“A Murder of Convenience” is a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. It is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935.
Aug. 29, 1935: Charles Autry saw his friend hurrying down the sidewalk on Webster Avenue and was ready to tease him about ducking out of work early. But the expression on James Johnston’s face warned Autry that he wasn’t in the mood for any kidding.
The afternoon sun darted between the ramshackle row houses of the Hill District, shading Johnston’s features in an odd mix of grief and anger. When he saw Charles sitting on the stoop, James wiped his eyes and tried to compose himself, failing miserably.
“What’s the matter, James?” Charles asked gently. “Why are you home so early?”
“A worker died at the plant. They sent us home,” James said, trying to sound calm.
“Did you see the accident? You know the guy?”
“Wasn’t no accident! He was a friend of mine,” James replied.
Saying this out loud seemed to settle the young steelworker, but it brought Charles to his feet.
“What do you mean, not an accident? I told you that mill was no place for a Black man!”
Now it was James’ turn to calm his friend. He sat on the stoop and waited for Charles to sit back down.
“George isn’t Black,” James said. “He’s an immigrant, from Yugoslavia. I used to ride the streetcar with him. He is … was ... the best stamper in the plant.
“I wish he’d told me he knew something about the Westwood murder. Damn squire had him killed to shut him up!”

Bewilderment suffused Charles’ face as he peppered James with more questions.
“What does a hunky have to do with that lady’s murder? Didn’t they just lock up Westwood and one of his constables two days ago? Everybody knew they did it. Why’d it take the cops two months to lock ‘em up?”
Everyone in Pittsburgh had heard about the arrests earlier that week of McKees Rocks justice of the peace James Westwood and constable Tim Drexler in the shooting of Westwood’s wife, Martha, while she was sleeping at their home in the Bottoms. Pittsburgh’s three newspapers said three neighbors saw Westwood running away from the scene. One was Sophie Sehar, whose description of the shooter kept changing, and one was her teenage daughter. The other was an unnamed man who lived across from the Westwoods. That would be George Matuza, the man who died today at the plant.
James tried to answer Charles’ questions while straightening it out in his mind.
“George lived across Clay Alley from the Westwoods. He told the cops he saw Westwood do it, gave them enough to arrest him. Then they let him go to work!
“I wondered why they stuck George with the new guy today. He already had a helper! Then they made him stay by his machine when we all went outside for air. His helper found him all mangled up, says it mighta been suicide or an accident. Ain’t no way a man workin’ on the same machine for 19 years has an accident. And George was in a great mood this morning!”
Charles’ face grew hard as he pieced the story together.
“Dead man can’t testify in court…. He got a wife, kids?”
“Yeah, nine kids! I got off at his stop to go see them, tell ’em how sorry I was. But I got scared when I see all the people standing around, staring at me. I caught the next trolley and came home. How do you tell a wife her man died for doin’ the right thing? That supposed to make her feel better?”
***
Anna Jane Phillips stood once again in Clay Alley, not far from where she parked her car the night of July 9, hours after someone shot Martha Westwood three times through her bedroom window.
“The Bottoms doesn’t look any better in daylight,” the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reporter said to herself. “Don’t these people have anything better to do?”
A crowd of gawkers mingled in the alley below the Matuza family’s apartment. Some posed for newspaper photographers. Others bragged that they were also there after Martha got shot. A couple of boys described how police had lowered them into the sewers to look for the shooter’s .38-caliber pistol.
Remembering the Westwood children’s tears that night, Anna Jane steeled herself for the grief of 10 Matuzas.
“You’re a reporter on the biggest story of the year!” she reminded herself. “Get all mushy and Joe will send you back to jams and jellies in Features.”
Joe Shuman, the Post-Gazette’s city editor, had taken a liking to the Vassar graduate. He called her A.J. and said she should make that her byline.
“People are already shocked at a girl reporter,” he said. “Why announce it?”
“Because it’s my name!” she said to herself as she waved her notebook to a cop at the bottom of the stairs.
“Matovich, right?” she said to the beefy patrolman. “I remember you from the night of the murder.”
George Matovich nodded and led her up the creaky stairs to the Matuzas’ apartment. The door opened to a bizarre scene: Barbara Matuza sitting stoically in the center of the apartment’s main room, surrounded by her children ranging in age from about 20 to 6 years old. The oldest children stared grimly as flashbulbs popped. The younger ones smiled for the cameras, not sure what the fuss was about.
As she asked her first question, Anna Jane tried not to think about how George Matuza had died, his skull crushed like an eggshell between the steel jaws of a steel stamping machine.
“How could the district attorney keep a straight face when he says it was a suicide or accident?” she thought angrily. “Even a contortionist couldn’t squeeze himself in there while standing on the safety switch.”
The Matuzas’ oldest child, Marie, 21, said her father didn’t tell his family he had seen Jimmy Westwood shoot his wife.
“I didn’t know he knew anything about the murder and I don’t even know if mother knew. Did you, Mom?”
“I know nothing,” Barbara Matuza replied, tears streaming down her blank face.
The widow did know one thing: Her husband was in high spirits the day he died because his asthma had finally let up. That sure didn’t sound like the suicidal witness DA Andrew Park was trying to sell to reporters.
Marie said her father enjoyed the untroubled sleep of an honest man last night. Officer Matovich, George’s longtime friend, agreed.
“We tried to persuade him to stay at a hotel but he wanted to work. We gave him all the protection we could. He was a good man, a good friend.”
Marie’s eyes widened in surprise as the patrolman spoke, then narrowed in anger at Anna Jane’s next question, directed at Matovich: “How do you feel about Matuza’s death since you were the one who convinced him to come forward?”
“How could you, Uncle George?!” Marie screamed at the startled cop. “You’re the reason my father is dead! If he had shut up he’d still be alive today.”
Matovich turned pale, his full lips trembling, and he reached out to the young woman he’d known since she was 11 years old. Marie turned away, sobbing, to wrap her arms around her mother. Her brother, Marko, 16, glared at the cop, who stood helplessly, staring at the floor.
Anna Jane closed her notebook and backed away, tears in her eyes.
“That doesn’t need to be in my story,” she said to herself, and headed for the stairs.
Monday: Chapter 8: The Squire Goes to Court
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.