"Foundry patterns are in many cases the last three-dimensional representations of the machines that once defined the steel mills [of our region's] industrial cities. ... As we enter the 21st century, they are symbols recalling our industrial past. Just as our forebears looked at the pre-industrial world of 19th century America with a nostalgic and idealistic gaze at the turn of the last century, we now look back at the era of industrialization with that same nostalgic eye. These patterns are symbols of the machinery of mass production from a time when steel communities were at the pinnacle of industrial achievement."

-- From "The Pattern Maker's Art: A Century of Industrial Artistry," Johnstown Area Heritage Association

In the old Polaroid photos, my father stands next to a large circular mold on the floor of the pattern shop of U.S. Steel in Johnstown. He and a fellow pattern maker, both dressed in work shirts and shop aprons, are dwarfed by the size of the pattern that would soon be cast in steel and go on to become part of an industrial machine used in the mill, or one of many steel mills throughout the United States.

For this particular project, my father was the inspector, or "checker," the person responsible for insuring the patterns were made correctly and to exact specifications. After each inspection, a black-and-white photo, like the one I keep in my desk, was taken of the successful mold to file away.

Advertise with us

For over 30 years, my father made his living as a pattern maker. He loved this exclusive and somewhat mysterious industrial trade that involved a unique mix of art and science.

As a kid, each day when his lunch bucket clanged onto the Formica kitchen table, announcing his return from the mill at 3 p.m., I scarcely understood what it was that put the sirloin or salmon cakes on the table for dinner each night. I didn't comprehend much about what my father did hovering over algebraic sums and blueprints that he mentioned were scattered on his pattern shop desk at the mill.

When I tell people what my dad did for a living, I often get blank stares, or the impression that the person believes my father worked in textiles or sewing. Unless of course I'm talking to a former mill worker. Often they'll squint their eyes at me and say things like, Oh, it's not easy to be a pattern maker ... One time an elderly neighbor on a Johnstown porch added cryptically: You have to see things no one else sees, referring to the need for the pattern maker to visualize in three dimensions what is only represented in mechanical designs on paper.

This is a job where the craftsman must be content to give birth to a precision project -- filled with laborious measurement, geometry and art -- that he will likely never see in its ultimate finished form. It is these rich metaphors and details of the trade -- one that requires such a duality in the right and left brains of the worker -- that has become a catalyst of inspiration for a book of poetry set in my home city of Johnstown, ("The Pattern Maker's Daughter" was published by Bottom Dog Press' Working Lives Series, a series that seeks to keep working class and blue-collar themes alive.)

The nexus of pattern making was that it was an "inside job." The artisan created replicas of future objects in molds -- the exact interior of what would be cast to become a machine part or other steel object.

Advertise with us

It's always been difficult to describe the pattern maker's trade and its origins. According to "A History of the Pattern Maker's Society," a document created in Britain at the turn of the century, it "cannot claim pure descent from any particular type of craftsman. A forerunner to the pattern maker could have been the millwright, but that craftsman was father to numerous other tradesman." It is related to the blacksmith, but more varied. In metalsmithing, it could be compared in some respects to the process of "lost-wax casting." It also took a certain perceptual vision and artist's eye. You had to be good at math, but also highly skilled as a woodworker to do the work.

As I wrote many poems influenced by the steel city landscape of Johnstown and this blue-collar trade, I peppered my father with more questions. I wanted to know more about a job that involved painstaking work that would be cast aside for a new, fresh metamorphosis.


I had always suspected that my dad was a closet artist. He could draw anything. Sometimes you'd find a pencil rendering on a simple sheet of plain paper left on his desk in the dining room. I knew from his reports over family dinners that his job was considered to be the "highest trade" in the mill. In the 1930s and '40s, my dad said, pattern makers wore shirts and bow ties to work.

This only enhanced the fact that pattern makers seemed to inhabit an "exclusive club" and one that was difficult to break into. Even after dressing up for work I faded after World War II, an "old-school" apprenticeship was the only way a worker could become a member of that club.

Advertise with us

My dad had been working as a laborer in the mills for two years, beginning in 1950, straight out of high school. His father, Gustav, had come from Germany to work in Bethlehem Steel and his son would do the same. In 1952, my father saw a posted sign for a pattern making apprenticeship and applied. Taking the required math tests, he knew the competition would be fierce and selective. Of dozens of men who desired the apprenticeship, only two were accepted: my father and a man named John Mish.

They would go on to become good buddies as they served their apprenticeship and took the ICS (International Correspondence School) courses required to be certified in the trade. The mill supplied a classroom for ICS and apprentices were required to go to classes twice a week, taking tests that were then sent into the national school for grading.

