“A Murder of Convenience” is a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. It is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935.

Aug. 31, 1935: Anna Jane Phillips stashed her reporter’s notebook in her handbag and tried to blend into the crowd in the Bottoms area of McKees Rocks. She didn’t want word to get back to Pittsburgh Post-Gazette city editor Joe Shuman that she was covering Martha Westwood’s murder on her day off.

“Why am I here?” she asked herself, unconsciously recoiling from the Eastern European men and women dressed in funeral black.

Barbara Matuza probably wouldn’t see her and if she did, it’s unlikely she’d recognize the reporter who had interviewed her two days earlier, hours after her husband, George, was killed at the Coraopolis steel forging mill where he worked.

Advertise with us

Anna Jane watched District Attorney Andrew Park emerge from the Matuzas’ Clay Alley apartment after offering condolences to the widow and her nine children. She seethed as he turned to reporters and dishonored George Matuza’s memory by announcing he was closing the investigation of the Yugoslavian immigrant’s death.

“George is no use to him now,” Anna Jane thought with disgust.

A coroner’s jury would never hear the dead steelworker’s testimony that he saw justice of the peace James Westwood flee after shooting his wife through their bedroom window on the other side of Clay Alley.

Anna Jane wouldn’t be at the coroner’s inquest; on Sept. 10, Shuman had assigned her to an Orphans Court hearing on the estate of the late architect Frederick J. Osterling. Even though she was no longer covering the Westwood murder, Anna Jane knew that Matuza’s grieving friends and family would agree that his horrible death in the jaws of a stamping machine was no accident, no matter what the D.A. said.

“A Murder of Convenience,” a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935. Read past chapters here.

The reporter stifled the urge to retrieve her notebook and document the scene around her. A band from the Croatian Fraternal Union played a quiet dirge as mourners emerged from the family’s three-room apartment and began a slow procession around the block. Joining them, Anna Jane couldn’t help but stare at the Westwoods’ neat brown-brick house on Ella Street. The curtains that Martha had started and her daughter, Bertha, had finished were pulled shut.

Advertise with us

Anna Jane walked in the funeral procession until it reached the McKees Rocks Bridge, then watched as the black river of humanity streamed across the steel span toward St. Mary’s German Catholic Church and its cemetery. The reporter suddenly realized that George Matuza would be buried just over the hill from Martha Westwood’s grave in Mt. Calvary Cemetery.

“God, I wish I was writing this story,” she said out loud as she looked for her car.

***

Sept. 10, 1935: Michael Matsey fought his way through a crowd outside the Allegheny County Morgue in Downtown Pittsburgh. He figured it was probably the biggest turnout ever for a coroner’s inquest in the building’s 30-year history. How could any case compete with murder charges against a squire and his constable for killing the squire’s wife?

The McKees Rocks police chief finally reached the thick double doors and began a frantic search for Andrew Park, the district attorney. He needed to make sure all their witnesses were ready, especially Sophie Sehar, who said she saw Jimmy Westwood running away from the scene, and party girl Peg Moran, who at first said that Jimmy and Tim Drexler never left her sight at Peyton’s Roadhouse the night Martha Westwood was shot.

Advertise with us

Hours of tough questioning and a lie detector test broke her, Matsey thought with satisfaction. Now she would say that both men disappeared for a half-hour just before the murder. That was plenty of time to drive the 6 miles from Peyton’s on Steubenville Pike to the Westwoods’ house in the Bottoms, shoot the wife three times, and get back to the roadhouse.

“Who cares if the other party girl sticks with Westwood and Drexler?” Matsey said to himself. “And Eddie Peyton? Nobody will believe that boozehound.”

Matsey wound his way through the morgue until he found the hearing room, far too small for the 15 witnesses, policemen, attorneys and jurors it needed to house. It looked like a courtroom in miniature, with a judge’s bench, a witness stand and tables arranged for the attorneys. W.J. McGregor, the coroner, was there. So was Chauncey Pruger, the assistant district attorney.

“Chauncey. Where’s Andrew?” he asked the pit bull of a prosecutor.

“Coming.”

Advertise with us

The district attorney, a rotund Republican, shoved into the room behind Matsey.

