“A Murder of Convenience” is a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. It is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935.

George Matuza squinted at his alarm clock and sighed. 1:45 a.m. He had to get up in less than four hours. He pictured himself wolfing down cornflakes and kissing Barbara before running to catch the No. 25 streetcar.

Rain that afternoon had cooled a July night in McKees Rocks, but the humidity and his asthma still troubled the steelworker from Yugoslavia. He raised himself to look across Clay Alley and was surprised to see the Westwoods’ light on. Martha Westwood usually turned in around 11:30, and Jimmy, from what he heard around town, was probably just finishing his third drink at some tavern.

Martha had done all right for a German girl, George figured. Jimmy was just a constable who boxed a little when he married the prettiest girl in the Bottoms 20 years ago. Now Jimmy was the justice of the peace and a big shot in this Republican town.

Advertise with us

“Does she ever think about me?” George wondered, remembering how the slim teenager had helped him with his English when he lived on the third floor of her parents’ house.  Did he imagine she had a crush on an immigrant 12 years older than her?

The lessons stopped when Jimmy Westwood came along, and George met Barbara. They had nine children, five more than Martha and Jimmy, but who’s counting?

A gunshot stirred George from his reverie. He sat up in time to see twin flashes and hear two more shots from the Westwoods’ porch. He ducked, afraid he might be next. Finally, he crept to the window and looked out.

A man stood below him, looking up and down Clay Alley. There was no concern on his rugged face, which was partly hidden by long curly hair. He knew that face. What he couldn’t know was that this face, this murder, would fill newspapers’ front pages for the rest of the summer.

***

Advertise with us

May 25, 1935: George usually stood on the trolley through McKees Rocks until he got off a few blocks away from his apartment in Clay Alley. But today his 48-year-old body was hurting from a grueling shift at the Coraopolis forging plant, so he took a seat in the back of the streetcar.

“A Murder of Convenience,” a serial novel by writers at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, is based on a real crime in the summer of 1935. Read past chapters here.

James Johnston, a young co-worker sitting next to him, asked if he was feeling OK.

“Yah, fine, joost fine,” George answered in an accent betraying his Eastern European birth. “Tired today.”

“I bet you’re tired!” James exclaimed. “You stamped 125 pieces before lunch, more than anyone else!”

George managed a weak smile. James, the only Black worker at Pittsburgh Forging Co., always tried to raise his spirits. Maybe because he was the only one paid less than stampers like George. He knew James got off the trolley somewhere down the line in Pittsburgh. He’d never asked where James lived.

Advertise with us

George perked up at the sight of the Island Avenue stop. He scanned the sidewalk, hoping to see a few of his nine children waiting for him. On this mild May day, there were two — 10-year-old Olga and 6-year-old Frank. The boy was hanging on to the stop sign at an angle, his right arm swinging limp, a goofy smile on his round face. Olga was leaning against the brick wall of a market.

“Kisgyereks!” he called to them, breaking his promise to himself to use more English.

But something was wrong. As he stepped off the trolley, Olga didn’t hug him so much as slump into his side, her head under his arm.

“Everything OK?” he asked, peering down into her face.

“The Westwoods had another fight,” she said.

Advertise with us

“Mrs. Westwood broke a dish!” Frank said loudly.

George turned to see whether they had been heard by other trolley passengers getting off. He didn’t want to spread neighborhood gossip. Then he tucked his calloused hands under each child’s arms and half-carried them home. Olga giggled as he lifted her out of her funk.

Marie Matuza, 21, still lived at home and earned a few dollars a week helping Mrs. Westwood with housework and her two younger children. Bertha Ann Westwood, who studied at a Downtown business college, was two years younger than Marie. Her parents rarely spoke to each other in front of Marie. When they did, they often argued.

George had known Jimmy Westwood for 20 years and Martha for 21. He’d heard about Jimmy Westwood before he met him. As a little kid, Jimmy had been the first to dig up ancient bones in the Indian burial mound at the edge of the Bottoms.

