When longtime film critic Janet Maslin retired, The New York Times took a chance on a boyish-looking book reviewer with the catchy first initials of A.O. That was 15 years ago. Anthony Oliver Scott, now the paper’s chief film critic, has earned a well-deserved reputation for his keen observations, sharp wit and rigorous analysis. He’s a thinker, for sure.

"BETTER LIVING THROUGH CRITICISM: HOW TO THINK ABOUT ART, PLEASURE, BEAUTY AND TRUTH"

By A.O. Scott

Penguin Press ($28).

Advertise with us

After all, this is a guy who graduated magna cum laude from Harvard and is Distinguished Professor of Film Criticism at Wesleyan University.  So it’s no surprise “Better Living Through Criticism: How to Think About Art, Pleasure, Beauty and Truth” is quite academic, sometimes exhaustingly so. Best keep a dictionary handy — it’s laced with words like “tautology,” “shibboleth,” “ontological” and “epistemological.”

However, his point that all art (yes, he willingly wanders into that minefield, “what is art?”) can and should be subjected to intellectual scrutiny is well-taken. Beginning with Aristotle, he attempts to build for us a foundation of the history and philosophy of criticism. He examines the museum in Western civilization, using the Louvre as the quintessential example. And finally he explores the role of the critic in an ever-changing world, and presents criticism as a noble, if misunderstood — even despised — endeavor.

I particularly enjoyed chapter five, where Mr. Scott shows us the many ways critics are fallible. Some can only appreciate the traditional stuff (and “wonder why they don’t make movies like ‘Bringing Up Baby’ any more”). Others are seduced by anything shiny and new. “The glare of [the new] can be blinding, and what may come to seem a ... tacky facade of novelty may look, in the flush of enthusiastic discovery, like the revolutionary real stuff.” Critics, it turns out, are like the rest of the human race, myopic. “The great falsifier of critical judgment is time.”

Wait, can I get college credit for this, you may be thinking.

To lighten things up, Mr. Scott intersperses mock interviews with himself, similar to David Foster Wallace’s “Brief Interviews With Hideous Men.” Here, the “discourse” is way more relaxed. For instance, when the faux interviewer asks, “Have you seen the movie ‘Ratatouille’?” he replies, “Yes. We saw it together. You cried the whole time.”

Advertise with us

Naturally he mourns the decline of print newspapers and literary periodicals, and laments the rise of rankings, ratings, lists, metrics and “the cult of data” in the digital era. “It’s a mystery and a horror to me that people are blindly trusting of aggregated or dubiously sourced opinion.” Though the Internet has seemingly limitless space for posting opinion, he fears true criticism is losing the good debate, the back and forth, essentially, its voice. “Just as sculpture and painting are arts of the hand and acting is an art of the body, criticism is, above all, an art of the voice,” he says like a poet.

He ponders the future of thoughtful criticism as a whole, and as a job. “Whether it should be a profession and how long it is likely to remain one are matters very much open to doubt.”

Did Siskel & Ebert know what they unleashed with their succinct thumbs-up or down? Mr. Scott realizes there’s no going back, but he still bravely calls for better, clearer, deeper and slower analysis, as well as quality formats for expressing and debating opinions with respect.

Ultimately his book is a critique of thinking, and the direction it seems to be headed. It’s profound, even if parts of it are a slog, and it’s more than a little sad for those of us who’ve always believed that a smart review is itself a work of art.

Carol O’Sullivan has taught film history since 1985. Her first critic-crush was George Anderson, from this very newspaper.