reporter and editor who teaches professional writing at Washington and Jefferson College.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.