Although it wasn't officially Barenaked Ladies Day in Pittsburgh -- it does have possibilities, though, doesn't it? -- Ed Robertson seemed to have key to the city on Tuesday.
BNL and tour partners Violent Femmes got a private tour of the Andy Warhol Museum, and then Robertson was at PNC Park to throw out the first pitch at the Pirates game.
"And later on," inserted drummer Tyler Stewart, "we're going to get massages from Sidney Crosby and Geno Malkin, and we're doing it in Mario Lemieux's wine cellar."
That part was a joke. Barenaked Ladies, who played Stage AE Outdoors Tuesday, are good at those. As good at it as they are at music. Maybe even better. They certainly do a fine job of localizing a show on the spot. Robertson worked in raps about his Pirates pitch and about the Mon and the Allegheny forming the Ohio, and he did a good five minutes of Kennywood-themed standup.
The clever has long spilled into the music of the Canadian goof-rock band, starting with the name. What wasn't funny was when singer-guitarist Steven Page left the band in 2009 after a drug arrest.
BNL has carried on admirably, with three more albums since then, mainly appealing to its cult following. Robertson, who could hold his own in a George Clooney lookalike contest, always had the smaller vocal role in BNL, and now does a solid job as the lead, although you do miss Page's nasally voice on songs like "Brian Wilson.“
The show is less about dazzling musicianship and amazing songs than comedy, fun and fan participation. Robertson has special tactics for accomplishing the latter. "Look around, folks,“ he said on ”Gonna Walk.“ ”Anyone who is not singing along on the choruses ... is a racist."
The Kennywood bit came as the intro to new song "Toe to Toe." "I'm a little bit upset with you," he told the fans. "We've been coming here for decades and no one mentioned Kennywood to us. I had no idea you had such a gem in your backyard. Are you trying to keep it from the tourists?"
"I contend it may be one of the greatest theme parks," he added. "There is nothing like riding a roller coaster that you're certain has been out of warranty for 75 years!"
BNL summoned opening act Colin Hay to the stage twice, for "Pinch Me" and for a cool cover of Men at Work's "Who Can It Be Now?" -- although Femmes saxophonist Blaise Garza did not join in, as he has on the tour. One of the BNL guys speculated that he might be busy getting a private tour of the Aviary.
They sampled new album "Silverball" with a handful of songs, including bouncy synth-pop tune "Duct Tape Heart." Between their peppy "Big Bang Theory Theme" and "One Week," Robertson did a hilarious bit, improvising a song using messages from the red LED sign on Mount Washington about donating blood, wearing seatbelts and the time.
They closed the set in spirited fashion with "1,000,000" and a goofy medley of covers ranging from "I'm Not The Only One" and "Shake It Off" to "Take Me To Church" and "Bohemian Rhapsody." Fans do go nuts over that one.
For the encore, Robertson took the drums so that Stewart could step out and take over the top with rollicking versions of "Drawing" and Led Zeppelin's "Rock and Roll."
Earlier, Robertson gave props to the middle act: "We owe a lot to the Violent Femmes. I don't think we could play like that if it wasn't for them."
Perhaps. But the edgier Femmes are a whole other deal. Thirty years later, their songs don't seem any less demented than the day we first heard them. In a middle slot between two artists of different genres and cultures, the Femmes came out and got "Blister in the Sun" out of the way, almost defiantly, with the first song.
This wasn't one of their wild, “slam-dancing” affairs like back in the day, but the crowd was definitely on board and knew the words to the biggies like "Gone Daddy Gone" and "Kiss Off."
Frontman Gordon Gano, dressed as if for a family cookout in baggie khaki shorts, sounds the same as ever and delivers the songs with a bemused smirk.
Two new songs, "Good For/At Nothing" and "Love Love Love Love Love," were enough like vintage Femmes to fit into the set. In his pitch for people to buy the new four-song EP at the merch stand, he admitted, "the other two aren't any better" in quality. Just about the same.
One thing you didn't see at a Femmes show in the early ’80s was a dad with a young daughter. You could sense the little girl’s confusion when Gano spun the dark narrative to "Country Death Song," a banjo tune about a man throwing his lovely daughter into well. At least, she was spared "Gimme the Car," which has been on recent set lists.
New drummer Brian Viglione (of Dresden Dolls) certainly re-energized the veteran Milwaukee trio, as did the added horns, percussion and cameos from BNL members Kevin Hearn on accordion and Jim Creeggan on bass. The wildest jazzy breakdown came on "Black Girls," a song that doesn’t meet today’s PC standard -- and didn’t really in 1984, either.
Gano and company saved his best for last, rocking hardest on "Add It Up," a song that sounds even more disturbing in these days of deranged loners with guns.
Hay opened with a basic coffeehouse-style set on acoustic guitar, occasionally flashing some of that elastic vocal range from his former days. He promised to play "songs from my old band, just in case you're saying 'Who was THAT guy?'" One that brought a cheer was "Down Under," offered as a more somber folk song with some echo effects.
He introduced new song "I Just Don't Think I'll Ever Get Over You" as having a chorus built for radio, and he was totally right.
Of course, we all know radio doesn’t want songs from these guys anymore. You have to see them live, and this borderline nostalgia package did a good job of emphasizing the “live” part.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576. Twitter: @scottmervis_pg





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.