
Theodore Roosevelt’s muscular presidency positioned America to leap to the forefront of the world’s powers during the early 20th century. Bluff, cheerful, endlessly energetic and optimistic, he seemed the embodiment of the American spirit.
In reality, he suffered from bouts of deep depression and a lifetime of health problems, but his public image captured an infectious part of him that led the country to flex its muscles on the international stage.
THE LOVES OF THEODORE ROOSEVELT: THE WOMEN WHO CREATED A PRESIDENT
By Edward F. O’Keefe
Simon & Schuster ($30)
The Panama Canal, the establishment of the U.S. national parks system, the beginnings of environmentalism and the formation of the Food and Drug Administration all constitute Roosevelt’s legacy. He was a Republican who was also, in the parlance of the time, a “progressive” who believed in a “Square Deal” for the common person and for business. He favored women’s rights and Black rights, won a Nobel Peace Prize for mediating the end of the Russo-Japanese War and sought to regulate monopolistic “trusts.”
Meanwhile, he wrote best-selling nonfiction books, at least one of which — “The Naval War of 1812,” written when he was 23 —is still regarded as a leading work in its field.
Perhaps the key mystery and tragedy of his life concerns his wives. He married Alice Lee, then 19, on his 22nd birthday. She died of kidney failure four years later and two days after giving birth to their only child. His mother had died of typhoid just hours before.
Famously, Theodore drew a large “X” in his diary entry for that day and wrote below, “The light has gone out of my life.”
He later married his childhood playmate Edith Kermit Carow, whom everyone had expected him to marry before he met Alice.
Author Edward F. O’Keefe, CEO of the Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library Foundation and a broadcaster at ABC News and CNN, winner of an Edward R. Murrow Award and a George Foster Peabody Award, has penned a new book on Roosevelt, “The Loves of Theodore Roosevelt: The Women Who Created a President,” due out on May 7.
O’Keefe brings to light new letters and lost love poems as well as a secret keepsake of Alice Lee that Theodore kept without Edith’s knowledge.
The author tries hard to dispel the common conception of Alice as a beautiful and superficial socialite who had no impact on her husband’s ideas.
The historical record gives him little help here. Few of Alice’s letters have survived the decades. What ones have lasted shed only dim light on their author. They are filled with cheerful phrases and wishes, not deep thoughts.
His letters to her are more telling, revealing that he tested ideas on her and began to hone his views on policy in talking with her. His devotion to her seems not to have dimmed in four years of marriage.
O’Keefe’s thesis that Alice was the great power behind Theodore’s early success, and that her ideas on policy shaped his for the remainder of his life, seems more wishful thinking than adequately supported by the record. The most that can be said, at least from what is presented here, is that her husband trusted and loved her, and that she was a good sounding board and hostess, outgoing, generous and athletic. Whether her political skills rivaled those of Theodore’s second wife or sisters is unclear.
O’Keefe focuses on these and other women behind Roosevelt’s ascendance, including his mother and, to a lesser extent, his daughter by his first marriage, Alice Roosevelt Longworth.
His sisters unquestionably contributed to his political success, particularly Anna “Bamie” Roosevelt Cowles. A behind-the-scenes operator, she arranged introductions and counseled courses of action.
But his second wife commands the most attention. O’Keefe paints her as regal and observant, filled with insight and good advice. “Whenever I go against [Edith’s] judgment I regret it,” her husband said.
Edith tried hard to stay just beyond the reach of history, remorselessly burning letters and choosing carefully what to make public. “Just as the camera is focused, she steps aside to avoid the click of the shutter,” one Washington neighbor remarked.
Formidable, jealous and controlling might also describe her. The book makes clear that she could be cold to her children, casually racist and given to making stinging remarks.
On her stepdaughter’s wedding day, Edith told her, “I want you to know that I’m glad to see you leave. You have never been anything but trouble.” Edith had no trouble letting her stepdaughter know that “it was just as well that [her] mother had died” and that had Alice Lee lived, she would have “driven [Theodore] to suicide from sheer boredom.”
Though publicly progressive on Black rights, Edith, in a letter, used the short form of a racist slur to refer to some young Black schoolchildren.
Of her own children, she said, “I like to see their little faces, but I prefer to see their backs.”
Not surprisingly, this book reads well and keeps the reader engaged. It needed another pass through the editor’s desk to squeeze out some of the repetitive detail, such as overuse of the phrase “Teedie and Edie.”
Still, the language is beautiful, especially in the beginning, and seeing Theodore’s life through the lens of his female family members gives it an intimacy sorely missed in many other biographies.
Laura Malt Schneiderman is an Assignment Editor and Interactive Developer for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. She is co-author of the book “Kaufmann’s: The Family That Built Pittsburgh’s Famed Department Store.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.