By 1935, Squire Westwood was one of the most powerful men in McKees Rocks. “Dapper Jimmy” — the nickname reporters gave him — prided himself on his wavy hair and $25 suits tailored to fit his compact, wiry frame. The Republican power broker who counted police officers and politicians as friends had a reputation as a good provider for his family and a notorious womanizer. Smart folks in the Bottoms knew to stay on his good side.

Advertise with us

Two years earlier, Jimmy Westwood had beaten a charge of jury tampering during a trial over whether he had charged Allegheny County for trying fictitious cases. But he wasn’t so lucky two months later when he and four others were convicted in federal court of voter fraud in the 1932 election for opening ballot boxes to change votes. Still, he cheerily walked the streets and carried out his duties while his attorneys pursued appeals.

George and other neighbors were wary of Jimmy, but they revered his wife. Martha Westwood was a buxom, handsome woman who favored gingham dresses she sewed herself. She was bright and sociable, a member of Ohio Valley Hospital’s ladies auxiliary, vice president of the Women’s Republican Club and a Sunday school teacher at First Presbyterian Church. Martha was famous for the hearty meals she prepared for the women in her card clubs.

But she carried a terrible burden of grief. In 1932, the Westwoods’ 14-year-old daughter, Clara, had died of a gunshot wound from her father’s revolver. It was said that she’d accidentally shot herself in the abdomen while examining the gun. Martha stayed with Clara in Ohio Valley Hospital for 11 days while the teenager clung to life.

A few months later, Martha’s parents died in a murder-suicide in the Westwood home. Police said her stepfather, a steady, hardworking man, had snapped, killing her mother and then himself with a .32-caliber pistol.

In February, their house on nearby Ella Street was destroyed in a gas explosion and fire. The Westwoods and their three children moved into an apartment above Joe Tkach’s meat market while the house was rebuilt.

Advertise with us

The couple were planning a neighborhood party to celebrate their return to their Ella Street home in late July. It was also the Westwoods’ 21st wedding anniversary and Martha’s 38th birthday. They had just invited the Matuzas a week earlier. The fancy invitation was sitting on a table by the door of their upstairs apartment.

As George and the two children walked the alley’s cobblestones toward home, he looked over his shoulder at the Westwoods’ apartment. It was quiet now, but he could imagine the yelling, the dish breaking, Martha crying. He had heard it before.

Right now, his only concern was calming his daughter. He felt weary again as he climbed the stairs.

***

Reporter Anna Jane Phillips burst into the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette newsroom, her shoes still caked with earth from walking around the Willow Grove Coal Mine with Eleanor Roosevelt. Despite the 60-mile drive from Bellaire, Ohio, Anna Jane was excited. She had a front-page story.

Advertise with us

The diminutive, bespectacled daughter of Pittsburgh industrialist John McFarlane Phillips was known as A.J. by everyone at the Post-Gazette. The graduate of Vassar College and Columbia University had returned home five years earlier to be a feature writer, covering movie stars, beauty contests and cooking schools. But she was starting to get juicier assignments after earning the respect of city editor Joseph Shuman.

The previous spring, she had covered the trial of Swissvale police Chief Tom Cummings, who was convicted of shooting and murdering his wife in their bedroom.

The 28-year-old reporter had just filed a story about the first lady’s train ride from Washington, D.C., and trip 2 miles into the earth to view Ohio miners’ working conditions. Now back in the Downtown newsroom, she darted past her desk and approached the city editor, who smiled at her over the top of his Corona typewriter.

“Great stuff, A.J.,” he said, stubbing a cigarette in an ashtray. He began to read aloud the story she had dictated a few hours earlier from Ohio:

“Women in shapeless house dresses, heavy work-worn men holding babies high above their heads so the youngsters could glimpse the President’s wife ...”

Advertise with us

“I like it,” he said. “But try to make sure your next assignment doesn’t end up with coal dust on your nose.”

The young reporter was wiping the bridge of her glasses before she realized he was teasing her.

“I’ll see you later,” she said, blushing and turning on her heel.

Tomorrow: Chapter 2: Babes in the Ballpark