Polls indicated that 81 percent of white evangelical Christians voted for Donald Trump for president in 2016.
In his new book, Rob Schenck, known in the 1980s and 1990s primarily for his anti-abortion activism and his connections to the religious right, explains why he’s no longer among that group. That makes “Costly Grace: An Evangelical Minister’s Rediscovery of Faith, Hope, and Love” important in its own right.
The most alarming part of this narrative is his admission, borne out with numerous anecdotes, that his side never bothered to reach out to anyone it considered an enemy — which may explain our divided politics today.
"COSTLY GRACE: AN EVANGELICAL MINISTER’S REDISCOVERY OF FAITH, HOPE AND LOVE"
By Rob Schenck
Harper ($26.99).
Mr. Schenck is the director of the Dietrich Bonhoeffer Institute, named for the German theologian martyred toward the end of World War II for plotting against Hitler. Mr. Schenck did a doctoral dissertation on Bonhoeffer and uses one of his most famous quotes — “Our struggle is for costly grace” — as the title of his book.
In fact, Mr. Schenck displays a Bonhoefferian spirit of humility and contrition that by his own admission wasn’t found during his activist years, most notably with Operation Rescue in Buffalo, N.Y. He also mentioned that, while researching for that doctorate, Bonhoeffer showed respect for the guards during his imprisonment, in contrast to the complaints about being incarcerated that he and other Christians made, especially during his time with Operation Rescue.
I can only imagine, given his need to risk a break with many of his friends and especially his financial backers over the years in the process, just how hard “Costly Grace” was to write. I admit to not being aware of all the issues in which he says he was involved — the Terri Schiavo case, the shooting of the Amish girls in Lancaster County, the situation with the lesbian Houston mayor, the Planned Parenthood “baby parts” controversy — and space doesn’t allow me to mention everything he encountered. That speaks to the depth of his experience, which would make the book even more compelling and comprehensive.
Descriptions abound of the often-stifling artificial lifestyle to which conservative evangelicals, more notably in its charismatic/Pentecostal wing — Mr. Schenck was originally ordained in the Assemblies of God — were expected to subscribe and the toll it took on his family.
Among other things, Mr. Schenck had to contend with rampant, sometimes-blatant patriarchal sexism. Upon learning that his wife, Cheryl, was planning to pursue a graduate degree in counseling, “One [of our donors] went to the bother of flying from Chicago to Seattle for a fatherly talk with me, telling me that [she] needed to withdraw from school and get back home where she belonged.”
Deep down, he understood that, due to his people-pleasing, he’d gotten off-track. “The vision that first drew me to ministry, of the parson, the shepherd caring for his lost sheep ... was getting lost in the oversized, frantic, belligerent warrior priest, the model of a pro-life clergyman that I had become.”
One situation that caused a change in his thinking was an encounter with an African-American pastor from suburban Washington, D.C., right after the 2008 general election. While they agreed on political/moral issues, that pastor said he was celebrating the election of Barack Obama to the presidency, telling Mr. Schenck, “Today I am as much a man as you are.” To that Mr. Schenck admitted, “This was a long-overdue validation of their very humanity. ... I had self-righteously questioned whether God could really love liberals like Barack Obama, Bill and Hillary Clinton and countless others who opposed us, because their political beliefs appeared so patently hostile to God’s moral will.”
And after attending the Republican National Convention in 2016, “I resolved that what I had been witness to in Cleveland was the final moral collapse of the politicized religion that had infected me and millions of others back in the [1980s], when American evangelicals entered into their Faustian bargain pact with Ronald Reagan’s party. Nothing good could come of this badly diseased body.”
Conservative evangelical Trump supporters might consider Mr. Schenck a turncoat. He’d say the same about them, as “Trump’s victory was the direct result of the evangelical sellout I had mourned after the Cleveland convention.”
This is the first book about such a dramatic change of heart by an evangelical leader that I’m aware of. There needs to be more.
Rick Nowlin: rnowlin@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3871.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.