“A Murder of Convenience” is a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. It is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935.
Noon was more than three hours away, but the July heat was already stifling inside the Kanai Funeral Chapel in the Bottoms section of McKees Rocks. The dozens of people crowded into the room used paper fans to cool themselves.
Anna Jane Phillips was unable to squeeze into the chapel, but she managed to peek in and see the body of Martha Westwood lying in an open casket. The undertaker had worked a minor miracle, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reporter thought. How did they cover up bullet holes in her cheek and forehead?
Once the family and closest relatives were done paying their respects, pallbearers lifted the casket and bore it to the First Presbyterian Church on Chartiers Avenue, where more than 700 people filled the pews. Hundreds more crowded the sidewalks and spilled into the streets, blocking any motorists foolish enough to try to get through. Even the hearse had to slow to a crawl. The funeral was the biggest ticket in town.
Anna Jane recognized one of the pallbearers as Tim Drexler, the constable who had been drinking with justice of the peace Jimmy Westwood the night his wife was shot.
The Rev. W.E. Howard directed the Saturday service with help from Rev. Robert Humphries, superintendent of Shadyside Church Mission. The choir performed three of Martha’s favorite hymns to honor the sweet-voiced woman who had faithfully sung alongside them every Sunday.

Rev. Howard remembered Martha as the first person he called when he needed a volunteer. “How she loved going to the movies and playing cards with her women’s clubs,” he said. The last time he’d seen her round, smiling face was when she had managed the annual strawberry festival on the church lawn the week before.
He also recalled her strength, how she had stayed at Ohio Valley Hospital for 11 days by the side of her 14-year-old daughter, Clara, before the teenager died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. How her mother and her stepfather had died in a murder-suicide the same year, but she kept the family together, never neglecting her children, Bertha, 19, Martha, 11, and Jimmy Jr., 7. She made sure that the family spent Sunday mornings at the church and Sunday afternoons with picnics at the lake, the minister said.
But the Rev. Howard’s message, Anna Jane noted, was more than one of solace and Christian comfort. There was a hint of indignant anger in his voice as he sent it soaring toward the coffered ceiling and stained-glass windows. He gripped the sides of the lectern and leaned in toward the congregants, his blue eyes seeming to search their very souls.
“Someone knows who did this,” he said slowly, pushing each word deeper. “We must not only have faith in God’s judgment, but we must have faith in the judgment of man, that the guilty — the person who committed the despicable act — will be apprehended and made to pay for his crime.”
He paused and lowered his eyes.
“I pray with all my heart that anyone who knows anything about this crime will have the courage to come forward and speak with authorities. And I am happy and willing to act as an intermediary, if necessary, to ease the concerns of anyone who is afraid.
“While Martha is safe in the loving arms of her maker, in the company of her parents and her daughter, Clara, we need to provide justice. So that this community, like Martha herself, can rest in peace.”
At the end of the service, a line of mourners, most of them women, filed slowly past the casket. Some leaned over to kiss Martha’s cold face. Then Jimmy Westwood rose from his pew in front and led his three children to the $1,000 white casket. He lifted little Jimmy, who wore white like his sister, so he could kiss his mother goodbye. After putting the boy down, he bent forward again and kissed Martha’s forehead, his lips moving in a whisper. Then the casket was closed.
After the service, 2,000 mourners and curiosity seekers walked behind the hearse and 150 cars making the 2-mile trek to Mount Calvary Cemetery in Kennedy. In her reporter’s notebook, Anna Jane described women in gingham house dresses consoling others in summer frocks with wide-brimmed hats and white gloves. She observed grimy mill workers walking alongside politicians and businessmen in natty suits, all members of the squire’s circle.
The sun was high and there was not a hint of a breeze as Martha Westwood was buried in a plot near her parents, who had been interred only three years earlier. The earth above their caskets still bore a shovel’s scars.
Anna Jane looked over the faces in the crowd and suddenly did a double-take. Patsy Valicenti, a local bootlegger, was among the mourners, his signature crooked grin nowhere to be seen. He patted his sweating scalp with a handkerchief, working it around his collar and the back of his neck. Then he joined the tide of mourners as it ebbed back into the Bottoms.
As the others dispersed, the Westwood family remained standing around the gravesite. Constable Drexler stood next to Jimmy Westwood, his arm around his friend’s shoulders. A woman Anna Jane didn’t know began ushering the children back toward home, and Drexler and Westwood fell in step. A Sun-Telegraph photographer who had been dogging them all day stepped forward, and Jimmy — out of habit or vanity? — stopped and posed his family for a picture.
Anna Jane recognized a man standing off to the side, in the shade of one of the oak trees, watching everything. She walked over and flashed a friendly smile.
“Good morning, Chief Matsey,” she said. “I was looking for Detective Monaghan. I thought, what with him being in charge of the investigation and all, he might be here today.”
Michael Matsey, the McKees Rocks police chief, had on his Sunday church-going suit rather than his uniform. He pulled the toothpick he was gnawing from between his teeth and shook his head.
“He’s at county headquarters, working.”
“Huh,” the reporter replied. “Seems to me everyone in McKees Rocks was right here today. Lots of potential witnesses. Maybe even suspects?”
The chief seemed to hesitate, as if weighing a response. He finally looked directly at Anna Jane and quietly said, “He’s interviewing Catherine Cole again.”
She could not keep her eyes from widening.
“One of the party girls that was with Westwood that night,” she said.
Matsey nodded and then stepped into the line of people walking back into town.
Anna Jane scribbled furiously in her notebook and ran to her car. She had a story to write!
Sunday: Chapter 7: A Convenient Accident.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.