“A Murder of Convenience” is a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. It is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935.

McKees Rocks residents call the wide, desolate stretch of lowlands between the Ohio River and the town’s hills the Bottoms. For the first half of the 20th century, the Schoen Steel plant filled the sky with smoke during the day and the light of flaming furnaces at night. The railroad yard provided a symphony of screeching steel wheels on rusting tracks and the concussive booms of rail cars colliding.

Rows of shabby wooden houses lined cobblestone streets and alleys carved into the hilly slopes, their long wooden staircases snaking down to yards and thoroughfares. Small, family-owned grocery stores, shoe shops, beauty salons and barber shops were squeezed between the churches and taverns that defined the community’s split personality.

There were two movie theaters three blocks apart on Chartiers Avenue. On July 9, the Roxian was showing a Mae West movie — “Goin’ to Town” — and the Orpheum featured Shirley Temple in “Our Little Girl.”

Advertise with us

Just before the 7:15 p.m. show, Jimmy Westwood pulled up to the Orpheum in his Ford Roadster and got out to open the back door for his daughter, Martha, 11, and son, James Jr., 7.

“As soon as the show’s over, you go find Mama,” he said to his daughter, counting 30 cents into her pale palm. “And be sure to hold Jimmy’s hand. Got it?”

“Yes, sir,” she replied stiffly as she grabbed her brother’s hand and waved to their mother in the passenger seat.

“Give my regards to Shirley!” Martha Westwood called out through the rolled down window and blew her children a kiss. “See you soon!”

Her round, pleasant face darkened as her husband got back into the driver’s seat.

Advertise with us

“You dress ’em like a couple Katzenjammer Kids,” Jimmy snarled as he pulled away from the curb. “What you got against Shirley Temple? You should be in there with ’em, not watching that floozy, Mae West!”

“You could take them to the show, too!” Martha shot back. “But that might cut into your time with the boys.”

Husband and wife said nothing more as Jimmy let her out at the Roxian. His tires screeched as he took off down Chartiers Avenue toward the police station and his office as McKees Rocks’ justice of the peace.

Jimmy arrived to find Bill Meisner, one of his constables, razzing Allegheny County police Detective Walter Monaghan.

“A Murder of Convenience,” a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935. Read past chapters here.

“Hey Walt, what brings you to the Bottoms? Shouldn’t you be taking a nap?”

Advertise with us

A smile lit up the Allegheny County detective’s face. The former railroad worker still boasted a shock of blond hair, but he’d long lost the fighting trim of the middleweight boxer who once battled “The Pittsburgh Windmill,” Harry Greb.

“Wanted to make sure our fishing trip is still on tonight,” Monaghan said.

Jimmy Westwood broke in, an unlit cigarette in his mouth and a lighter in his hand. “You boys headed to Pine Lake?”

“Yeah, I got a place there,” Monaghan said.

“Sounds nice,” Jimmy said. “Mind if I tag along? Tim Drexler and me are headed to Eddie Peyton’s Roadhouse tonight for the midnight floor show. We’ll be getting home around 2 a.m. I can drive. We’ll get an early start fishin’!”

Advertise with us

Monaghan hesitated. He didn’t know Westwood well enough to go fishing with him in the middle of the night. Still, it never hurt to be seen with the justice of the peace, especially one with Westwood’s clout. He nodded and smiled at the squire.

“It’s a date! My boy’s coming too. Hope you don’t mind.”

“Not at all!” Jimmy answered with a crooked smile.

***

After a late movie and a bumpy streetcar ride home with two crabby youngsters, Martha Westwood was too tired to help cut out a dress. But Bertha Ann, her oldest child, was excited so she faked enthusiasm.

Advertise with us

“This will look fine on you at church this Sunday!” she said as they pinned the paper blueprint to blue cotton. “When it’s done, you can help your mama sew curtains for the house. Won’t it be nice to be back home? The contractors took so long.”

“We’ll have so much more room!” Bertha Ann said, looking around the three-room apartment. “I’ll have my own bedroom.”

“Maybe then you’ll get to bed at a reasonable hour,” her mother said, smiling. “Don’t stay up too late. A pretty girl like you shouldn’t have bags under her eyes…. I’m bushed. Remember to leave the door unlocked for your father.”

Martha kissed her daughter’s cheek and was asleep practically the moment her head hit the pillow. She was so tired she forgot to turn off the small lamp on the bedside table.

***

Advertise with us

“I’m getting too old for the foxtrot,” a sweaty, breathless Jimmy Westwood announced to his companions as the band finished a set at Peyton’s Roadhouse. “I got this round. Two Tom Collins for the girls, rye and rocks for Tim and a bourbon and club soda for the old squire!”

Peg Moran looped her arm through Jimmy’s as he headed to the bar, eyeing the girls from the floor show in their feathered outfits.

“Always the gentleman, Jim,” she said. “How you gonna get up for your hearings tomorrow? I feel sorry for the poor slobs standing in front of a judge with a hangover!”

“I can hold my liquor,” Jimmy replied, laughing.

The crowd around the bar parted for the justice of the peace, who called out his order and lingered to soak in the boozy laughter. When the drinks appeared, Jimmy laid a dollar on the bar, handed the Tom Collinses to Peg and grabbed the other cocktails.

Advertise with us

“This’ll have to be our nightcap,” he said as he set down the drinks and slid into his seat. “I got a 2 a.m. date with a couple gents and a trout.”

Despite their groans, Drexler and their dates didn’t seem too upset that their evening was winding down. They had to work on Wednesday.

***

The streets of the Bottoms were empty and quiet at 1:30 a.m., the night sounds muffled by the heavy, humid air of a July night. Fans in cages whirred in nearly every open bedroom window on Ella Street and Clay Alley. But Sophie Sehar was awake. The mother of three half-dozed on her feet by an open window, trying to rock her teething baby back to sleep. Then three bangs jolted her awake.

“Since when does a car backfire three times?” she wondered, looking up and down the cobbled alley for a car. Then she caught sight of a thin figure walking down the alley toward her. He stopped at the corner, seemingly unsure of which way to go.

Advertise with us

She stiffened as the baby in her arms let out a soft cry, prompting the man to look up directly into her eyes. She could see his face in the streetlamp — handsome, clean-cut but with long, dark, curly hair. Almost like a wig, she thought to herself.

He turned and sprinted out of sight down Munson Avenue.

Clay Alley suddenly came to life, lights appearing in every window, groggy voices calling out and then a young woman’s scream: “Mama’s been shot! Call the police!”

***

Jimmy Westwood pulled up at the police station at 2:45 a.m. and turned to Drexler. “I’m gonna stop in the office. You sure you don’t mind taking Peg home?”

Advertise with us

Drexler was already out of the car and jogging around to the driver’s seat. “No trouble, boss.”

Westwood was heading to his parked car when he saw George Matovich, a McKees Rocks patrolman, running out of the police station, his face red and sweaty.

“Have you been home?” he asked breathlessly.

Jimmy shook his head. “No, why?”

“Well, you’d better go right away! Your wife’s been shot!”

Wednesday: Chapter 4: Who shot the Squire’s Wife?