Although J.D. Salinger died Wednesday, nothing has changed. He's still unavailable for comment.

The reclusive author of "The Catcher in the Rye" died at 91 of natural causes at his fenced-in home in rural New Hampshire, where he moved 53 years ago from New York City in a defiant rejection of the public life of an American writer.

Unlike his contemporaries John Cheever, Norman Mailer, Philip Roth and John Updike, who played active roles in literary culture, Mr. Salinger, like Melville's Bartleby the Scrivener, simply preferred not to.

He followed his popular novel with three short story collections -- "Nine Stories," "Franny and Zooey" and "Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters and Seymour: An Introduction." Their stories previously appeared in The New Yorker magazine mostly in the 1950s.

Advertise with us

His last published story was "Hapworth 16, 1924," appearing in the magazine in 1965. No more words emerged from his New Hampshire home except in lawsuits challenging the republishing of a story and the unauthorized use of his letters in a 1988 biography.

"The Catcher in the Rye" appeared in 1951, set in the 1940s when gathering pessimism and paranoia followed World War II. In its teenage hero, Holden Caulfield, the novel called into question the conventions of success and adulthood.

In a way, "The Catcher in the Rye" prefigured America's creation of the teen market a decade later when rock 'n' roll music became anthems for the young and the novel became the credo of a generation ready to question authority.

Holden viewed his elders as "phonies" and his encounters with adults, including a prostitute and her pimp and a gay teacher, convinced him to reject the grown-up world for his younger sister Phoebe. They do childish things like visit the zoo and ride a merry-go-round.

When she asks him what he wants to be, he replies that he can see himself as a guardian of young children playing in a rye field near a cliff:

Advertise with us

"I have to catch everybody if they start to go over that cliff ... I'd just be the catcher in the rye and all. I know it's crazy, but that's the only thing I'd like to be."

"We forget how daring 'Catcher' was -- is -- because it's the industry standard and assigned to every high schooler," said novelist Stewart O'Nan, who lives Regent Square. "But imagine coming to it fresh and on your own, having never seen or heard anything like it.

"All I can compare his achievement to is that of James Dean -- both of them inscrutable, inescapable originals who can't be improved on."

The novel also launched the genre today called "young adult fiction" for teen readers subsisting on a diet of Hardy Boys and Nancy Drew reared by parents who viewed them as adults-in-training, preparing for a career and family in suburbia.

With his profane slang, drinking and world-weariness, Holden spoke a language teens could understand, but their parents couldn't.

Advertise with us

"Before 'Catcher in the Rye,' everybody looked at children through rose-colored glasses," said Katherine Ayres, young adult author and writing instructor in children's literature at Chatham University. "Salinger and S.E. Hinton created the field of young adult books and inspired plenty of writers to follow them."

Mr. O'Nan agrees. The Pittsburgh native with 12 novels to his credit said, "Every author who uses a teenaged first-person has to deal with Salinger, still 50 plus years down the road."

"Snow Angels," Mr. O'Nan's first novel, is set in Butler with high school students as key characters.

"He nailed that desperate combination of feigned nonchalance, braggadocio and self-pity better than anyone since Sherwood Anderson, and did it without any literary models."

Mrs. Ayres, however, continues to favor Mr. Salinger's short stories about the fictional Glass family in their Upper West Side New York apartment that included the children Seymour, Franny and Zooey.

Advertise with us

"I first encountered these stories in The New Yorker and was so taken by them, more than 'Catcher in the Rye,' " she said. "There was such a poignancy to them that these characters always stay with me."

With their urban neurosis and spiritual angst, the Glasses were a good fit for The New Yorker whose editor, William Shawn, remained one of Mr. Salinger's friends after he left New York.

The author's affection for his fictional family contradicted his image as a cantankerous crank whose foibles were revealed in two books -- "At Home in the World" (1998) by Joyce Maynard and "Dream Catcher" (2000) by his daughter, Margaret.

Ms. Maynard said she had an affair with Mr. Salinger when she was 19 in 1972 and described several of his bizarre habits. She later auctioned off her correspondence with the author to the highest bidder, who then returned it to Mr. Salinger.

Despite the enduring popularity of "Catcher," the current generation of high schoolers are finding it a bit dated, said English teacher Jeff Miller, who has stopped teaching it in his Shady Side Academy classes.

Advertise with us

"For me, it's still a beloved text, but today, these kids are part of a group that wants to succeed. They can't accept that guy can go against the grain and reject conventional ways of getting ahead," Mr. Miller said.

"It hurt me to realize that my students simply don't have the sympathy for Holden and his situation. They ask me, 'Why doesn't he get on with his life?' so I stopped teaching it."

Alienation, a word that went into vogue in the early 1950s as inspired by the best-seller "The Lonely Crowd," is frequently applied to Holden, who narrates his story after his nervous breakdown.

Mr. Miller, however, looks at Holden in a different light. "The truth of Holden is that he sees the priorities of kissing up and accepting everything that's handed to him as symptomatic of deeper issues in our society. He questions that society."

Like his hero, Mr. Salinger questioned his society as well, and then rejected it.

Advertise with us

"Salinger rejected the whole materialism of things, the need for public confirmation," said Mr. Miller. "He had a deeper morality. He was not a sellout."

Besides his daughter, Mr. Salinger is survived by his third wife, Colleen O'Neill, and his son Matt. There will be no funeral, his literary agency said.