Religious leaders around the world have noted how the fire that ravaged the Notre Dame Cathedral occurred during Holy Week — a time when the church celebrates rebirth and salvation.

So, as workers in Paris spent Easter weekend stabilizing the damaged structure, experts in architecture and construction are looking forward to the massive rebuilding effort.

But reconstruction of the majestic, centuries-old Gothic landmark is sparking debate over whether it should involve new technologies and designs. French President Emmanuel Macron, for example, wants a “contemporary architectural gesture to be considered” for the collapsed 19th-century spire, which wasn’t part of the original cathedral. And he wants it completed in five years.

Another consideration will be incorporating modern fire-protection into a structure that is treasured, in large part, for its historic look.

Advertise with us

Robert Solomon, who grew up in Cranberry, is a director with the National Fire Protection Association in Quincy, Mass., a nonprofit group founded in 1896 devoted to eliminating death, injury, property and economic loss due to fire. A graduate of fire protection engineering at the University of Maryland, he has spent more than 30 years working to assure fire protection in historic buildings.

“It’s such a delicate balance there to provide or enhance protection features,” he said. “There’s that fine line that you’re not destroying the historic fabric while trying to include meaningful fire-protection systems or features to make it safer.”

A picture taken on April 16, 2019 shows an interior view of the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris in the aftermath of a fire that devastated the cathedral. (AFP/Getty Images)

He encountered such discussions during the renovation of Windsor Castle in the United Kingdom, which burned in 1992, and the U.S. Treasury Building in Washington after the roof of the 19th-century building caught fire in 1996.

“We have a pretty good handle in terms of the things that can go wrong and the things people can consider when they’re trying to protect a building from fire,” he said.

Mr. Solomon said fire codes in Europe differ from those in the U.S., particularly in requiring fire-prevention equipment — such as sprinklers — because European construction has tended toward the use of fire-resistant building materials such as stone, brick and steel.

Advertise with us

“Nowadays, they tend to use very little wood in most buildings,” he said. “In the U.S., we use a fair amount of wood, even in our newer buildings. And we install automatic sprinkler systems.

“In Europe, there’s this understanding that [they] can build a building out of concrete and steel and nothing in it will burn. And that’s great, but then the tenant moves in and they’re bringing in furniture, desks, chairs, wall hangings, plastic — and now it’s full of combustible contents.

“So you might think you have a church that won’t burn, but there’s wood on the floor, in the pews, up on the altar. The bottom line is you introduce combustible materials as part of the normal function of the building.”

This image shows an aerial shot of the fire damage to Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris on Tuesday, April 16, 2019. (Gigarama.ru via AP)

Mr. Solomon said that over the past 15 years or so there has been a European shift toward the U.S. model of incorporating fire-protection systems because “we know we’re not going to manufacture chairs and desks made of concrete. They’re going to be combustible and that’s what the sprinkler system helps with.”

Franck Riester, the French culture minister, said he welcomes debates about restoring the cathedral, even though the state, which owns it, will ultimately decide.

Advertise with us

Architect John Cullen, of Cullen & Associates in Friendship, has been involved in renovations at the Bellefield Presbyterian Church on the University of Pittsburgh campus in Oakland and the Fourth Presbyterian Church in Friendship, the latter after it was damaged by a fire in 2002.

“It didn’t do a lot of damage, but there was a lot of restoration that we had to do on the inside,” he said. “Those churches are in the range of 115 years old, which is old by American standards. Not in European standards.”

Mr. Cullen, a graduate of the Carnegie Mellon University school of architecture, said the key to rebuilding Notre Dame will be in the stone foundation.

“Although the walls are relatively intact, the fire will have affected the mortar in the walls,” he said. “They might have to reset some of the stone. They might have to [repair] some of the mortar. But the exterior structure, other than being charred, should be OK.”

And the roof, he said, has to be rebuilt of wood.

Advertise with us

“There’s no way you can do it and capture the grandeur and the glory of the original structure without wood,” he said. “Wood is critical to the way it looks. You could frame it in steel and cover the steel with wood, but it’s never going to look the same.

“The issue, I can assure you, when they redo it, they’re going to have to put sprinklers in. But aesthetically, nobody wants sprinklers all over the building. They’ll have to find a way to integrate the sprinklers into the structure. They have to try to make them as unobtrusive as possible.”

Eric Fisher, of Fisher ARCHitecture in Shadyside, said old buildings without new protections “is a recipe for disaster.”

“Yet these buildings have lasted literally thousands of years.”

A graduate of Harvard University’s architecture masters program, Mr. Fisher has close to 30 years’ experience, including more than 10 years running his own firm.

Advertise with us

“The miracle is that the stone structure [of Notre Dame] didn’t come down,” he said. “The stone walls actually depend on the wood ceiling to brace themselves. There’s an outward thrust from the roof in the middle, and as a result the walls are built to resist that thrust. So when that mitigating force goes away, it puts the whole structure at risk.”

A worker checks on a wooden support structure placed on the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris, Wednesday, April 17, 2019. (Francois Mori / AP)

He expects the French will be able to rebuild the cathedral on the stone foundation.

“From what I’ve seen, the stone carcass of the building is intact, but the wood and the spire — all of that is gone. So the first thing they will do is brace the existing structure to keep it from being additionally harmed. That’s going to take some weeks, with teams of engineers doing analyses to see if there’s been movement in the stone and what kind of damage has been done.

“Once they brace the thing, likely what they’ll do, they’ll begin the reconstruction of the stone, the foundation of the building. They’ll repair the stone, all of the stuff that’s outside that’s remaining. Once they have that in good structural shape they’ll do aesthetic changes to the stone. At the same time they will have tarped the roof to protect it from the weather.

“Once they have it braced and covered, then they can begin the reconstruction of the wood. There are two different ways to do this. You know they’re going to want to make it look exactly the way it looked before. But the problem is that the huge timbers that existed are no longer available anywhere in Europe. Also, if you make it literally the same, you have the risk of the same thing happening again.

Advertise with us

“The second way is to reconstruct it so it looks precisely the way it looked before, but with modern means and methods. That’s what past renovations have done. It’s called adaptive reuse versus preservation. You use methods that are hidden, and you update it so what you see is like it was before.”

Mr. Solomon said there is a long history of incorporating modern protections into the renovation of historic buildings. The National Fire Protection Association has codes for just such work.

“We try to highlight or show examples of how you can put an automatic sprinkler system in the building and make it a bit less intrusive. One way is to use copper tubing, especially in wood construction, where it tends to blend in better than steel or non-metallic piping. You retrofit with copper and people, for some reason, see it as having more character. That’s one of the things that people get used to.”

Mr. Solomon said the U.S. government “has been pretty robust for 20, 25 years now” about installing sprinklers in existing federal office buildings. All of the Smithsonian buildings, for example, are protected.

“In America, you don’t have as much pushback from those opposed to modernization,” he said. “Besides, you can do things that you can see, but it’s very unobtrusive. The exposed parts, you can color match or match the texture. There are so many ways to get this stuff to blend in nowadays.

Advertise with us

“I hope that the French government and the church don’t consider putting a sprinkler system around the wood as being a compromise. It’s a piece of insurance. Some copper tubing might be visible to the public, but I really don’t think the public is going to be upset about that.”

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.

Correction, posted April 22, 2019: An earlier version of this story included an incorrect last name for Robert Solomon.