“Andrew, you got somebody other than Sophie Sehar to corroborate what Matuza saw?”

“What do you think I’ve been working on all day?” Park replied angrily.

***

“State your name for the record, please,” Pruger said.

Advertise with us

“Edward Peyton.”

“Mr. Peyton, is it correct that on the night of July 9 into the early morning of July 10, James Westwood, Tim Drexler and two female companions attended a show at your establishment?”

“Yes.”

“What time did they leave the establishment?”

Peyton paused. “I think it was about 2:30.”

Advertise with us

“Were any of them gone for a portion of the night before then?”

“I think Jimmy and one of the girls went out to the car at some point, for a little, uh, private time.” Peyton winked.

Park played along. “And what time was private time?”

“I dunno, about 2.”

Matsey listened as the assistant district attorney grilled Peyton about the location of the roadhouse, routes to and from it, how far away it was from McKees Rocks. He noted that a county detective had driven two different routes from the roadhouse to Clay Alley. One took 10 minutes, the other 11. That meant Westwood could have left at 2 a.m., committed the murder and returned from “private time” before the four of them left the club at 2:30 a.m.

Advertise with us

“How’m I supposed to know if he did or didn’t do that?” Peyton protested. “Wasn’t like I was in the car with him.”

“Isn’t it true you lied when first interviewed by County Detective Monaghan in saying Westwood and Drexler were not with girls?”

“No,” Peyton shouted. “I didn’t lie. I didn’t see them come in with girls. How was I to know they had girls with them? Tim Drexler danced with lots of girls and knows lots of girls.”

Peyton raised his right hand. “I’ll swear to God that I have told the truth.

“You’ve already been sworn,” the coroner said.

Advertise with us

“Well, he can’t tell me that I lied,” Peyton snapped. “No man’s got a right to say that.”

McGregor smiled coldly. “Sometimes actions speak louder than words.”

***

It was mostly smooth sailing for Park and Pruger after that. Sophie Sehar described how she had seen Westwood in the alley behind his house shortly after she heard the shots, and her 17-year-old daughter backed her up. The jurors didn’t seem to mind that her story had changed. She told Matsey she saw Westwood do it the night of the murder but then said it was a much taller man with long, curly hair. Sehar said she was afraid of what Westwood would do and who wouldn’t be? The squire was the closest thing to God in McKees Rocks.

The jurors looked more skeptically at tiny Peg Moran, who also changed her story and punctured Westwood’s alibi. But it seemed to Matsey that the jury was buying her new story.

Advertise with us

Matsey, who had spent many long days on the murder investigation with Allegheny County Detective Walter Monaghan, was confident about everything but the paraffin test, which detects gunshot residue on a person. The bald chemist’s testimony was hardly riveting, but he had said that Westwood’s test was the only one of the three that showed he had fired a gun within 72 hours of his wife’s murder. The police chief knew this was the first time the test had been allowed as evidence in a Pennsylvania legal proceeding. The jurors would have to believe the science, and that wasn’t something you could count on in this town.

At the end of the hearing, the jurors took only a half hour of deliberation. When they returned, McGregor talked to the foreman, climbed the bench, and spoke to a quiet room:

“The jury has heard the evidence presented at this inquest on the 10th of September, 1935. In so doing, it charges James Westwood with murder, and Tim Drexler with accessory to murder before and after the fact.”

***

Detective Walter Monaghan was still seeing spots from the newspaper photographers’ flash bulbs. It had taken him nearly an hour to shepherd James Westwood through the throngs of bystanders and take him to the county jail.

Advertise with us

Before handing Westwood off to the guards, Monaghan shook his hand. “Well Jim, it seems to be the will of God that you’re to be here.”

“Some day, Walter,” Westwood responded, “you’ll learn that I’m telling the truth.”

Epilogue

Someday never came for James Westwood.

The McKees Rocks justice of the peace was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison on Jan. 25, 1936. He served his sentence at Western Penitentiary, now known as State Correctional Institution-Pittsburgh, and died there on May 14, 1951.

The 60-year-old fell from a 30-foot scaffold while doing repairs on a building within the prison’s walls. He maintained his innocence until the end.