Learning the craft was like a dream come true for my dad, who by then already had the first of his four children to support. But it was short-lived. Bethlehem Steel laid him off after three years into his work.

After taking a 20-year detour into sales and other positions that he never liked nearly as much and which tested his spirit at times, he was able to swing back into the trade by an unlikely route. During the worst of the steel crisis, he moved solo to Seattle, Wash., to do a stint for Boeing as a pattern maker for plane parts. He sent his earnings home to my mom who was raising the children -- the whole time longing for the hills of Western Pennsylvania.

But the upside of being temporarily away from home was that he managed to have Boeing supply him with the paperwork needed to classify him as a "C" Grade pattern maker. This allowed him entry into U.S. Steel (which eventually became Johnstown Corporation) and to earn his way into an "A" rating, where he could do the work he felt he was meant to do until his retirement in 1997. "I loved every day of it," he says. "Every pattern was different and a challenge. And fun. It was great work."

Advertise with us

Today, I know a lot more about pattern making than I ever did in the 1970s when growing up in Johnstown and could have learned all I cared to simply by driving along with my father over to Moxham's Bar and Wire plant.

I know that the first thing a pattern maker does is calculate the "shrinkage rate" of various metals so that they can make the tiny allowances for the molds to fit once shrunken and cast in steel. I know that the "the pattern maker has to proceed to build and carve the pattern out of wood, keeping in mind the needs of the molder who would actually cast the item in a mold made of hardened sand," according to "The Pattern Maker's Art: A Century of Industrial Artistry."

But mostly I understand how the pattern maker must have vision and contentment to labor at a job that serves a crucial but fleeting step in a larger process. I see how a first-generation immigrant woodworker can also have the eye of the artist to see three-dimensionally into the future of the steel machinery of an era from the flat lines of the blueprints on his desk.

I see that vision in my patient and humble father and celebrate the unique mix of hard mill work ethic and the artist's hand that drew the circus elephants and other images on paper to charm his daughter many years ago.


Advertise with us

My father was pleasantly surprised several years ago while visiting the Johnstown Heritage Museum with my brothers and me on a holiday. We took the elevator to the third floor and came upon a curated display: "The Lost Art of Pattern Making." Room after room of blueprints and labyrinths of huge wood patterns defining and celebrating what my dad had done all those years, and explaining it in layman's terms for the public to enjoy.

The look of surprise mixed with delight that came over his face was one I'll never forget. That day he became the docent, and his children the attentive students.

On the drive home, he said, "I never dreamed anyone would be interested enough in what I did to put it in a museum."

And that is, I believe, how it should be. The beauty and dignity of the work of the pattern maker is not one to be boasted about, but savored quietly and eloquently as the old wooden form that sits atop my living room mantle, branded with the iron numerals that would set it apart from the thousands of other forms that went on to be hardened and cast into steel, completing the life cycle of the pattern as it was meant to be.


Advertise with us

"The Pattern Makers"

By Sandee Gertz Umbach

Johnstown, I want to be your Eugene Smith,

shoot Graflex still shots

of men's hardened hands, blue veins around steel.

Advertise with us

I want to capture pattern makers from the 1950s

when they sized molds in shirts and ties,

figuring their Algebraic sums in Moxham's Bar & Wire,

pencil in ear, like my father and his father lifting

their prints to the shop light, exacting

Advertise with us

measurements of what steel will cast and harden.

Not everyone can be a patter maker,

old men on porches tell me.

You have to see things no one else sees.

Like petunias blooming through concrete

Advertise with us

up against tumble-down houses, rising shapes

where there are only flat lines.

Driving his Buick across Broad Avenue to the mill's iron gate

my father often said he saw himself instead turning

the wheel and taking off for Route 30 West -

Advertise with us

climbing the steep summit and setting up

brushes and canvas, where for years,

he'd talked of painting the sunrise.

What did he envision beyond the craggy tops

of mountains that rimmed our valley city,

Advertise with us

lulling us all into forgetting there was an open sky?

In the deep folds of the hills, German Lutheran men pace

silent rooms, push quarters to the edges of tired bars as pitchers

of beer lower and foam. Hundreds are sent by wives to scrub

in basement sinks, wringing their fingers under the copper faucets,

Advertise with us

while my father dreams of the deep Black Forest,

holding his unopened tubes of Burnt Sienna.

Today when I drive the gray streets, small, bent-over

women mop porches on calloused knees.

Smith would take a picture of their wrinkled housedresses,

Advertise with us

but I would capture the mill men posed on patios,

gazing out to the Alleghenies, the patterns

of each hill, folding and unfolding in their hands.