“A Murder of Convenience” is a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. It is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935.
The phone jangled by Anna Jane’s Phillip’s ear. The reporter fumbled for the earpiece and grabbed the mouthpiece.
“This is Anna Jane,” she mumbled, half-asleep.
“A.J., I need you!” came the familiar West Virginia drawl of Joe Shuman, city editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
She bolted up in bed, flicking on the bedside lamp and checking her watch. It was 3 a.m. “What for?”
“You need to get out to McKees Rocks. Jimmy Westwood’s wife’s been shot.”
“Squire Westwood?”
“Yeah. He’s been staying with a butcher, guy named Tkach.”
“Tack?”
“T-K-A-C-H. An apartment in the 100 block of Clay Alley. Take Carson to McKees Rocks, then go to the Bottoms.”
“Got it, Joe,” she snapped and yanked her nightgown over her head.
“Good. Look for our photographer when you get there.”
The phone went dead in her ear. She got dressed as fast as she could and ran to her car.

When A.J. pulled into Clay Alley 20 minutes later, police cars blocked the street. Gripping a notebook in one hand, she used the other to try to calm her windblown hair, then jammed a hat on her head. A train roared past, making the ground shake and drowning out voices.
Skimming the scene, A.J. spotted George Matovich, a borough cop she’d talked to before, crouched on a second-story porch.
In the alley stood a slim man with thick, wavy hair and a sheen of sweat on his face. She immediately recognized James Westwood, McKees Rocks’ justice of the peace. Next to him was his oldest daughter, who had her arms around her siblings, a girl and a boy. In the dim light, A.J. noted their thin legs.
“Stay still, kids,” Jimmy said, smiling as a photographer snapped a family portrait. A.J. hurried across the uneven bricks, grateful she had worn Oxfords.
“Mr. Westwood?” A.J. called. “Post-Gazette. Why do you think someone would kill your wife?”
“I can think of absolutely no motive,” he said woodenly.
“Why you livin’ here?” asked a photographer. A.J. recognized him as a Sun-Telegraph shutterbug.
“House blew up. Police said it was gas,” Westwood answered. “Mr. Tkach was generous enough to let us stay in this apartment…. We were gonna move back in next week, have a big party for Martha’s birthday, plus our anniversary.”
“How old was your wife?” A.J. asked.
“About to turn 37.”
“How many years were you married?”
“Twenty-one.” He wiped an eye. “She’s my teenage sweetheart.”
A.J. nodded. “These your kids?”
“Yeah,” he said, growing impatient. The older daughter shot A.J. a strange look.
“Jim, you might want to look away now,” a patrolman said to Westwood.
Men were coming down the back steps, grunting under the weight of a gurney carrying a sheet-covered body. A.J. pushed her glasses up her nose, noticing the heft of the woman’s body. As she turned to Westwood, his face suddenly contorted.
“Oh, God!’ he wailed. “Who could have done this?”
He hid his face in his hands, his shoulders shaking. Seeing their father break down, all three children began to sob.
A.J. waited while the men loaded the body into the coroner’s Chrysler. Their departure seemed to lift the family’s grief a bit. Westwood raised his face from his hands and patted his daughter’s shoulder.
“It’s OK, Princess,” he said. “It’s over.”
The reporter had a sudden intuition. “You were there?” she asked.
The young woman lowered her eyes and nodded.
“What’s your name?” A.J. tried to sound calm, but her heart was pounding.
“Bertha Ann,” came the soft reply.
“What did you see, Bertha Ann?”
“Now, Princess...” her father said, frowning.
“I heard three gunshots,” she said. “I ran into her room — she was facing away from me — and said, ‘Mama, did you hear those shots?’”
In the gloom, A.J. saw her lower lip tremble.
“She didn’t answer. That’s when I saw the blood. I screamed and called the police.”
“That’s enough, Princess,” Westwood said, an edge to his voice.
He turned to A.J. “No more questions, lady. It’s been a busy night.”
“Where were you when it happened?” she asked, not ready to give up.
“I was with Tim Drexler, the constable. He can vouch for me,” he replied defensively. “We went out to the Main Street Hotel....”
“Where’s that?”
“In Carnegie. We got some mineral water.”
Noticing A.J.’s raised eyebrow, he continued.
“I take the waters. Got a pain from an operation. We left around 11:20.”
“Where’d you go then?”
“Eddie Peyton’s Roadhouse.”
“Peyton’s? On Steubenville Pike?”
“Yeah, that’s the one.”
“A night club, on a work night?” A.J. said dubiously.
“Well, Tim and me, we wanted to see the midnight show.… I didn’t have hearings in the morning. We were goin’ fishing!”
“What time did you leave?” A.J. pressed.
“Around 2 o’clock. When I got to the police station, they told me to get out here right away because Martha had been shot.
“Oh! Who would do this to poor Martha? Everyone loved her. We never had no trouble. Why, if I had 6 bucks, I’d give her 5. Didn’t I, Bertha?” he said, pulling his daughter to him.
“Yes, sir,” she said quietly.
“Mr. Westwood, can I talk to you?” said a man behind A.J.
It was that damn Sun-Telly reporter! A guy from the Pittsburgh Press was there, too, and reporters from Little Washington, Beaver, even Johnstown! A flash bulb went off as Westwood turned his back on A.J., Bertha Ann in tow.
“Whadya need, boys?” he said congenially.
A.J. eyed the crowd, looking for another interview.
“I saw him!” cried an excited woman in a robe holding a baby on her hip. “I heard the shots, ran to the window and looked into the alley. I saw this man running from Helen Street. He didn’t seem to know which way to go.”
“What’d he look like?” A.J. asked eagerly.
“Tall, thin, long, curly dark hair. Dark trousers and a blue shirt.”
“What did you do?”
“I didn’t do anything. My Richard started to cry, and the man looked up at me.... Then he ran down the alley.”
“Your name?”
“Sophie Sehar. S-E-H-A-R. That’s Mrs. Sophie Sehar.”
A.J. checked her watch. It was almost 4:30 a.m. She had to file a story by 7 to catch the second edition. She stuffed her notebook in her bag and headed for her car.
The little knot of neighbors began talking in low voices to each other. She wished she had time to talk to them. Early light was just silvering the gutters of the hillside houses as she drove back Downtown.
Friday: Chapter 5: A Witness and the Wax





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.